Declaraciones sobre expectativas de la Dimensión de Bienes Tangibles:

McKane fu rth er develops th is argument w ithin h is 1986

81.

In other words, i f a text ex h ib its a correct

chronology towards historical events in Jeremiah's day, and

is similar to other sentiment expressed within the book of

Jeremiah, i t is arguable that the text also originates from

Jeremiah.

82.

William McKane, "Relations Between Poetry and

Prose In The Book Of Jeremiah With Special Reference To

Jeremiah III 6-11 And XII 14-17",

32 (1980), 220-

237.

commentary on J e r e m i a h .®4 He labels th e process which

had occurred with 3:1-13 an example of poetry "triggering"

or "generating" prose through the concept of a rolling

corpus th e o ry of t e x tu a l building w ith in Jeremiah.®®

McKane considers t h a t vv.14-17 have also been triggered by the existence of vv.1-13, th u s an example of poetry and

prose generating prose. V.18 presupposes the existence of

vv.14-17, and expands t h i s prose section, with the former section dating from th e exilic period, the la te r from the

p o s t- e x lll c period.®® Vv.19-25 are presented as being

words from Jeremiah®^ th o u g h th e y c o n s t i t u t e an

independent u n i t from vv.1-5, 12-13. Jeremiah 4:1-2 Is

considered an Independent unit authentic to Jeremiah.

In his 1979 work on dissonance th e o r y and th e prophetic t r a d iti o n s Robert Carroll makes a passing comment t h a t the poetic material within 3:l-4:2 Is most likely to be

asso cia te d w ith t h e e a r l i e s t p e rio d of J e r e m i a h 's

ministry.®® He ex pa nd s h i s comment In 1981 by

I d e n t i f y i n g t h e o r i g i n a l J e r e m ia n ic r e p e n ta n c e poem

materials (bound together by the thematic uses of the verb

64. William McKane, Jeremiah, Vol.I, ICC, T. &. T.

Clark, Edinburgh, 1986.

85. J b i d f ., 1x11, 64-69.

86. I D i d . , 76-77. V.18 Is considered to be an

attempt a t harmonization which will encompass both Israel

and Judah.

87. I D i d . , 77-83. McKane breaks t h i s u n i t Into

th r e e sections of speech from Yahweh (v v .1 9 -2 0 , 22a), th e

p ro p h et (V.21), and th e confession from th e p erson ifie d

community ( v v . 2 2 b - 2 5 ) .

88. Robert P. Carroll, When Prophecy Failed, SCM

miu) as being 3:1-5, 12b-13, 1 9 f 21-23; 4 :1-2.®9

C a rr o ll's 1966 J e r e m i a h c o m m e n t a r y 90 r e f l e c t s h i s

opinions concerning these verses from a broader research

base. He offers the possibility t h a t 3:12-4:2, because of

t h e i r usage of the aim material, might be a t t r i b u t e d to exilic circles which preached turning-repentance a f t e r the

d e s t r u c t i o n of Jerusalem.9i Vv.6-18 a r e t h e r e f o r e not

considered an Intrusion In the proposed poem of Stade (3:1-

5, 19f.). Thus vv.l2b-13, 19-20, 21-23, 4:1-2 a r e all

Independent poems which have been thematically grouped together, placed In t h e i r present configuration by a l a te r

editor. 3:1-5 relate to th e preceding Jeremianic discourse

of chapter 2, whereas 3:6-12a, 14-18 and 24-25 all date to

l a t e r r e d a c t l o n a l a c t i v i t y ,92 By proposing such a

stance, C arro ll extends himself beyond any previous

scholarly positions concerning the a u th e n tic ity and dating of t h i s section of Jeremiah.

Rainer Albertz’s 1982 consideration of Jeremiah 2-6 produces no new Insights into the possible dating of 3:1- 4:2.93 The major concern of his article Is to present a two phase chronology of the materials he considers were used

In t h e c o n s t r u c t i o n of J e r e m i a h 's f i r s t scro ll.9^

89. I d e m . , From Chaos to Covenant, SCM Press,

London, 1981, 73-74.

90. I d e m . , J e re m i a h , SCM Press, London, 1986. 91. I D i d . , 147.

92. I D i d . , 140-156.

93. Rainer Albertz, " J e r 2-6 und die F r u h z e i tv e r -

Kiindlgung Jeremias," Z A W 94 (1982), 20-47.

94. Following t h e examination of C. Rletzschel,

D a s P r o D l e m d e r U r r o l l e , G ûttersloher, Güttersloh, 1966, 130f., who considered the material which encompassed

Through a thematic analysis which seeks to catalogue