Power lines and the public perception

(1)

! " # $% " $% &

' ## (

! !

"

# $%& $'&

! (

) *

+

)

,

! , -.. !/ 0 12.. !/ 30

) ( * +'

/ + 4 ( % ( % +

5 "" ,-.. / / * *0 #

!

"#$ $ #% $ & :

(2)

. # 1 2

% ' (

(

) 7

) +%%% 288 6998 :6; +%0

26<=25699= :>; !

( '? %?

$ &

@/

+ )

2 $4/ &

) 3

, $A/&

( !

$/B& !

! ,

( C

+ * $C+*& +

$/ &

$BD& $/B&5

, (1)

# ) $A/&

* 5

(

! )

(3)

> $+*B& ) $>&

(2)

(

'

2 $/+&

,

! -.. !/ 0 $ ( 6 E

8& 2.. !/ 30 ( > - +

30

[image:3.612.91.562.293.709.2]

+ '

Figure 1 - HVAC Towers 500 kV Figure 2 - HVDC Tower 600 Kv

Figure 3 - Typical Design Tower 500 kV

Typical Design$ 3&

0 5 EE

-0 6. =

5 8> E

3 5 >2

? F 5 <9

Figure 4 - Cross Rope Suspension 500 kV

0 ? $0?&

0 5 EE

-0 6. =

5 86

-3 5 68

(4)

[image:4.612.89.554.64.198.2]

Figure 5 - HVDC CC 600 kV

@/30

0 5 E< 8

0 5 6. =

5 82 .

3 5 6- 8

(

68.. 6>.. 4F ( @/30

68..

+ !

! +

!

4 % 5

6 5 7% 2 $ 5

)

6 +0G+?B :E; :8;

! :-; :2;

Table I – Maximum levels of electric and magnetic fields.

4 4

+0G+?B :E; +0G+?B :8; :-; :2;

% ( :!/" ; - - E$H&

4 ( :I ; 6.. >.. >-$H&

$H& ? F $?#F&

6 ' 5 ? @ +0G+?B :<;7 8.. . -( +0G+?B

/ % $8

? *% <<"699= :E; %

[image:4.612.106.512.464.543.2]

(5)

8 5

/

B

#

5 )

(

'

9 %

( 2 3 ( < 0?

( @/30 !

+0G+?B

[image:5.612.118.492.388.525.2]

% 0?

Figure 6 – Electric Field TD Figure 7 - Electric Field CR

#

( = 3 ( 9 0? (

(6)

[image:6.612.68.517.68.205.2]

) " * $

Figure 8 - MagneticField TD Figure 96 – MagneticField CR Figure 70 - MagneticField HVDC

4 0?

?

( 2.. !/ 30

+0G+?B

/ % $8

)

/ 5 * !

+ $/B&

5 !

7 !

) +

!

+ #/ 5 0

$4/ &

( 66 )

(7)

2

a) Neighbouring observers b) Initial visibility (VA)

c) Sharpness Correction (VA x PL) d) Visibility from residential areas (VA x PL x VP)

% .. * J

% :/

+ 0/5 + !

#

) $A/&

( 6E K ( 68

)

(8)

)

Figure 13 - Landscape units identified Figure 14 - Quality of Landscape map of landscape units.

' 5 D

0 $4/ & ) $A/&

(

6-* "( +, #Landscape sensibility Map.

/ 5 + '

( 62 '

[image:8.612.96.532.97.248.2] [image:8.612.169.445.355.547.2]

(9)

= * "( - #Visual Impact for line route 1 and 2.

! (

3 6

C

F ) 7

7 !

7

?

! 5

/ + % 4 (

3 4₄

4

@ % 4

4

0? *

4 4

D % 4

0

@/30 D D

@ G %

(10)

; %

(

0?

+

+0G+?B 30

30

! +

) )

( ! ,

F ,

*! <(

:6; +%%% * 288 4 6998 $?>..=& +%%% * B 4 B

( ) % 4 ( ( 0 B D

:>; +%0 26<=25699= 4 )

* )

:E; C D % / % 4

% ( $ E.. C@ & +0G+?B 699=

:8; C D % / % 4 ( $6 @

6.. L@ & +0G+?B >.6.

:-; ? M *% <<"9= * N % N G M $ & ' N #

GO >= =-9 6P * M

:2; ? M %G?% .-82"6999 % G ? % $ &

' N # GO >9 6E- 6<

:<; C D % * 4 ( +0G+?B >..9

:=; 0+C?Q ' E=E * 3 B +