Preprint of the paper
"A general numerical model for grounding analysis in layered soils" I. Colominas, J. Gómez-Calviño, F. Navarrina, M. Casteleiro (2000)
En "Computational Civil and Structural Engineering", 209---216; G. De Roeck, B.H.V. Topping (Editors); Civil-Comp Press, Edinburgh, UK. (ISBN: 0-948749-73-3)
V peWeiVN W=eiy]VN !*eN 3!i pi!=W*yWp
VWVNO7y7 yW NVOeie* 7!yN7
y ]BjB8$tsR F p?B89T]sj%$KtB 3 Ws%s$ts stI ]sRj$B
V}}j$I sY8s${R *}s8t ]$%$j et$t$t 7{YBBj
=t$%R$k BP ]BZtts 7_VyW
VARs{
qY RsPk BP Y }RBtR Y }B{$Bt BP Y JZ$}8t stI Y {Bt$tZ$k BP Y }Bb RZ}}jk s Y 8s$t BA`{T $%R BP Y BZtI$t RkR8 BP s js j{${sj $tRsjT js$Bt 3B $R s{{Zs IR$t $ $R RRt$sj B I8$t Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt Bt sY RZPs{ stI Y JZ$%T sjt R$Rst{ BP Y RkR8 yt Y$R }s} b }Rt s tZ8${sj s}}Bs{Y AsRI Bt Y BZtIsk ej8t 8YBI PB BZtI$t stsjkR$R $t jskI RB$jR qY PsR$T A$j$k BP Y$R PB8Zjs$Bt $R I$R{ZRRI b$Y $R s}}j${s$Bt B s sj BZtI$t RkR8 8AIII $t I$&t ,$tIR BP jskI RB$j 8BIjR
d ytBIZ{$Bt
7$t{ Y sjk IskR BP Y $tIZR$sj ZR BP Y j{${$k BAs$t$t Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt $t js j{${sj $tT Rsjjs$BtR }BIZ{I bYt s PsZj {Zt $R I$%I $tB Y RB$j wYBZY s R$tj {BtIZ{B B s 8RY BP Y8U s BZtI$t $ID YsR At s {Ysjjt$t }BAj8 VtI Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt Bt sY RZPs{ $R b$YBZ IBZA Y 8BR $8}Bst }ss8 Ys $ $R t{RRsk B ,tBb $t BI B IR$t s RsP BZtI$t RkR8 V XBZtIT $t" B XsY$t" RkR8 {B8}$RR sjj $t{Btt{I BZtI$t Ps{$j$$R BP st R}{$h{ ss BP st j{${sj $tT Rsjjs$Bt A$t Y XBZtI$t $I" wB Y XBZtII j{BI"D Y 8s$t j8t BP YR RkR8R
yt 8BR BP sj j{${sj RZARs$BtR Y BZtI$t $I {BtR$RR BP s 8RY BP $t{Btt{I {kj$tI${sj {BtIZ{T BR YB$9Btsjjk AZ$I stI RZ}}j8tI Ak BZtI BIR %${sjjk YZRI $t {s$t }js{R BP Y RZARsT $Bt R$ yR 8s$t BA`{$% $R B {sk stI I$RR$}s j{T ${sj {ZtR }BIZ{I IZ$t PsZj {BtI$$BtR $tB Y BZtI $t BI B tRZ Ys s }RBt $t Y %${$t$k BP Y BZtII $tRsjjs$Bt $R tB -}BRI B s {$${sj j{T ${sj RYB{, stI B sRRZ Y }Bb RZ}}jk {Bt$tZ$k stI Y $t$k BP Y JZ$}8t qB ss$t YR BsjR Y s}}st j{${sj R$Rst{ BP Y BZtI$t RkR8 8ZR A jBb tBZY B Zsst Ys PsZj {ZtR I$RR$T }s 8s$tjk YBZY Y BZtI$t j{BI $tB Y RB$j bY$j j{${sj }Bt$sj %sjZR Abt {jBR }B$tR Bt
Y sY RZPs{ Ys {st A {Btt{I Ak s }RBt 8ZR A ,} ZtI {s$t 8s-$8Z8 RsP j$8$R wR} BZ{Y stI 8RY %BjsRD RsAj$RYI $t 8BR BP Y Z$IR stI jsj }B{IZR BP BZtI$t RkR8 IR$t>d 1H
7$t{ Y R$-$R R%sj 8YBIR stI }B{IZR PB Y BZtI$t stsjkR$R stI IR$t BP j{${sj RZARs$BtR Ys% At }B}BRI qYR 8YBIR tsjjk AsRI Bt Y }BPRR$Btsj }s{${ Bt R8$T8}$${sj bB,R Bt -T }$8tsj Iss BAs$tI PB8 R{sj 8BIj sRRskR B Bt $tZ$$% $IsR }RtI st $8}Bst $8}B%8t $t Y BZtI$t stsjkR$R ss <Bb% RB8 }BAT j8R Ys% At }BI RZ{Y sR js {B8}Zs$Btsj T JZ$8tR Ztsj$R${ RZjR bYt R8ts$Bt BP {BtT IZ{BR $R $t{sRI stI Zt{s$tk $t Y 8s$t BP B>d nH
eJZs$BtR B%t$t Y }YkR${sj }YtB8ts BP Y j{T ${sj {Zt I$RR$}s$Bt $tB s RB$j s bjjT,tBbt stI {st A RsI PB8 s-bjj:R ej{B8st${ qYBk W%YjRR Y$ s}}j${s$Bt stI RBjZ$Bt PB Y {B8T }Z$t BP BZtI$t $IR BP js $tRsjjs$BtR $t }s{${sj {sRR }Rt RB8 I$^{Zj$R !A%$BZRjk tB stsjk${sj RBjZ$BtR {st A BAs$tI $t s sj }BAj8 3ZY8B Y {Yss{$R${ B8k BP Y BZtI$t RkR8R ws 8RY BP $t{Btt{I As {BtIZ{BR b$Y s s$B I$T s8\jtY js$%jk R8sjjD 8s,R %k I$^{Zj Y ZR BP tZ8${sj {Yt$JZR {B88Btjk ZRI PB Y RBT jZ$Bt BP ABZtIsk %sjZ }BAj8R wRZ{Y sR ht$ j8tR B ht$ I$&t{RD R$t{ Y I$R{$9s$Bt BP Y IB8s$t wY BZtID $R JZ$I yt YR {sRR BAs$t$t RZ^T {$tjk s{{Zs RZjR RYBZjI $8}jk Zts{{}sAj {B8T }Z$t &BR $t 88Bk RBs stI ]_= $8
1 sY8s${sj BIj BP Y _BAj8
1d pB%t$t eJZs$BtR BP Y _BAj8
VR b Ys% -}BRI $t Y $tBIZ{$Bt JZs$BtR bY${Y B%t Y I$RR$}s$Bt BP j{${sj {Zt $tB Y BZtI YBZY s BZtII j{BI {st A RsI Ak 8stR BP s-bjj:R ej{B8st${ qYBk qYZR R${$t Y stsjkR$R B Y j{B,$t${ RsIkTRs R}BtR stI tj{$t Y $tt R$R$%$k BP Y sY$t {BtIZ{BR wYt }Bt$sj $R sRRZ8I {BtRst $t %k }B$t BP Y BZtI$t j{BI RZPs{D Y n* }BAj8 {st A b$T t sR
I$%wD ) (, )sIsIwsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsI ~D $to
0zzzzzzzzzzzzzz
o) ( $t o ~ )~ $t
~ (, $P/??????????????/ wdD
bY o $R Y sY $R $R {BtIZ{$%$k tRB o $R
Y sY RZPs{zzzzzzzzzzzzzzo$R $R tB8sj -$B Zt$ hjI stI
$R Y j{BI RZPs{ >xH
qYPB bYt Y BZtII j{BI ss$tR s %Bjs
~ wpBZtI _Bt$sj i$R B p_iD js$% B s 8B
sY Y RBjZ$Bt B }BAj8 wdD $%R }Bt$sj ~ stI
{Zt ItR$ks st sA$sk }B$t?????????????? qYt $ $R }BRT R$Aj B BAs$t Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt Bt sY RZPs{ wstI {BtRJZtjk Y R} 8RY stI BZ{Y %BjsR BP Y sY$t RkR8D stI Y Bsj RZ {Zt stI Y
JZ$%sjt R$Rst{ Ak 8stR BP Y {Zt ItR$k
Bt >d 1H !t Y BY YstI R$t{ ~ stIs }B}BT
$Btsj B Y p_i %sjZ $ b$jj A ZRI Y tB8sj$9I
ABZtIsk {BtI$$Bt~) d PB8 Y Bt
yt 8stk BP Y 8YBIR stI YB${sj }B{IZR }BT }BRI PB BZtI$t stsjkR$R Y RB$j $R {B88Btjk {BtT
R$II YB8BtBZR stI $RBB}${ qYt {BtIZ{$%$k
$R RZAR$ZI Ak st s}}st R{sjs {BtIZ{$%$k Ys
8ZR A -}$8tsjjk BAs$tI>dH !A%$BZRjk Y$R YkT }BYR$R IBR tB $tBIZ{ R$t$h{st BR $P Y RB$j $R RRt$sjjk Zt$PB8 $t sjj I${$BtR $t Y %${$t$k BP Y BZtI$t $I>dH stI Y$R 8BIj {st A ZRI b$Y jBRR BP s{{Zs{k $P Y RB$j R$R$%$k {YstR Rj$Yjk b$Y I}Y W%YjRR R$t{ RsPk }ss8R $t%Bj%I $t Y BZtI$t IR$t {st R$t$h{stjk %sk $P Y RB$j j{T ${sj }B}$R {Yst YBZY Y RZARs$Bt R$ wPB -s8}j IZ B {YstR BP Y 8s$sj tsZ B Y YZ8$I$k BP Y RB$jD $ R8R sI%$RsAj B I%jB} 8B sI%st{I 8BIjR Ys {BZjI s, $tB s{{BZt %s$s$BtR BP Y RB$j {BtIZ{$%$k $t Y RZBZtI$tR BP Y j{$T {sj $tRsjjs$Bt
y $R BA%$BZR Ys B s, $tB s{{BZt sjj Y %s$s$BtR BP Y RB$j {BtIZ{$%$k bBZjI t% A s&BIsAj t$T Y PB8 Y {BtB8${sj tB PB8 Y {Yt${sj }B$t BP %$b 3B Y$R sRBt s 8B }s{${sj RB$j 8BIj }BT }BRI {BtR$RR BP sRRZ8$t Y RB$j Rs$hI $t s tZ8A BP YB$9Btsj B %${sj jskR IhtI Ak st s}}B}$T s Y${,tRR stI st s}}st R{sjs {BtIZ{$%$k Ys
8ZR A -}$8tsjjk BAs$tI yt Ps{ $ $R b$Ijk s{T {}I Ys bBTjsk RB$j 8BIjR RYBZjI A RZ^{$t B BAs$t BBI stI RsP IR$tR BP BZtI$t RkR8R $t 8BR }s{${sj {sRR>dH qY$R }s} $R I%BI B RZIk$t Y s}}j${s$Bt BP tZ8${sj 8YBIR PB BZtI$t stsjkR$R $t Rs$hI RB$j 8BIjR stI R}{$sjjk $t {sRR b$Y bB I$&t YB$9Btsj B %${sj jskR whZR d stI 1D
γ
12
γ
3$Z d 7{Y8 BP s RB$j 8BIj b$Y bB YB$9Btsj jskR
γ
2γ
13$Z 1 7{Y8 BP s RB$j 8BIj b$Y bB %${sj jskR
qYPB $t Y Yk}BYR$R BP s Rs$hI RB$j 8BIj PB8I Akg jskR b$Y I$&t {BtIZ{$%$$R stI Y
BZtII j{BI AZ$I $t Y jsk K Y 8sY8sT
${sj }BAj8 wdD {st A b$t $t 8R BP Y PBjjBb$t WZ8stt -$B }BAj8>H
I$%wD ) (, )sIsIwsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsI ~D $t o, dg
0
ezzzzzzzzzzzzzzo) ( $t o, ~K) d $t
~( $P/??????????????/ , 0zzzzzzzzzzzzzz)0Ldzzzzzzzzzzzzzz $t ,
dgd w1D
bY o $R s{Y Bt BP Y RB$j jskR $R $R R{sjs
{BtIZ{$%$k ~ $R Y }Bt$sj s st sA$sk }B$t BP
jsk o $R $R {BR}BtI$t {Zt ItR$k $R
Y $tPs{ Abt jskR o stI oLd stI zzzzzzzzzzzzzz $R Y
tB8sj hjI B >H
11 ytsj e-}RR$Bt PB _Bt$sj
~Y s$B Abt Y I$s8 stI Y jtY BP Y {BtT
IZ{BR js$%jk R8sjj wd(nD qY$R s}}stjk R$8}j
B8k $8}j$R R$BZR I$^{Zj$R $t Y 8BIjj$9s$Bt BP Y }BAj8 R$t{ $ R8R BA%$BZR Ys tB stsjk$T {sj RBjZ$BtR {st A BAs$tI $t sj {sRR stI Y ZR BP RstIsI tZ8${sj {Yt$JZR bY${Y s b$IR}sI ZRI PB RBj%$t ABZtIsk %sjZ }BAj8R wRZ{Y sR 3e B 3*D RYBZjI $t%Bj% s {B8}jjk BZ BP st {B8T }Z$t &B R$t{ $ $R JZ$I Y I$R{$9s$Bt BP Y
n* IB8s$tRo 3B YR sRBtR b Ys% ZtI BZ sT
t$Bt B BY tZ8${sj {Yt$JZR bY${Y JZ$ Btjk Y I$R{$9s$Bt BP Y ABZtIs$R BP Y }BAj8 3B Y$R hR BP sjj $ $R RRt$sj B I$% st $tsj -}RT
R$Bt PB }Bt$sj~ $t 8R BP Zt,tBbtR IhtI Bt Y
ABZtIsk>xH
*Z$t Y {BtRZ{$Bt }B{RR BP Y j{${sj $tRsjT js$Bt Y RZBZtI$tR BP Y RZARs$Bt R$ s j%T
jjI stI Zjs$9I qYZR sY RZPs{ o stI $tT
Ps{R Abt jskR {st A sRRZ8I YB$9Btsj {BtT
RJZtjk b b$jj sIB} st XYB$9Btsj jsk RB$j 8BIj" $t BZ 8sY8s${sj 8BIj $t BI B {s{Y Y %s$sT $BtR BP Y RB$j {BtIZ{$%$k b$Y I}Y whZ dD yt Y {sR BP YB$9Btsj %s$s$BtR BP Y RB$j {BtIZ{$%$k ts Y BZtI$t RkR8 Y R$8}jR 8BIj b {st Rs ws X%${sj jsk RB$j 8BIj"D $R B sRRZ8 Ys Y sY
RZPs{ o $R YB$9Btsj stI Ys Y $tPs{R s
}}tI${Zjs B o stI }ssjjj s8Bt Y8 whZ 1D
qYZR s,$t $tB s{{BZt YR sRRZ8}$BtR Y s}}j${sT $Bt BP Y X8YBI BP $8sR" stI Y pt:R yIt$k B }BAj8 w1D k$jIR Y PBjjBb$t $tsj -}RR$Bt>H PB }Bt$sj ~w??????????????D s st sA$sk }B$t ?????????????? ;o $t 8R
BP Y Zt,tBbt js,s {Zt ItR$k wD w )0zzzzzzzzzzzzzz
bY zzzzzzzzzzzzzz $R Y tB8sj -$B Zt$ hjI B D s stk
}B$t BP Y j{BI RZPs{ 2oKU
~w??????????????D ) ;$d K
8 8
;>Kw??????????????, DwDQ, ?????????????? ;o, wnD
bY $tsj ,tjR >Kw??????????????, D s PB8I Ak R$R BP
$tht$ 8R {BR}BtI$t B Y RZjst $8sR BAT s$tI bYt WZ8stt -$B }BAj8 w1D $R stRPB8I $tB s *$${Yj Bt> H *}tI$t Bt Y k} BP Y RB$j 8BIj ZRI YR R$R {st Ys% st $tht$ B s ht$
tZ8A BP 8R yt Y {sR BP Zt$PB8 8BIj wg ) dD
Yk s IZ{I B Btjk bB RZ88stIR R$t{ Y $R Btjk Bt $8s BP Y B$$tsj $I>; xHU
>ddw??????????????d, D ) w?????????????? d
d,>?, r, FHDL
d
w??????????????d,>?, r,FHD, w;D
bY w??????????????d,>?, r, FHD $tI${sR Y I$Rst{ PB8??????????????d B
#>?, r, FH vstI B $R Rk88${ }B$t b$Y R}{
B Y sY RZPs{ ov y $R sRRZ8I Ys Y B$$t
BP Y {BBI$tsR RkR8 $R Bt Y sY RZPs{ stI Y
FTs-$R $R }}tI${Zjs B o
yt Y {sR BP s bBTjsk %${sj 8BIj whZ 1D Y R$R BP Y ,tjR s sjRB IZ{I B s ht$ tZ8A BP
8RU
>ddw??????????????d, D ) w?????????????? d
d,>?, r, FHDL
d
w??????????????d,>?, r,FHD
L
w??????????????d,>?,r, FHDL
w??????????????d,>?,r,FHD,
>d1w??????????????1, D ) w?????????????? d L
1,>?, r, FHDL
d L
w??????????????1,>?, r,FHD,
wxD
bY w??????????????,>?, r, FHD $tI${sR Y I$Rst{ PB8 ?????????????? B
#>?, r, FH vstI B $R Rk88${ }B$t b$Y R}{
B Y sY RZPs{ o stI Y RZjst $8sR b$Y
R}{ B Y %${sj $tPs{v y $R sRRZ8I Ys Y B$$t BP Y {BBI$tsR RkR8 $R Bt Y sY RZPs{
stI Bt Y %${sj $tPs{ stI Y FTs-$R stI rTs-$R
s }}tI${Zjs B o stI d R}{$%jk ]B^{$t
$R s s$B IhtI $t 8R BP Y jsk {BtIZ{$%$$R
) d1
dL13 wED
yt Y {sR BP st YB$9Btsj bB jsk RB$j 8BIj whZ dD Y -}RR$BtR BP Y $tsj ,tjR s $%t Ak
>ddw??????????????d, D ) 3
7)(
7
w??????????????d,>?, r,17ILFHD
L3
7)(
7
w??????????????d,>?, r,17IFHD
L3
7)d
7
w??????????????d,>?, r,17ILFHD
L3
7)d
7
w??????????????d,>?, r,17IFHD
>d1w??????????????1, D ) 3
7)(
wd LD7
w??????????????1,>?, r,17ILFHD
L3
7)(
wd LD7
w??????????????1,>?, r,17IFHD
>1dw??????????????d, D ) 3
7)(
wdD7
w??????????????d,>?, r,17ILFHD
L3
7)(
wdD7
w??????????????d,>?, r,17IFHD
>11w??????????????1, D ) w?????????????? d
1,>?, r, FHD
w??????????????1,>?, r,1ILFHD
L3
7)(
wd1D7
w??????????????1,>?, r,17ILFHD wD
yt Y sAB% -}RR$BtRw??????????????,>?, r, FHD $tI${sR Y I$RT
st{ PB8 ?????????????? B # >?, r, FH vstI B Y Rk88${
}B$tR stI $8sR BP b$Y R}{ B Y sY RZPs{
o stI B Y $t}Ys{ RZPs{ Abt jskRvI $R
Y Y${,tRR BP Y Z}} jsk stI$R $%t Ak wED y
$R sRRZ8I Ys Y B$$t BP Y {BBI$tsR RkR8 $R Bt Y sY RZPs{ stI YFTs-$R $R }}tI${Zjs B o
VR b {st BAR% $t -}RR$BtR w;D wxD stI wD bs,jk R$tZjs ,tj >Kw??????????????, D I}tIR Bt Y {BtIZ{$%$k BP
}B$t ?????????????? B Y }B$t stI B sjj Y $8sR BP b$Y
R}{ B Y sY RZPs{ o stI B Y $tPs{R
Abt jskR> H 3B Zt$PB8 stI bBTjsk RB$j 8BIT jR YR ,tjR {st A -}RRI $t Y tsj PB8U
>Kw??????????????, D ) q>
3
q)(
>q
Kw??????????????, D, >Kq w??????????????, D ) qwD
w??????????????, qwDD, wMD
bY q $R s b$Y$t {B^{$t Ys Btjk I}tIR Bt
s$B IhtI Ak wED stI w??????????????, qwDD $R Y eZ{j$Ist
I$Rst{ Abt Y }B$tR??????????????stIq A$t+ Y }B$t
Bt Y j{BI RZPs{ w+wD ) D bY q wq W)
(D s Y $8sR BP b$Y R}{ B Y sY RZPs{
stI B Y $tPs{R Abt jskR>H q> $R Y tZ8A
BP RZ88stIR $t Y R$R BP Y $tsj ,tjR stI $ I}tIR Bt Y {sR stsjk9I wR w;D wxD stI wDD
1n zs$s$Btsj 3B8 BP Y _BAj8
qY $tsj -}RR$Bt PB Y }Bt$sj wnD $R sjRB Rs$RT hI Bt j{BI RZPs{ bY }Bt$sj %sjZ $R ,tBbt
Ak Y ABZtIsk {BtI$$Bt ~KwD ) d ; ]BtRT
JZtjk js,s {Zt ItR$k 8ZR %$Pk Y PBjjBbT
$t 3IYBj8 $tsj JZs$Bt BP Y hR ,$tI Bt d
;$K 88
;>KKw, DwDQ ) d, ;3 wD
y $R $8}Bst B 8s, Ys BAs$t$t Y js,s {ZT t ItR$k PB8 $R Y ,k BP Y }BAj8 R$t{ Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt }BIZ{I bYt s PsZj {Zt $R IT $%I YBZY Y BZtI$t $I {st A sR$jk BAs$tI
Ak ZR$t stI -}RR$Bt wnD !Y RsPk stI IR$t
}ss8R wRZ{Y sR Y JZ$%sjt R$Rst{ stI Y BT
sj RZ {ZtD {st A I${jk {B8}ZI PB8>xH
qY sAB% JZs$Bt {st A b$t $t s %s$s$Btsj PB8 $P Bt $8}BRR Ys wD $R %$hI $t Y RtR BP b$YI R$IZsjR $ Y PBjjBb$t $tsj $It$k
88
;jwD
X
d ;$K
88
;>KKw, DwDQd ~
Q ) (,
wd(D 8ZR YBjI PB sjj 88ARjwD BP s RZ$sAj {jsRR BP R PZt{$BtR IhtI Bt >; xH WBb $ $R {js Ys s tZT 8${sj s}}Bs{Y AsRI Bt Y BZtIsk ej8t YBI R8R B A Y AR {YB${ B RBj% JZs$Bt wd(D stI B
BAs$t Y js,s {Zt ItR$k R$t{ $R RBjZ$Bt
JZ$R Y I$R{$9s$Bt BP Y IB8s$t w$ Y RZPs{ BP Y {kj$tI${sj {BtIZ{BRD
n e WZ8${sj 3B8Zjs$Bt
nd ptsj 1* s}}Bs{Y
qY js,s {Zt ItR$kstI Y j{BI RZPs{
{st A I$R{$9I sR
wD )
[ 3
7)d
7]7wD, ) &
)d
, wddD
PB $%t RR BP [ $sj PZt{$BtR\]7wDiIhtI Bt
stI &bB I$8tR$Btsj ABZtIsk j8tR\i
W-$tsj -}RR$Bt wnD PB }Bt$sj ~w??????????????D {st sjRB A
I$R{$9I sR
~w??????????????D ) [ 3
7)d
7~,7w??????????????D ~,7w??????????????D ) & 3 )d q~ 3 q)( ~q ,7w??????????????D
wd1D
~q
,7w??????????????D ) ;$d K
88
;>
q
Kw??????????????, D]7wDQ wdnD
bY q~ }RtR Y tZ8A BP RZ88stIR {BtR$II
$t Y %sjZs$Bt BP Y R$R BP Y ,tjR A$tq~ )q>
$P Y$R tZ8A $R ht$ B Y t{RRsk tZ8A BP 8R B {BtR$I Zt$j {Bt%t{ $R s{Y$%I $P q> $R $tht$
!t Y BY YstI %s$s$Btsj PB8 wd(D $R IZ{I B
s j$ts RkR8 BP JZs$BtR PB s $%t R BP [ R
PZt{$BtR\jiwDiIhtI Bt U [
3
7)d
pi77)"i wi ) d, 3 3 3 ,[D
pi7) & 3 #)d & 3 )d qp 3 q)(
p#qi7 , "i) & 3
#)d
"i#,
wd;D
A$t {B^{$tRp#qi7 stI"i#U
p#qi7 ) ;$d
K 88
;#jiwD
88
;>
q
KKw, D]7wDQQ#,
wdxD
"i#)
88
;#jiwDQ
#, wdED
bY qp }RtR Y tZ8A BP RZ88stIR {BtR$II
$t Y %sjZs$Bt BP Y R$R BP Y ,tjR A$tqp)q>
$P Y$R tZ8A $R ht$ B Y t{RRsk tZ8A BP 8R B {BtR$I Zt$j {Bt%t{ $R s{Y$%I $P q> $R $tht$
7BjZ$Bt BP j$ts RkR8 wd;D }B%$IR Y %sjZR BP Y {Zt ItR$$R7w7) d, 3 3 3 ,[D js,$t PB8 Y tBIR
BP Y $I <Bb% Y Rs8t BP Y$R RkR8 T JZ$R Y I$R{$9s$Bt BP s 1* IB8s$t wY bYBj RZT Ps{ BP Y BZtII j{BIRD $R 8s$- $R PZjj stI Y {B8}Zs$Bt BP $R {B^{$tR JZ$R B }PB8 IBZAj $ts$Bt Bt 1* IB8s$tR qYR Ps{R $8}jk s js tZ8A BP IR BP PIB8 stI st Zts&BIsAj {B8}Z$t &B $t ]_= $8 $t Y stsjkR$R BP }s{${sj {sRR 3B sjj YR sRBtR $ $R t{RRsk B $tBIZ{ RB8 sII$$Btsj Yk}BYRR $t BI B I{sR Y {B8T }Zs$Btsj {BR>xH
n1 V}}B-$8sI e s}}Bs{Y stI ^T
{$t{k BP Y tZ8${sj R{Y8
VR b Ys% }RtI BZtI$t $IR BP 8BR j{$T {sj $tRsjjs$BtR s PB8I Ak s 8RY BP {BtIZ{BR b$Y
s$B I$s8\jtY %k R8sjj w d(nD *Z B Y$R
{B8}Zs$Btsj {BR>d xH yt Y$R bsk Y js,s {ZT
t ItR$k $R {BtRst sBZtI Y {BRR R{$Bt BP
Y {kj$tI${sj {BtIZ{BR BP Y BZtI$t $I stI I$RT {$9s$BtR wddD stI wd;D A{B8 8Z{Y R$8}j R$t{ Y {jsRRR BP R stI $sj PZt{$BtR s R${I B YBR b$Y {${Z8Pt$sj Zt$PB8$k bY$j Btjk Y s-$sj j$tR BP Y BZtI$t j{BIR Ys% B A I$R{$9I>xH
yt {B8}s$RBt b$Y Y tsj 1* ABZtIsk j8t PBT
8Zjs$Bt Y tZ8A BP j8tsj {Bt$AZ$BtRp#i7 stI
"i#tII B Rs Y RkR8 BP j$ts JZs$BtR wd;D stI
Y tZ8A BP Zt,tBbtR 7 s tBb R$t$h{stjk R8sjj
PB s $%t j%j BP 8RY ht8t
yt R}$ BP Y $8}Bst IZ{$Bt $t Y {B8}Zs$Bt {BR Ys $8}j$R B I$R{$9 Btjk Y s-$sj j$tR BP Y j{BIR -tR$% {B8}Z$t $R R$jj t{RRsk 8s$tjk A{sZR BP Y {${Z8Pt$sj $ts$Bt Bt Y }$8T BP Y j{BIR Ys s $t%Bj%I $t Y $tsj ,T tjR W%YjRR $t }%$BZR bB,R b Ys% }B}BRI Y %sjZs$Bt BP YR {${Z8Pt$sj $tsjR $t st s}T }B-$8sI PB8 Ak ZR$t R}{$h{ JZsIsZR $P RZ$sAj R$8}j$h{s$BtR $t Y tsj s}}Bs{Y s $tBIZ{I>xH qY htsj RZj $R st s}}B-$8sI d* s}}Bs{Y R$8$js B Y }RtI $t R{$Bt nd bY Y {B8}Zs$Bt BP {B^{$tR BP Y JZs$BtR RkR8 JZ$R $ts$Bt Bt d* IB8s$tR $ Y s-$sj j$tR BP Y j{BIR>H
WBb R}{$h{ tZ8${sj s}}Bs{YR {st A I$%I PB I$PT Pt Rj{$Bt BP RR BP $sj stI R PZt{$BtR $t Y tZ8${sj R{Y8 w s _B$t ]BjjB{s$Bt R{Y8 B s psj,$t BtD 3ZY I$R{ZRR$Bt $t Y$R }s} $R T R${I B Y {sR BP s psj,$t k} s}}Bs{Y R$t{ Y 8s$- BP {B^{$tR $R Rk88${ stI }BR$$% Iht$>xH yt Y stsjkR$R BP BZtI$t RkR8R $t Zt$PB8 RB$j 8BIT jR PB _B$t ]BjjB{s$Bt stI psj,$t k} b$Y$t tZ8${sj PB8Zjs$Bt sZYBR Ys% I$%I s Y$Yjk PT h{$t stsjk${sj {Yt$JZ B %sjZs Y {B^{$tR BP Y j$ts RkR8 BP JZs$BtR>xH WBb R$t{ Y d* s}T
}B-$8sI -}RR$BtR PB 8R ~q
,7 stI p#qi7 $t wdnD
stI wdxD s PB8sjjk JZ$%sjt B YBR BAs$tI $t Y {sR BP Zt$PB8 RB$j 8BIjR Y$ {B8}Zs$Bt {st sjRB A }PB8I stsjk${sjjk>H
Vt $8}Bst sR}{ BP Y tZ8${sj PB8Zjs$Bt }BT }BRI $R $R Bsj {B8}Zs$Btsj {BR qYZR PB R}{$h{
I$R{$9s$Bt w& j8tR BP tBIR s{Y stI s BT
sj tZ8A BP [ IR BP PIB8D s j$ts RkR8
wd;D BP BI [ 8ZR A tsI stI RBj%I
s$-ts$Bt }B{RR JZ$R 5w&11b1D B}s$BtR R$t{
1 R$R BP {Bt$AZ$BtR BP k} wd(D Ys% B A {B8T
}ZI PB %k }s$ BP j8tR stI s}}B-$8sjk YsjP BP Y8 s I$R{sII A{sZR BP Rk88k yt Zt$PB8 RB$j 8BIjR YR R$R s PB8I Ak Btjk bB 8R bY$j $t bBTjsk 8BIjR Y R$R {st Ys% st $tht$ tZ8A BP Y8 Ys b$jj A tZ8${sjjk sIII Z} Zt$j s Bjst{ $R PZjhjjI B st Z}} j$8$ BP RZ88stIR $R s{Y$%I ]BtRJZtjk 8s$- ts$Bt b$jj A 8Z{Y 8B -}tR$% $t bBTjsk 8BIjR
qsAj d sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U ptsj ]YsT s{$R${R
sjs$IBR yy ]Yss{$R${R
s- p$I *$8tR$BtRU Edd 8d 8
p$I *}YU (M( 8
WZ8A BP p$I ej{BIRU d(
WZ8A BP z${sj iBIRU E
ej{BI *$s8U dd1M 88
z${sj iBI *$s8U d;(( 88
z${sj iBI NtYU dx 8
pBZtI _Bt$sj i$R wp_iDU d( ,z
y
(61.1,79.1)
x
(0,0)3$Z n sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U _jst BP Y BZtI$t $I w%${sj BIR s 8s,I b$Y Ajs{, }B$tRD
!t Y BY YstI R$t{ Y 8s$- $R Rk88${ AZ tB R}sR RkR8 RBj%$t }B{RR JZ$R 5w[nbnD B}sT
$BtR $P Y RBjZ$Bt $R {s$I BZ b$Y s I${ 8YBI
<t{ 8BR BP {B8}Z$t &B $R I%BI B 8s$- tT s$Bt $t R8sjj\8I$Z8 }BAj8R bY$j j$ts RkR8 RBjZ$Bt bBZjI }%s$j $t 8I$Z8\js BtR yt YR {sRR Y ZR BP I${ 8YBIR PB Y j$ts RkR8 RBT jZ$Bt $R BZ BP st qYPB $s$% B R8$$s$% {Yt$JZR b$jj A }PsAj qY AR RZjR Ys% At BAs$tI Ak s I$sBtsj }{BtI$$BtI {Bt`Zs sI$T t sjB$Y8 b$Y sRR8Ajk BP Y jBAsj 8s$->xH qY$R {Yt$JZ YsR ZtI BZ B A -8jk ^{$t PB RBj%T $t js R{sj }BAj8R b$Y s %k jBb {B8}Zs$Btsj {BR $t {B8}s$RBt b$Y 8s$- ts$Bt 7B Y {BR BP Y RkR8 RBjZ$Bt RYBZjI t% }%s$j
stk $%t }B$t wtB8sjjk s Y sY RZPs{D Ak 8stR BP wd1D Btjk JZ$R5w&D B}s$BtR R$t{{Bt$AZT $BtR BP k} wdnD Ys% B A {B8}ZI PB %k j8t <Bb% {B8}Z$t $8 8sk A $8}Bst $P $ $R t{T RRsk B {B8}Z }Bt$sjR s s js tZ8A BP }B$tR PB -s8}j B Isb {BtBZ j$tR
qY -s8}j }RtI $t Y t- R{$Bt {BR}BtIR B Y stsjkR$R BP s BZtI$t RkR8 PB I$&t ,$tI BP RB$j 8BIjR G {B8}s stI I$R{ZRR RZjR BAs$tI Ak ZR$t st Zt$PB8 stI bBTjsk RB$j 8BIjR
-20.00 0.00 20.00 40.00 60.00 80.00 X (m.) -20.00
0.00 20.00 40.00 60.00 80.00 100.00 Y (m.)
3$Z ; sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U _Bt$sj I$RT
$AZ$Bt wd( ,zD Bt Y sY RZPs{ BAs$tI Ak
ZR$t st Zt$PB8 RB$j 8BIj w8BIj VD
; V}}j${s$Bt BP Y tZ8${sj s}}Bs{Y
B }s{${sj {sRR
;d *R{$}$Bt BP Y sY$t RkR8
qY }B}BRI tZ8${sj s}}Bs{Y AsRI Bt Y BZtIT sk ej8t YBI YsR At $tsI $t s ]B8}Z V$II *R$t RkR8 PB sY$t stsjkR$R yt Y$R R{$Bt b b$jj }Rt RZjR BAs$tI Ak ZR$t I$&t ,$tI BP RB$j 8BIjR $t Y stsjkR$R BP s sj BZtI$t $IU Y sjs$IBR yy RZARs$Bt {jBR B Y {$k BP z$B $t 7}s$t
qY sY$t RkR8 BP Y$R RZARs$Bt $R s $I BP d( {kj$tI${sj {BtIZ{BR wI$s8U dd1M 88D AZ$I B s I}Y BP M( {8 RZ}}j8tI b$Y E %${sj BIR ws{Y Bt YsR s jtY BP dx 8 stI s I$s8 BP d;( 88D qY
Bsj RZPs{ }B{I $R Z} B ;M(( 81 qY Bsj ss
RZI$I $R s {stj BP dx( 8 Ak d;( 8 bY${Y $8}j$R
s RZPs{ Z} B 1d((( 81 qY pBZtI _Bt$sj i$R
{BtR$II $t Y$R RZIk YsR At d( ,z qY }jst BP Y BZtI$t $I $R }RtI $t hZ n stI s RZ88sk BP Y {Yss{$R${R BP Y RkR8 $R $%t $t sAj d
-20.00 0.00 20.00 40.00 60.00 80.00 X (m.) -20.00
0.00 20.00 40.00 60.00 80.00 100.00 Y (m.)
3$Z x sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U _Bt$sj I$RT
$AZ$Bt wd( ,zD Bt Y sY RZPs{ BAs$tI Ak
ZR$t st YB$9Btsj bBTjsk RB$j 8BIj w8BIj D
qsAj 1 sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U ]Yss{$R${R BP Y WZ8${sj BIj
e WZ8${sj BIj
qk} BP V}}Bs{YU psj,$t
qk} BP ]Zt *tR$k ej8tU N$ts
WZ8A BP ej8tRU 1;d
*R BP 3IB8U 1(M
;1 iRZjR Ak ZR$t I$&t RB$j 8BIjR
qY tZ8${sj 8BIj ZRI $t Y RBjZ$Bt BP Y$R }BAT j8 $R AsRI Bt s psj,$t k} b$Y$t es{Y As $R I$R{$9I $t Bt R$tj j$ts js,s {Zt ItR$k jT 8t bY${Y $8}j$R s Bsj BP 1(M IR BP PIB8 wPB Y$R {sR Y ZR BP Bt R$tj {BtRst ItR$k j8t } j{BI bBZjI $8}jk s Bsj BP 1;d bY$j Y ZR BP Bt R$tj }ssABj${ j8t bBZjI $8}jk ;;D
G Ys% stsjk9I Y {sRR $t Y sjs$IBR yy BZtI$t RkR8 PB I$&t ,$tI BP RB$j 8BIjR XBIj V" {BT
R}BtIR B st Zt$PB8 RB$j 8BIj b$Y ) x(d w8Dd
X8BIj " {BR}BtIR B st YB$9Btsj bBTjsk RB$j
8BIj wsR hZ dD b$Y d ) x(d w8Dd 1 )
x(((d w8Dd stI I ) d3x 8 stI X8BIj ]" {BT
qsAj n sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U WZ8${sj T RZjR PB Y I$&t RB$j 8BIjR
7B$j BIjR
V ]
eJZ$% iR$Rst{ wD (nnE MM (;;;
qBsj ]Zt w,VD 1 ddd 11x
]_= q$8 wRD 1E d(nx ;1
d) x(dw8Dd1) x(((d w8DdstI Y %${sj
$t}YsR $R B s I$Rst{ BP d 8 BP Y BZtI$t $I
wk ) M(3d 8- $t Y }jst BP hZ nD
3$Z ; RYBbR Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt Bt Y sY RZT Ps{ BAs$tI Ak ZR$t Y Zt$PB8 RB$j 8BIj V 3$ZR x stI E RYBb Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt Bt Y sY RZPs{ BAs$tI Ak ZR$t Y bBTjsk RB$j 8BIjR wYB$9BtsjD stI ] w%${sjD 3$Z $R s {B8}s$RBt BP Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt Bt Y sY RZPs{ BAs$tI b$Y 8BIjR V stI ] $t Y sY$t R$ {jBR B Y 9Bt b$Y %s$s$Bt $t Y {BtIZ{$%$k BP Y BZtI
-20.00 0.00 20.00 40.00 60.00 80.00 X (m.) -20.00
0.00 20.00 40.00 60.00 80.00 100.00 Y (m.)
3$Z E sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U _Bt$sj I$RT
$AZ$Bt wd( ,zD Bt Y sY RZPs{ BAs$tI Ak
ZR$t s %${sj bBT jsk RB$j 8BIj w8BIj ]D
qsAj 1 RZ88s$9R Y {Yss{$R${R BP Y tZ8${sj PB8Zjs$Bt ZRI $t Y RBjZ$Bt BP Y I$&t {sRR stI qsAj n RYBbR RB8 RZjR BAs$tI PB s{Y {sR stsT jk9IU Y JZ$%sjt R$Rst{ BP Y BZtI$t RkR8 Y Bsj {Zt I$%I B Y RB$j stI Y ]_= $8
qY tZ8${sj s}}Bs{Y YsR At $8}j8tI Bt s ]V* RkR8 bY${Y YsR At {B8}$jI stI Zt BtB st !$$t 1((( 7$j${Bt ps}Y${R {B8}Z s Y eZB}st ]tT
-10.00 0.00 10.00 20.00 30.00 40.00 50.00 60.00 X (m.)
60.00 65.00 70.00 75.00 80.00 85.00 Y (m.)
-10.00 0.00 10.00 20.00 30.00 40.00 50.00 60.00 X (m.)
60.00 65.00 70.00 75.00 80.00 85.00 Y (m.)
Case A, detail
Case C, detail around vertical border in y=80.1m ( =1/50 ( ·m) in South,γ1 Ω
-1 γ Ω -1
2=1/5000 ( ·m) in North)
3$Z sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U ]B8}s$RBt
Abt Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt wd( ,zD Bt Y
sY RZPs{ BAs$tI Ak ZR$t RB$j 8BIjR V stI ] wIT s$j BP Y BZtI$t R$ {jBR B Y 9Bt b$Y {Yst $t Y {BtIZ{$%$kD
PB _ssjjj$R8 BP s{jBts ]e_ V VjYBZY Y !1((( $R s Y$YT}PB8st{ {B8}Z b$Y E; y_7 id(((( }B{RRBR s 1x( <9 sjj Y -s8}jR Ys% At RBj%I $t RJZt$sj 8BI PB Y Zt$PB8 stI Y bBTjsk 8BIjR
VR b {st R $t YR -s8}jR Y Rj{$Bt BP Y RZ$T sAj RB$j 8BIj $R RRt$sj B Zsst Y RsPk $t Y BZtI$t $tRsjjs$BtR R$t{ RZjR BAs$tI Ak ZR$t s 8Zj$}jTjsk RB$j 8BIj {st A tB${sAjk I$&t PB8 YBR BAs$tI Ak ZR$t s R$tj jsk wB Zt$PB8D RB$j 8BIj whZR ;xEM stI sAj nD qYPB $ {BZjI A sI%$RsAj B ZR 8Zj$Tjsk RB$j PB8Zjs$BtR B stsT jk9 BZtI$t RkR8R sR s tsj Zj $t R}$ BP Y $tT {sR BP Y {B8}Zs$Btsj &B yt Ps{ Y ZR BP Y$R ,$tI BP sI%st{I 8BIjR RYBZjI A 8stIsBk $t {sRR bY Y {BtIZ{$%$k BP Y RB$j {YstR 8s,Ijk b$Y I}Y B $t Y %${$t$k BP Y RZARs$Bt R$
!A%$BZRjk Y$R ABZtIsk j8t PB8Zjs$Bt {st A s}T }j$I B stk BY {sR b$Y s Y$Y tZ8A BP jskR <Bb% ]_= $8 8sk $t{sR Z} B ZtsI8$R$Aj j%T jR 8s$tjk IZ B Y }BB s BP {Bt%t{ BP Y ZtIjk$t R$R -}stR$BtR stI Y tI B %sjZs IBZAj R$R w$t YTjsk 8BIjRD $}j R$R w$t PBZT jsk 8BIjRD stI RB Bt
A
C B
A C
x y Line x = 30.0m
Line y = 79.1m
-10. 0. 10. 20. 30. 40. 50. 60. 70. 80. 90.
y (x=30.0) (m)
8.0
8.5
9.0
9.5
10.0
10.5
Potential
(kV)
-10. 0. 10. 20. 30. 40. 50. 60. 70.
x (y=79.1) (m)
8.0
8.5
9.0
9.5
10.0
10.5
Potential
(kV)
BG.P.R.=10 kV
G.P.R.=10 kV
3$Z M sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U _Bt$sj }BT hjR w,zD Bt sY RZPs{ sjBt bB j$tR Ak ZR$t Y PBZ k}R BP RB$j 8BIjR WB${ Y $8}Bst I$&T t{R $t Y RZjR I}tI$t Bt Y ,$tI BP RB$j 8BIj Rj{I
{Yt$JZR>d(H stI Bt Y BY YstI Y }ssjjj$9s$Bt BP Y 8Zj$Tjsk ABZtIsk j8t tZ8${sj s}}Bs{Y bY${Y {BZjI A{B8 s sjT$8 IR$t BBj PB BZtI$t stsjkR$R>MH
x ]Bt{jZR$BtR
yt Y jsR ksR Y sZYBR Ys% I%jB}I s Y$Y ^T {$t tZ8${sj PB8Zjs$Bt AsRI Bt Y BZtIsk ejT 8t 8YBI PB sY$t stsjkR$R $t Zt$PB8 RB$j 8BIjR bY${Y YsR At RZ{{RPZjjk s}}j$I B R%sj sj {sRR
yt Y$R }s} b Ys% }RtI s tsj$9s$Bt BP Y$R ABZtIsk j8t s}}Bs{Y PB BZtI$t $IR 8AIT II $t Rs$hI RB$jR qY }B}BRI s}}Bs{Y YsR At s}}j$I B Y stsjkR$R BP s sj $I {BtR$I$t I$&t ,$tI BP RB$j 8BIjRU s R$tj stI bB jsk 8BIjR wYB$T 9Btsj stI %${sjD bY${Y sjjBbR B stsjk9 Y $t4Zt{ BP Y %s$s$BtR $t Y RB$j {BtIZ{$%$k b$Y I}Y stI $t Y RZBZtI$tR BP Y BZtI$t RkR8
qY RZ$sAj Rj{$Bt BP Y RB$j 8BIj $R s ,k }B$t $t BZtI$t stsjkR$R G Ys% RYBbt Ys $ $R }BRR$Aj B BAs$t Y$Yjk s{{Zs RZjR b$Y Y }B}BRI ABZtIT sk j8t tZ8${sj s}}Bs{Y stI YR RZjR {st A tB${sAjk I$&t I}tI$t Bt Y ,$tI BP RB$j 8BIj {BtR$II $t Y RZIk ]BtRJZtjk R$t{ Y BZtIT $t RsPk }ss8R 8sk R$t$h{stjk {Yst $ {BZjI A sI%$RsAj B ZR Y 8Zj$Tjsk RB$j PB8Zjs$Bt sR s tsj Zj $t R}$ BP Y $t{sR $t Y {B8}Zs$Btsj {BR
E V{,tBbjI8tR
qY$R bB, YsR At }s$sjjk htst{I Ak }B`{ d3*T (d(M BP 7p_y]OqTe] {Bhtst{I b$Y 3e*ei PZtIR stI }Bb {B8}stk =3y7V stI Ak Rs{Y stR BP Zts I psj${$s ]e_ V stI =t$%R$IsI Is ]BZKts
iPt{R
>dH VW7y\yeee 7IM( yeee pZ$I PB RsPk $t V] RZARs$Bt BZtI$t Wb OB, dME
>1H 7%s, Fp _BRR $t 7} stI qBZ{Y zBjs eJZs$BtR BP VW7y\yeee 7IM( yeee q_Gi*dn E1uE d
>nH ps *N _Z$ Fp _BAj8R et{BZtI b$Y Y V_ BP Vtsjk9$t pBZtI$t 7kR8R yeee q_Gi*d(; ;((Eu;(1n dMx
>;H Ws%s$ts 3 ]BjB8$tsR y ]sRj$B Vtsjk${sj yts$Bt q{Yt$JZR PB esY$t p$I ]B8}ZsT $Bt Ak e WZ8 $t et stI V}}j 7{$ ddud1(E ]yWe s{jBts d1
>xH ]BjB8$tsR y Ws%s$ts 3 ]sRj$B V ABZtIT sk j8t tZ8${sj s}}Bs{Y PB BZtI$t $I {B8}Zs$Bt ]Ve d; nT( d
>EH ]sRj$B NV <t?stI9 y ]BjB8$tsR stI 3 Ws%s$ts 8Bk stI =R Z$I BP RkR8 q!q e PB ]V* BP BZtI$t $IR $t j{${sj $tRsjjs$BtR ]$%$j et 7{Y =*] d;
>H ]BjB8$tsR y Ws%s$ts 3 ]sRj$B V WZ8T ${sj 3B8Zjs$Bt PB pBZtI$t VtsjkR$R $t 7s$hI 7B$jR 7ZA8$I B yeee q_Gi* d
>MH ]BjB8$tsR y Ws%s$ts 3 BRJZ$s p e$Bs F ]sRj$B WZ8${sj 8BIjj$t PB BZtIT $t $IR $t Y$YT}PB8s{ }ssjjj {B8}ZR BZtIsk ej8tR yy ]B8} {Y _ZA 7BZYs8}Bt = 1(((
>H p3 qs esY iR$Rst{R _$8st Wb OB, dE;