TRIBUNAL CONSTITUCIONAL B. Sobre la inadmisibilidad de la acción de amparo
II. SOBRE EL CASO PARTICULAR
About the County Attorney’s Office”……….
Broward County Property Appraiser’s Office”……… ori Parrish, Property Appraiser
“Creati Joseph (CD a “Th r Evan L (CD a
Additio ided at the January 12, 2005 MESC meeting:
Evaluation & Appraisal Report (EAR) Introduction and Executive Summary, Office of
“
Sharon Cruz, Interim County Attorney
“ L
(Oral Presentation Only)
ng Affordable Housing in Broward County”……… Kocy, Director, Office of Housing
Av ilable)
e B oward County Procurement System & Recent Amendments to the Administrative Code” s ukic, County Auditor
Av ilable)
nal papers and /or materials prov o
Urban Planning & Redevelopment-Broward County ,2-24-2004
Human Services o Status Report of the Broward Information Network (BIN), Broward County
Department,1-4-2005
o Permitting & Licensing Integration Project (PLIP) Program Update-Current Summary by Initiative- January 2005- Office of Information Technology Broward County
nd Maria Gross, Assistant Director, Pete Corwin, Assistant to Broward County Administrator
oward County Administrator
o Evaluation & Appraisal Report (EAR) and Interlocal Agreement Database, January 12, o Status of the Recommendations of the 2000 Management & Efficiency Study Committee-
Patricia West, Executive Director a
o Summary of Status of Management & Efficiency Study Committee’s recommendations Chart, MESC Staff and Pete Corwin, Assistant Br
2005 Office of Urban Planning & Redevelopment Building Code Services Divisions, Broward County (CD Available)
February 9th, 2005 (Paper Copy Available)
orce Field Analysis’ Determining Choices of Action 2005’ ………. ……… roward County Management and Efficiency Study Committee Preplanning Survey 2005’………… ack Pinkowski Ph.D. t r, Inst ute of Government & Policy, NOVA /Southeastern
niversity
Add
o Su 0 Recommendations that have not been completed, 0
o St ittee Recommendations updated
E ‘F
‘Force field Analysis Matrix’ 02-9-2005……… ‘B
J , , Direc o it U
itional papers and /or materials provided at the February 9th, 2005 Meeting:
mmary of Status of MESC 200 1-01-05
atus of 2000 Management and Efficiency Study Comm
01-10-2005, Maria Gross, Assistant Director of Broward County Management and fficiency Study Committee
March 2nd, 2005 (Paper Copy Available)
Broward’s County Wide Integrated Water Resource Plan” 2-21-2005……….
rt ent of
D Available)
iami at Midnight: Final Report” 12-30-2004……… om Gustafson, Director of Government Relations, Institute of Government and Public Policy,
ce: Community-Based, Pedestrian-Oriented, Intermodal Facilities” 0-9-2004……….. om Gustafson, Director of Government Relations, Institute of Government and Public Policy,
A New Community Paradigm: Pedestrian-Oriented Intermodal Systems within the Built ernment Relations, Institute of Government and Public Policy, nga School of Business and Entrepreneurship, Nova Southeastern University
…….. Force field Analysis Matrix’ 03-02-2005……… Jack
Un e
A l “
Broward County Depa m Environmental Protection (C
‘M T
H. Wayne Huizenga School of Business and Entrepreneurship, Nova Southeastern University “Transportation Renaissan
1 T
H. Wayne Huizenga School of Business and Entrepreneurship, Nova Southeastern University also by Dr. Jack Pinkowsky,
“
Environment of Urban Centers 2005……….. Tom Gustafson, Director of Gov
H. Wayne Huize
“Broward County Management Efficiency Committee” 3-15-2005……… “
Pinkowski, Ph.D., Director, Institute of Government & Policy, NOVA /Southeastern iv rsity
pri 13th 2005 (Paper Copy Available)
“A Re or Evan “P rf ……… Ev s Works ………. Facilitated by Dr. Jack Pinkowski, Director, Institute of Government and Policy, Nova
o Broward Information Network’s (BIN) response, regarding the need for legislative action to the question, “To what extent do the new HIPPA laws affect the BIN?” Broward County o County Attorney’s response regarding “Collections for FY 04” Sharon Cruz, Interim County o of Broward County Commissioners goals and MESC Goals, Dr. Jack Pinkowski,
o ission Goal Setting Meeting January 13, 2005,” Maria Gross Management And Efficiency Study Committee
genda item #19” 2-01-05……… p t on Transition Review Services for Broward County Property Appraiser
Lukic, County Auditor
e ormance Review Report” March 2005……… an Lukic, County Auditor
heet Numbers 1-15, 2005……… Southeastern University
“Housing Services”……… Broward County Office of Housing Finance and Community Development Division
Additional papers and /or materials provided at the April 13th 2005 Meeting:
Human Services Department 02-09-2005 Attorney 02-01-2005
Comparison
Director, Institute of Government and Policy, NOVA Southeastern University, also by the Management and Efficiency Study Committee Staff
o Email Regarding conversation with Bill Leonard, Demographer, Broward County Urban d Red elopm nt of t f people moving into Broward County 02-17-2005
tection, 01-11-2005
e Future: The Case for Establishing Dedicated Long-Term local Funding Sources for The Region’s Transit Needs 03-01-2005, South Florida Regional Planning Council (SFRPC) (CD Available)
dy Committee dated 12/22/04, Broward County Office of Urban Planning and
ailable)
Planning an ev e he figure on the number o
o Emails regarding Summary of Management & Efficiency Study Committee Recommendations, Department of Environmental Pro
o Funding th
o Accommodating Population Growth in Broward County, 2000 to 2030, Broward County Office of Urban Planning & Redevelopment August 2003 (CD Available)
o Status Report on Year 2000 Recommendations: Management and Efficiency Stu Redevelopment (CD Available)
o Broward County Independent and Dependent Water control Districts, Broward County Attorney’s Office(CD Available)
o 2000 MESC Recommendations status update response from Department of Environmental Protection (CD Av
May 11th, 2005
Additional papers and /or materials provided at the May 11th 2005 Meeting:
randum to Stacy Ritter, MESC Chair, From Rodney P. Rawls, Chair MESC Transportation Subcommittee, Reference: Transportation Subcommittee Goals
o Levels of Transportation Activity Affecting Broward County Transit Development,
o Management & Efficiency Study Committee Service Delivery Subcommittee Report, May nt Broward Study od start.’’ 05-08-2005
une 8
o Synopsis of projects from MovingBroward Website, May 10, 2005
o Key Recommendations & Broward Commission Goal, Vision Broward a community economic development partnership
o Memo
05-10-2005 11, 2005
o Article from The Sun-Sentinel: Title “Government, Capsule Comme Committee off to a go
th
J , 2005 Paper Copy Available
ffice of Management and Budget
D Available) Refer back to Dec. 15, 2004 Meeting for copy of CD.
……… e Kocy, Director of Broward County Office of Housing
Additi
o tey Kaletta, Chair of the Service Delivery
o f Tomorrow,” Edward Grayson,
“Overview of the County Budget” ……… Kayla Olsen, Director of O
(C
‘Affordable Housing’……… Jo
onal papers and /or materials provided at the June 8th Meeting:
“13th Annual Sterling Conference,” Pe
Subcommittee, Patricia West, Executive Director of MESC, May 31 –June 3, 2005 (Copy of CD Available)
o “Sterling Navigator,” The Florida Sterling Council, Karen E. Ryals, CEO, Achieve Tampa
Bay
“Employee Development Preparing for the Workforce o 06-01-2005
o Community Consolidated School District 15, “Charting the Course to Performance Excellence,” June 2005
“Integrating Organ
o izational Strategy, Core Processes, and the Individual Employee
o
o g to Dramatically Cut Costs, Raise Productivity, and Improve o
o
8/2003 Baldrige Recipient
Se e
Performance Evaluation System,” Robert H. Seemer, Executive Director, June 2, 2005 “Leadership by Process, Not Personality” Competitive Solutions, Inc.
o Competitive Solutions, Inc.; “Process Based Leadership, Manage Less, Accomplish More-
Practical Tools”
“32 Ways to Use Sterlin
Services,” Dr. James A. Zingale, 06-02-2005
“The Sterling Turnaround,” Steve E. Dickinson, 06-03-2005 o “Audit Score Summary”
“A Journey to Excellence In Two Organizations,” David Spong, President, Boeing Aerospace Support (Retired) 199
pt mber 14th, 2005
Additional papers and /or materials provided at the September 14th 2005 Meeting:
o Lett 07- 2005
o n issioners thru: Zachary
St cole Fontayne, Chief Information Officer, 7-12-2005 o e
N
er from the Town of Pembroke Park to Broward County Commissioners/Mayor 21-
I teroffice Memorandum To the Broward County Board of Comm
Williams Assistant County Administrator, (ITSBP) Broward County Information Technology rategic Business Plan Project Plan, Ni
R port to Full MESC Committee, September 14, 2005, Service Delivery Subcommittee
ovember 29th, 2005 (CD Available Only)
“W lm ………
Tony Carper, Director of Broward County Emergency Management i a Briefing” 11-29-2005………
January 11th, 2006 (Paper Copy Available)
“Broward County & the Sterling Management System” 1-11-2006 ……… County
The Sterling Approach to Organizational Development” 01-11-2006………
dditional papers and /or materials provided at the January 11 Meeting: “Dispa
easy,” Newsp
Author: Paul Davidson
Zachary Williams, Assistant County Administrator at Broward “
Christine Heflin, Organizational Development Coordinator, Human Resources Department, Coral Springs
th A
rate Radios create problem, Agencies can’t communicate during crises, but fix not aper Article: USA Today
Janu ry 25a th, 2006
dd o
D Redistricting in the Middle of a Decennial Census Period,” 1
o Sc Surveys, ETC Institute
o s
Fe ru
A itional papers and /or materials provided at the January 25th Meeting:
Memorandum From Jeffrey J. Newton, County Attorney, to Patricia Glasco West, Executive irector MESC, RE:
2-16-2005
ope of Work: Broward County MESC Customer
2006 State Legislative Program, Board of County Commissioner
b ary 8th 2006
/or materials provided at the February 8th 2006 Meeting:
“Rental-car gets push in Palm Beach County for Mass-transit funding,” Article from South Survey of the Development Community- Draft 2, ETC Institute
Broward County Survey of Contractors/Vendors- Draft 2, ETC Institute
o mmunity Leaders, complete survey to ensure recommendations from MESC
o
the County, Broward County Board of County Commissioners, 02/2006
Letter to Broward County Residents, complete survey to ensure that the County’s priorities are aligned with the needs of our residents, Broward County Board of County
Additional papers and
o
Florida Sun-Sentinel, Author: Anthony Man, 02-08-2006 o
o
o Schedule For the Developer/Vendor Surveys Letter to Co
reflect the needs of County’s development community, Broward County Board of County Commissioners, 02/2006
Letter to Broward County Vendors, complete survey to ensure recommendations from MESC reflect the needs of our external partners who provide services and supplies to o
Commissioners, 02/2006
March 8, 2006
Additional papers and /or materials provided at the March 8th 2006 Meeting:
Process, and Procedures, Finalized 03-08-06, Julia Trevarthen, Institute for Community Collaboration (ICC)
rt 3-08-2006
Weiss Serota Helfman Pastoriza Cole & Boniske, P.A., Re: Termination of Employee/ Employee Evaluations, February 28, 2006, Richard Weiss, Esq.
Memorandum to Shelley Eichner, Chair, Growth Management Subcommittee, from Susan L. hority Under the Broward County Charter, 03-07-2006
varthen, Re: Recommendations of the Growth Management Subcommittee, 03-07-2006 rom the MESC Service Delivery Subcommittee to Stacy Ritter, tey” Kaletta, Chair, MESC Service Delivery Subcommittee, 03-08-2006 “Some Residents to be Surveyed,” Article from Today’s Herald, 02-27, 2006
Broward County 2006 Employee Survey Results, Presented By ETC Institute, 03-2006
o Broward County Management and Efficiency Study Committee Affordable Housing Subcommittee, Draft Recommendations Concerning Finance,
o Broward Housing Partnership Strategic Solutions, 03-01-2006
o Broward County Management and Efficiency Study Committee Governance Subcommittee Repo
o o
Trevarthen and Johanna M. Lundgren, Re: Status of Municipal Platting Aut
o Memorandum to Shelley Eichner, Chair, Growth Management Subcommittee, from Susan L. Tre
o Interim Recommendations f Chair from: H.K “Pe
o o
o Interim Recommendations from the MESC Transportation Subcommittee to Stacey Ritter, Chair, Management & Efficiency Study Committee (MESC) from Rodney Rawls, Chair, MESC Transportation Subcommittee, 03-08-2006
April 4, 2006
“Seaport News” ………
dditional papers and /or materials provided at the April 4, 2006 on the tour:
Management & Efficiency Study Committee Port Tour, Tuesday, April 4th 2006 10:00am- 12:00pm
o
Full MESC Committee Tour, Port Everglades (CD Available)
A o
Map of Port Everglades, Broward County, Florida May 10, 2006:
Additional papers and /or materials provided at the May 10, 2006 Meeting:
s Matrix for Affordable Housing, Emergency o
ecommendations Concerning finance, Process, and Procedures o
o committee Inter-Office
and Efficiency Study Committee (Committee”)/Adjustment of County Commission District Boundaries – Proposed Charter Amendment, 05/08/2006 o Broward County Management & Efficiency Study Committee, Governance Subcommittee
Final Draft Recommendations Report, 05/08/2006
o ent & Efficiency Study Committee, Governance Subcommittee Final Draft Recommendations Report, 04/12/2006
o Memorandum to Shelley Eichner, Chair, Growth Management Subcommittee from Susan L. tions Regarding Improvements to the Planning, Zoning and Land Use Review and Permitting Process in o
ty Mass Transit Department,
ratransit Services, 05/03/2006 o MESC 2006 Subcommittee Recommendation
Preparedness, Governance, Growth Management, Service Delivery, and Transportation. Broward County Management and Efficiency Study Committee Affordable Housing Subcommittee Final R
04/11/2006
Emergency Preparedness Final Recommendations: Individuals, Municipalities, and County Management and Efficiency Study Committee Governance Sub
Memorandum No. 2006-02 to Ilene Lieberman, Chair- Governance Subcommittee Members of the Governance Subcommittee from Samuel S. Goren, Special Outside Counsel reference Management
Broward County Managem
Trevarthen, Esq. and Johanna M. Lundgren, Esq. reference Recommenda Broward County, 04/04/2006
Management & Efficiency Study Committee Service Delivery Subcommittee Draft Recommendations, 04/12/2006
o Recommended Version, Establishment of Broward Coun
Transportation Subcommittee of the Broward County Management and Efficiency Study Committee
o Transportation Subcommittee of the Broward County Management and Efficiency Study Committee, Current Recommendations
o Memorandum from Ed Wisniewski, Manager of Paratransit Services Broward County Transit to Patricia Glasco West, Executive Director, Management & Efficiency Study Committee Reference: Inquiry on Pa
o Broward County Management & Efficiency Study Committee (MESC) Final Report to be presented to the Broward County Board of County Commissioners on June 6, 2006
May 24, 2006:
itional papers and/or materials provided a
Add t the May 24, 2006 Meeting:
Broward County Management & Efficiency Study Committee Draft Final Report dated 2006
o
June 6,
o Copy of Management & Efficiency Study Committee 2005 Interim Report, 5-24-05
APPENDIX C MESC SUBCOMMITTEE MEETING MATRIX 2005-2006