Capítulo 3. Modelos para la innovación, evaluación y diseño
3.2. Evaluación y análisis de material didáctico
1. BUILDING RELATED EVENTS
This table of events is not necessarily exhaustive. It is provided to support Stakeholders in the identification of the events rele- vant to their services.
HAZARD REF FUNCTION HAZARD OR EVENT
H-BU_1 Building ATC rooms Total loss of ATC roomsdue to object collision (aircraft, meteorite, vehicle...), severe damage of building
H-BU_2 Building ATC rooms Total loss of ATC roomsdue to weather conditions (earthquake, tornado, lightning, wind, snow, flooding ....) leading to evacuate the personnel of the building, severe damage of building
H-BU_3 Building ATC rooms Total loss of ATC roomsdue to hostile action leading to evacuate the personnel of the building
H-BU_4 Building ATC rooms Total loss of ATC roomsdue to chemical pollution, leading to loss of the staff H-BU_5 Building ATC rooms Total loss of ATC roomsdue to pollution (exterior fire smoke) leading to
evacuate the staff
H-BU_6 Building ATC rooms Total loss of ATC roomsdue to electromagnetic irradiation H-BU_7 Building ATC rooms Total loss of ATC roomsdue to :
- switch off of the Power Supply public network (failure) - strike of the Power Supply public network
H-BU_8 Building ATC rooms Partial loss of ATC operations due to noise
H-BU_9 Building ATC data communication Total loss of ATC data(voice, radar, network, phone, meteorology, others FIR’s) H-BU_10 Building ATC rooms Partial loss of ATC roomsdue to earthquake, vibration..., leading to a
degradation of the building facilities H-BU_11 Building ATC rooms Degraded conditions in ATC roomsdue to :
- turning off the potable Water Supply public network - strike of the Water Supply public network
H-BU-12 Building ATC rooms Degraded conditions for ATC roomsdue to fire personnel or emergency personnel (unavailability )
H-PS_1 Power Supply ATC rooms Total loss of power supplydue to : - water, fire, flood, earthquake, lightning, - equipment failures (wiring damages...) H-PS_2 Power Supply ATC rooms Partial loss of power supplydue to :
- water, fire, flood, earthquake, lightning - equipment failures (wiring damages ...) - micro breakdown
HAZARD REF FUNCTION HAZARD OR EVENT
H-WASU_1 Water Supply ATC rooms Total loss of the Water Supply functions:
Loss of the drinking and non-drinking (technical used) water supplies due to: - equipment or internal Water Supply network failures
- partial loss of Power Supply - fire, earthquake
H-WASU_2 Water Supply ATC rooms Partial loss of the Water Supply functions: Loss of the drinking water due to:
- equipment or internal Water Supply network failures - partial loss of Power Supply
- fire, earthquake
- internal Water Supply network pollution
H-HVAC_1 HVAC Total loss of HVAC: loss of the consoles ventilation, rooms ventilation, smokes extraction due to:
- fire
- partial loss of Power Supply - earthquake
- equipment or network failure
H-HVAC_2 HVAC Partial loss of HVAC functions : loss of the consoles ventilation due to: - partial loss of Power supply
- equipment or network failures - fire, earthquake
H-HVAC_3 HVAC Partial loss of HVAC functions: loss of the smokes extraction (in the ATC rooms and the escapes way) due to:
- partial loss of Fire Detection - partial loss of Power supply - equipment failures - fire, earthquake,
H-FIRE_1 Fire Protection ATC rooms Total loss of fire Protection functions : loss of Fire Prevention, fire detection, users and equipment protectiondue to:
- partial loss of Power supply - earthquake
- materials degradation - partial loss of the BMS
H-FIRE_2 Fire Protection ATC rooms Partial loss of the Fire Protection functions: loss of the fire prevention (included equipment protection) due to:
- materials degradation or equipment failure or degradation of protection means
HAZARD REF FUNCTION HAZARD OR EVENT
H-FIRE_3 Fire Protection ATC rooms Partial loss of the Fire Protection functions : loss of the fire detectiondue to: - partial loss of Power Supply
- partial loss of the BMS - equipment failure - earthquake
H-BMS_1 BMS Office Total loss of the BMS officedue to : - fire
- flood altering network
- network out of order (section cut-off )
leading to an inability to supervise, monitor and to control the equipment of the sub-systems.
H-BMS_2 BMS Office Total loss of the BMS officedue to:
- partial loss of Power supply acting on BMS room H-BMS_3 BMS Control function Partial loss of the BMSdue to a loss of control functions
(sub-systems elements failures, server failure, control station failures, loss of monitor functions.).
H-BMS_4 BMS Monitoring function Partial loss of the BMSdue to a total loss of the monitoring function (sub-systems elements failures, server failure, work station failure...) H-BMS_5 BMS Software Total loss of the BMSdue to a bug of the software
(main program generating a false alarm or unwarranted command...) - where the issue freezes or shuts down SW application,
BMS:Building Management system
2. ATM RELATED EVENTS
This table of events is not necessarily exhaustive. It is provided to support Stakeholders in the identification of the events rele- vant to their services
HAZARD ID FUNCTION HAZARD/EVENT
H-RDP-1. MRT Total loss of MRT (Multi Radar Tracker) within centre for more than X seconds (fallback available)
H-RDP-2. MRT Total loss of MRT (Multi Radar Tracker) within centre for more than Y seconds with fallback unavailable
H-RDP-3. Fallback Total loss of Surveillance fallback for more than X’ H-RDP-4. Correlation Total loss of track correlation for more than X’
H-RDP-5. By-Pass Total loss of all radar by-pass
H-RDP-6. By-Pass Loss of one radar by-pass
H-RDP-7. SSR code Total loss of SSR code management
H-ODS-1. ODS- Maps Total loss of maps at one ACC-CWP
H-ODS-2. ODS- Maps Total loss of maps at one ACC-sector
H-ODS-3. ODS- Maps Total loss of maps at one APP-CWP or sector
H-ODS-4. ODS- Maps Total loss of maps in ACC
H-ODS-5. ODS- Maps Total loss of maps in APP
H-ODS-6. ODS -QNH Total loss of QNH on APP-CWP
H-ODS-7. ODS Total loss of one ODS of a sector
H-ODS-8. ODS Total loss of all ODS of a sector
H-ODS-9. ODS Total loss of all ODS of a Centre
H-NET-1. STCA Total loss of STCA for more than 30 sec.
H-NET-2. MSAW Total loss of MSAW for more than 1 min.
H-NET-3. AIWS-DAIW Total loss of DAIW for more than 30 sec. H-R&P-1. REC&PLB Loss of Record & Replay
HAZARD ID FUNCTION HAZARD/EVENT
H-FDP-2. FDM Total loss of FDM (Flight Data Management) for more than 3 hrs
H-FDP-3. CWP-FDP Total or partial loss of 1 CWP for more than one FDP data up-date (10 sec) H-COM-1. A/G COM Total loss of A/G COM for more 10 sec. of the frequency one sector
with G/G COM available
H-COM-2. A/G COM Total loss of A/G COM for more 10 sec. of all frequencies of the centre (main, reserve, emergency) with G/G COM available
H-COM-3. A/G COM Total loss of A/G COM for more 10 sec. of all frequencies of the centre (main, reserve, emergency) with G/G COM unavailable
H-COM-4. A/G COM Partial loss of A/G COM (total loss of transmission of 1 sector) with G/G COM available
H-COM-5. A/G COM Partial loss of A/G COM (total loss of transmission of multiple sectors) with G/G COM available
H-COM-6. A/G COM Partial loss of A/G COM (total loss of reception of 1 sector) with G/G COM available
H-COM-7. COM A/G Partial loss of A/G COM (total loss of reception of multiple sectors) with G/G COM available
H-COM-8. COM G/G Total or partial loss of G/G COM for more than 10 min. one sector with A/G COM available
H-COM-9. COM G/G Total or partial loss of G/G COM for more than 10 min. of all G/G comm. multiple sectors with A/G COM and OLDI available
H-COM-10. COM G/G Total or partial loss for more than 10 min. of all G/G comm. of the centre with A/G COM available and OLDI unavailable
H-COM-11. COM G/G Total loss of OLDI with one centre for more than 6’ H-COM-12. COM G/G Total loss of OLDI with all centre for more than 6’
H-COM-13. COM G/G Total loss of CFMU connection
H-SUP-1. SUP Total loss of Operational supervision