Forensic evaluation of the evidence using automatic speaker recognition systems

(1)

8+107409+642 8+ 36:+63+7305 36;2790543-0

<=>?@ABC ?DEFGEHB=@ =< HI?

?DBJ?@C? G AB@K EGH=LEHBC

AM?EN?> >?C=K@BHB=@ AO AH?L A

PQRSTS UVWQVXYZP

R[YZ\YWTV]^ UR ZY R[TUR^WTY _VXR^SR

\QTZT`Y^UV STSQRaYS Y\QVaY]QTWVS UR

XRWV^VWTaTR^QV UR ZVW\QVX

b cdefgf fhijgkkel mno kde lepoee nmq

rstusv s

w xyz{s|

s

} y~

logl nejieo

(2)

(3)

4 /4

+

4

- 9 7 0

+ 1

0 , 3 4 !

" 1 8 ; 18;

- # $$% 8 7 - 0 " 6

& &

& & " &

." 0 9 "

(4)

(5)

! "

# $ %

&'()*+ ,'-./ 0'/12.

3.'456

7

( 8.(9'+*6 9 ,.:26

7;

5*9

<

= >>?

@

A5)/ B*2('(:6 *9 8.6-*9

<

%

3'C)*2 D21*

;

' 8'2E6

7 '

<

F G

0H2)/1.IH* 0H'-I.:

J<K L$J

F

B*2-'(( M5(N 9*++

% O< P$=

F Q

&'C): C'( A**5R*(

" S !< S S$J

TUV WVXVYWZU [VXZW\]V[ \^ _U\X TUVX\X `YX ZYWW\V[ ab_ `\_U\^ _UV c\adV_W\Z eVZaf^\_\a^ gWabh i

jTkl Y__UVmVh_n ao p^fV^\VWq

r

Yjb[\as\XbYtu vadb^\ZYZ\a^VXwxXZbVtYy^\sVWX\_YW\Y[V p^fV^\VWq

r Y

TVZq^\ZY [V TVtVZadb^\ZYZ\a^q w y^\sVWX\[Y[ zat\_VZ^q \ZY [V {Y[W\[ |oWad }~~ _a }~~ Y^[ Y_ _UV

mVh_n ao p^fV^\VWq

r

Y p^oaWdY_\Zq Yw xXZbVtY zat\_VZ^q \ZY lbhVW\aWw y^\sVWX\[Y[ jb_a^adq Y [V {Y[W\[

|oWad }~~ _a }~~n TUV hWaVZ_ `YX hYW_\Yttu ob^[V[ ]u Y zUm XZUatYWXU\h oWad vadb^\[Y[ [V

{Y[W\[ Y^[ a^[a laZ\YtxbWahVan

(6)

(7)

!

" #

$% & %

'

$ (! ! )

* +,, & , -*

,

. # & / ) 0#

1"

"/&," 0# (,/

1)

2+* &

* & ,3) 0 #

4 %

, 5

6

O7)

8

*

,

5$

SO $ S7

)

,

. # & / )

0# "/',) 0# 1""/& ," 0# (,/1) 2

*

94 ,

*/ /

8"3) 0!

:#

(8)

(9)

# %

< # %<

< % O6

% O6 O% %

< O <

< O< < # % O

O <

<

S< <O O

% %

O O%

! O<

% O <

@ O% <O%

#

# O OO ,

,

K O O% # #

< # O

O % # $ $

O% %

O

% O% < %

#

O < % #

% <

O % O

# % K % %

! ,

,

% <

# #

< %<

O< % <

(10)

O # <

<

% %

<% < O%

% < % J

< O K% J

<

%

<

*

<

% % %<

O% < OO< %

!

< O

< % O % <

% <%

%

< %

<

%

O < O%

O % <O

#

% O

< % #

!%< % O< %

,

% %

O% % "

O O O % O% P

@ # %

% <O%

O %

(11)

" O6< <

< O K

O% % "

# O< O

% #

<$

% -< G

(12)

(13)

# % F

$ P >>Q O G

% @ @

>>

# O O

%

P P @< PP@ O

% O % O% @

! < 6 % %

< O <

! < # # %

P$

% S O %

< % % %

% O < <

< % # # F

"P

<

% O O% J S

O %

'" < %

% % # % #

@

< # <

6% % O %

!

@

< <

J < J "<

O O

< #% #

@

< <

OS%< P<S<

O

% % #

% O % % % J #

@ @ < #

S % %

# < % O % %< #

< %<

<! <" $O 6 %6 % %

(14)

% < O

% J% #

!% % % O<

< # #

O O #

# <

O O % # F

@

## % # % % # #

O %

<#<<

#

*

! %< O

% K <

% # J P< " < < $ F<

< $< % %#< K%<

% O

# %

# # O

<

# $< P L< J<

S < % # #

P @<% 6 J<

% # # F

< < < < O < %

% % #

P $< P P< !< <

J < ! < O < ! < <

@

< P < <J < PO%<!<F

P < < @ < 6 O6 < %

%6 6% F#

< P < ! O #

(15)

&

) 8 :

(16)

(17)

/12'E1

E(.R+*:

;

*-*(1/

A)/1 . )

;

52*/

A)/1 . '+*/

(12.:5E1).(

GG ! G %

GGG @

GG ?

GG Q #

G

G Q GG

G " G

G $ O G

,*+'1*: R.2/

G # G

GG % G

G G

G Q %

G O

G ! # Q

G #

O %

G S Q>

QG

Q QG

Q # % Q

QG !

O # Q

(18)

Q $O

O # Q

Q Q # Q

@ % Q

I*2)-*(1'+ 2'-*R.2

QG % G

QGG

Q # Q

Q G O Q

Q

Q Q # %

Q Q @ % >

H)*2'2EH)E'+ -*1H.:.+.

;

.2 .2*(/)E '51.-'1)E /I*'*2 2*E.

;

()1).(

G

! #

Q @ #

S % #

G S% O

@

% >

H* :)/E2)-)('1).( +*C*+ /E.2*'/*: '51.-'1)E /I*'*2 2*E.

;

()1).(

G

GG

G

#

G

@O J #

?>

Q O% ?

!

Q @ %

H* I2*/*(1'1).( +*C*+ E.-I51'1).(

G

GG G

% %

Q %

QG @O

Q % # G>G

Q Q O G>?

(19)

@

O % G>

G G>

GGQ

Q GG

@ GG?

GG?

GG

G O G >

S%O O G

Q @O G Q

G ?

O % G

? @ % GQQ

H* .2*(/)E +*C*+ .2*(/)E 2*I.21)(

;

'(: I2*/*(1'1).( )( E.521

?G $ # % GQ?

?GG ,

,

#

GQ?

?G O% # GQ

? # % GQ

?

G F #

% G >

? % G

? Q P G

? QG % G

? Q G

? Q Q $ G ?

? @ % G>

0.(E+5/).(/ '(: 5152* R.2

G @ GG

GG O GQ

! K# G

(20)

(21)

GG

< %

G " <

O O OO GG >>

< " < O

O % <" " O

! % %

G # O

< >> Q

G Q

G G

G % $% >>Q >

O # % < O Q

Q P # % Q

<

P

#

? # Q>

% # O % Q

% %<

>>

G

PO # %

P$ < >> Q

(22)

G>P < O O

%O #

% O

O %

O% %

O<

P O < O < O

O P Q

GGFO%

P O

O

O F P % $ >>

$ >> O Q?

G FO% O %

P Q O

OO Q <

O F P %

$ >> Q

GQO !< < O

< @ O

O

Q

G ! <O %

6 #O

#

>>

Q

,

Q %

# ,

,

?

O% % #

O % #

G %

#

! !$ % O %<

(23)

Q $"

@

?

! !$

O O O %

O <

O

?

J ?

? $ O <

< P FPJ

% GG G ??

@

! O% O

<< P

FPJ % GG G ??

J O >> $ P % O FPJ

% ?

G> %<

% PF % O

P % < %

P <

GG F P FPJ % G

G $ >> $ >> O

G F %

G $ >> $ >> O

G %

#

" O O

Q

%

Q

% %

# %

O%

# % < O

< O O

O% O

<

(24)

% %

% #

O

% GQ

O O% O%

@%< O O%

O O%

% <

OO% 6

% ?

? O#

J OO% <

% O O

O #

O

%

O ! !$ G>

G>F GG PF

F % O O J

% O G %

G G>

GG G>

G < O

% % G< % % Q O %

G>

GQ % GG>

G $ % %<

O %< <

% GGG

G % O

O % %

< % O

OO% % # < GG

G@ O F FF %

$ >> O O<

O GG

G? % O FF P O<

% GG

(25)

G

< %O O

GG

G ! !$ O F # %

$ >> O

@

O

G

>@ %OO

J

! G O<P O <

O < % !

G

G % G

O G

>> $ G ?

Q

G G

F P %

G

O F

P % GQ>

O F

P % GQG

? O F

P % <

GQ

% O GQQ

?G %

# GQ

? F

P % <

O< %

F P %

G G

? Q PP@ % $ O

< O< %

O% #

% G

(26)

? G ?

? O

> G

? O

< % <

O G

??

O "J < O < <

G

(27)

GG @

% %

@

>>> ?

G ! # O G>

G < G> % P

G> % O <

GQ% $ # ! @O

% @" O% O %

@< >>? Q

QG O $ J >>

Q $ $ >> %

O G

G G O $

>>

>

> ?

Q Q $

G O ?

J P % ? O

G> ?

Q J FPJ % ? O

G> ?

G F OO $ G>

(28)

(29)

# %

<

%

#

% %

O

!

O P< >>> " O <% <

4

,) 4) "

! !

/

P >>> S< O % #

%

@

< >>> P< >>>

< O OO

" @< >>> <

# % O6

O6 K

< @ >>> S<

O

<% % #

# < % O 6 O

# # < >> < >> < O

< O% < %

# < >> @<

>>>

@ %<

>>

> < G

J%< G?? ! GG

%< #

O% < O %

% O O<

< # < >>

@

< >>O < >>

< >> < GQ # < >> < %

(30)

Relevant question for the fact finder

Background information in the case

Potential offenders

Witness testimony

Relevant population

Other forensic evidence

Police investigations

...

Forensic evidence

Recovered (questioned source)

Control (known source)

!

" #

$

%&'

< O% <

% % O %

# # < >> <

>

#< >><

G % < GG < GQ # < >> #<

G<O % O

,

<

O

< O %% >(

%< % < O< < < #<

#< O O

% % @<

>>

%<

>>

Q

% < >> # < >> "

O O%

@< GQ < @

%

O%<% % #% O

" << %

# < #% O 6

(31)

# < >>%<GG <

# O O

OO%

O < <@ >>O %

O% <

O% < # % # GG

>> ! G < >>S < >> < %

O<

% # O

$O < >>Q$O #< >>

' !

! ' !

" ! '

" "

'

' $!

'

O # %

# O O6

% < O O #< >>

@

O<

G? P$ #< >>? S< O

%

% # O

%

# $ $ G %O#

#< >>? < % #O

(32)

% O #< >> $%< >>QOJ #< >>

O O

@O S@O

#< >> J$P

#

J

@

"P #< >>> #

% < >>%O#

#<

>>?

J

#< >> < #

O #< >>? K% #< >> <

#

< # O O%

O < O% O O#

#< >> #< G< >>? < >>? $ < >> $

P6< >>? $ #< >> L< >> < $< >>

< >>Q <

>

> "%%< G

>>

FO< >>?<O L

< >> < O# F

@

< >> P #< >>Q

#< >> #< >>>O%O# #< >>? < >> J

#< >>K

#< $

?

G Q =

#< >> < 6

< >> < >>

@

" ?< >> $%< >>Q <

@

<

>> < >> < < >> @Q?< >> <

O < >> % P< >>

# %

< #

* ,

< >>

@

< >>? %6< >>? P$ #< >>?O %< >>G $

@ #< >>O % O # O

O O

,

#<

K O% <

< O

#

O# < O

% J% >>

# O

#

>> @O G?

# # J J<

G > < % O

# O# % O O%

O# < %

< O < #<

O% # < O

(33)

# < >> % < J < %

% < # <

< # # < >>

% O < <

#< O < O < #< <

< # <O < "

< % #<

# < >> % O O

< O < < < <

< O <

G Q

Crime

Scene _Evidence ^Transfer Criminal

Crime Scene Criminal

(source)

From crime scene to criminal

Crime scene

(source) Criminal

From criminal to crime scene

?

...blackmail...

?

'

< O

O

# < >> < >>

<G K <

# O O

@

# #< G <

<

% < %

< % @ %< >>>

< G

< O# O O <

,

(34)

@

< >>> <

O % <

% O%

@%< O

O< O% < < < < < #<

< < O O 6

< %

O#

G H* 5/* . /5*E1)C* 1H2*/H.+:/ % %

% O6 %< %

% O% % O

% < # O6

< O # <

# <

O O O O% @

%< >>> < O6

<

%< GG <

6 % O

< < #

.(*E)*(1 5/* . 1H* 'C')+'+* (.R+*:

;

*

%

# O O#<

OO% O %

# OO

@ %< >>>

O

OO %% % OO OO

< O % S<

6 O < # O6

<% O

O GG <

O % %

% O % %

(35)

$"

<<<O

# %

"

'

# >> < ,

,

<% O% <

$ O% %

%

O

% # < >>

" < % O @< GQ

O <

O

G S O

O # <6%O%

%% O

S O O6 O

Q K # %

O < %% O

S O % %

O% O O<% !

TUV_VWd \Xb^[VWX_aa[ \^ lYXY^[ aVUtVW }~~ Y^[ _UaWabfU _U\Xm\XXVW_Y_\a^ YXYXU\o_

_a`YW[XXZ\V^_\Z dV_Ua[atafuwY^[ ^a_YXYbU^^\Y^ hYWY[\fd XU\o_ bU^w}

(36)

O < O <

@<

>>

# < >> %

O%

% O%

@ <

>>

G < G P$

#<

>>

?O %<

>>G $< >> < % @< >> % < GG # < >>

# < >> @ #< >>> < >> <

O O<

O <

@

< >>O %

#< >>Q@ < >>G 6 # @<

>>

O < >> S < >> 6 < % O

6O%

O @< >>> @< >> # < >>

%< O % @

O <

# O OO% <

@

< >>>

@

%< >>> # < >> %< GG

< O #

% O< O % <

O # %<

O %

& '/ ' /E)*(1) E -.:*+

< % ,

# < >>

@ G>< % < 6

O O <O O

< %<

< O < >># < >>

# < OO

<

< OO OO

# < >> < >> < >> % < >>> <

%

# # < >> @ %< >>><GG

#< G < OO

# < >> < >> %

% % < O % O

Forensic evaluation of the evidence using automatic speaker recognition systems

Relevant question for the fact finder

Background information in the case

Potential offenders

Witness testimony

Relevant population

Other forensic evidence

Police investigations

...

Forensic evidence

Recovered (questioned source)

Control (known source)

Crime

Scene Evidence Transfer Criminal

Crime Scene Criminal

(source)

From crime scene to criminal

Crime scene

(source) Criminal

From criminal to crime scene

?

...blackmail...

?

Scene _Evidence ^Transfer Criminal