CAPÍTULO 4 ORIENTACIÓN TEÓRICA
5.2. D ISEÑO Y FASES DE LA INVESTIGACIÓN
5.2.3. Fase de recogida de datos
The years of the Iran-Iraq War were not the only period in recent Iraqi history in which instability, political repression, and violence have placed constraints on the lives of Iraqi writers and played a role in the nature of fiction being written in Iraq. One
236 Mohsen, 10.
237 Hanoosh, 399-400 and 399, n.84. 238 Al-Musawi, Reading Iraq, 94.
scholar has even referred to the collective Iraqi experience in recent decades as “a historical nightmare and a horror serial.”239 The years that followed the Iran-Iraq War,
however, are notable for their violence: the 1990 occupation of Kuwait; the Gulf War in
1991, followed by a widespread Shiʿī uprising in southern Iraq and its suppression by
the regime; the years of embargo (1991-2003); the destruction caused by the U.S.-led invasion in 2003; and the years of chaos, civil war, and violence that followed.
The sanctions era (1991-2003) witnessed a shift in Iraq’s cultural landscape, causing “the iron fist…to loosen[…] its grip,” as ṢaddāmḤusayn’s oldest son ʿUdayy was put in charge of several official cultural organizations.240ʿUdayy removed many writers
of the 60s generation from their posts and absorbed younger outsiders into the state apparatus. Yasmine Hanoosh attributes this shift in part to a greater attention paid by the outside world—including new Gulf media and Western academics—to marginalized Iraqi voices.241 Internally, it also reflected the growing disjuncture between Iraqis and
the regime that had failed to impose hegemony over them: as Muhsin al-Musawi expresses it, “the masses no longer had a vested interest in a system that, to use
239 Ferial J. Ghazoul, “Iraqi Short Fiction: The Unhomely at Home and Abroad,” in Journal of Arabic Literature 35, no. 1 (2004): 1.
240 Mohsen, 22. 241 Hanoosh, 394.
Fanon’s words, expelled them from history.”242 Al-Musawi’s view of the Baʿthist state’s
failure to impose hegemony over the Iraqi populace contrasts with an earlier
conception of Baʿthist Iraq as a uniquely totalitarian state that used fear to ensure the
silent consent of Iraqis, a view associated most closely with Kanan Makiya and his 1998 book Republic of Fear, and which scholars have more recently come to reject.243
The weakening of the regime’s authority during the embargo years had an emboldening effect on the Iraqi literary field: the regime’s censorship apparatus weakened sufficiently that writers on the inside were able to produce writing that Fatima Mohsen terms “resistance” literature, although they avoided direct
confrontation with the regime through the use of symbols and indirect narrative.244
The high cost of printed books due to the embargo led to the phenomenon of the “photocopy book,” in which self-published and pirated texts circulated on the black market. The result was an informal circulation of literature that escaped the notice and control of state censorship.245 At the same time, the extended period of sanctions
242 Al-Musawi, Reading Iraq, 88.
243 Kanan Makiya, Republic of Fear: The Politics of Modern Iraq (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1989; Revised edition: 1998). For a summation of the arguments against Makiya’s view, see Achim Rohde, “Revisiting the Republic of Fear: Lessons for Research on Contemporary Iraq,” in Iraq Between Occupations:
Perspectives from the 1920s to the Present, edited by Amatzia Baram, Achim Rohde, and Ronen Zeidel (New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2010), 129-141.
244 Mohsen, 6. 245 Hanoosh, 397.
coupled with decades of authoritarian rule led to “aridness” and “fatigue” in Iraqi culture, which drove many prominent Iraqi writers who came of age during the 1990s—
such as ʿAlī Badr (b. 1977) and Ḥasan Blāsim (b. 1973)—to leave Iraq during that period, or soon after the 2003 occupation.246
The decades of authoritarianism, war, and economic isolation inevitably had an impact on the nature of Iraqi fiction as well, as a number of scholars have pointed out. In contrast to the realism that predominated in previous decades, Ferial Ghazoul says that recent Iraqi fiction
has veered towards the fantastic, the surrealist, the Kafkaesque, the labyrinthine, the uncanny, not out of renunciation of the real, but out of verisimilitude… [C]onfidence in a hopeful future has given way to a consciousness of the absurd and monstrous.247
In a separate essay, Ghazoul links the “excesses and contradictions in Iraqi culture” to the prominence of the “fantastic” and the “strange” in contemporary Iraqi fictional discourse.248 In this essay, she encapsulates this sense of displacement and strangeness
(“the unfamiliar experienced as familiar”) as being “uncanny” (borrowing a translation
246 Mohsen, 20.
247 Ferial Ghazoul, “A Forest of Symbols: Iraqi Fiction Today,” in Banipal 14 (2002): 3-4. 248 Ghazoul, “The Unhomely at Home and Abroad,” 1.
of Freud’s term Unheimlich.)249 The Iraqi critic Fāḍil Thāmir also noted an experimental
and fantastic turn in Iraqi literature in the late 1980s and early 1990s, pointing out that many of its proponents were older writers from the 1960s and 1970s generations, including Khuḍayyir. For Thāmir, the turn towards the fantastic was “marked by an attempt to return to legend, history, and fantasy, and sometimes has recourse in making use of storytelling and classical (turāthiyya) language.”250
To be sure, the fantastic mode draws on much older sources. Iraqi critic Qays
Kāẓim al-Janābī links the fantastic mode to ancient Mesopotamian myth, magical
realism, and the tradition of visions in Iraqi fiction, by means of which “new narrative writings attempt [to] transcend a narrative account through the use of the tools of intertextuality and suggestion.”251 Ghazoul describes the fantastic as an “irruption” of
pre-modern narrative elements into contemporary fiction: it offers a range of motifs that serves as “both an aesthetic quest and a political camouflage,” as a way to avoid censorship.252 But even if fantastic motifs draw on earlier narrative traditions, their
249 Ibid., 2.
250Fāḍil Thāmir, al-Maqmūʿ wa-l-maskūt ʿanhu fī l-sard al-ʿarabī(Damascus: Dār al-Madā, 2004), 225. 251Qays Kāẓim al-Janābī, al-Riwāya al-ʿirāqiyya al-muʿāṣira: anmāṭ wa-muqārabāt(Damascus: Manshūrāt ittiḥād al-kuttāb al-ʿarab, 2012), 157-58.
presence in contemporary Iraqi fiction, along with tragic, paranoid, and absurd elements, also reflect the crises that have marked Iraqi life at least since the 1980s.