CARACTERÍSTICAS DE LA EVALUACIÓN
DE LA INSTITUCIÓN EDUCATIVA INVESTIGADA 70.59/100 B BUENO
5.2. INTERPRETACIÓN Y DISCUSIÓN DE LOS RESULTADOS.
Issues in initiating and expanding the use of Issues in initiating and expanding the use of nuclear power
nuclear power
Group 9: included 4 fellows from developing countries
Group 9: included 4 fellows from developing countries
Issues of Focus Issues of Focus
Timescales
Human resources and training Technology support
and organization
Fuel supply
security Funding and economics Costs
Available
Technology Regulatory aspects
Public information
Used fuel and waste management Decommissioning
Legislation
HR & Training HR & Training
••
Already difficult for developed Already difficult for developed countries and will be even countries and will be even more difficult for newmore difficult for new programs
programs
••
Knowledge database and Knowledge database andeducation are vital to starting education are vital to starting a nuclear program
a nuclear program
••
Essential for developing a Essential for developing a safety culturesafety culture
Technology Support & Organization Technology Support & Organization
••
Need experienced sources of Need experienced sources of technical support fortechnical support for regulatory and operating regulatory and operating
••
Necessary to become selfNecessary to become self--reliantreliant
••
Closely related to HR issueClosely related to HR issueFuel Supply Security Fuel Supply Security
••
Uncertainties with Uncertainties withfuture demand and supply future demand and supply
••
Highly political, even within Highly political, even within NPT countriesNPT countries
••
Investment is necessaryInvestment is necessaryPWR fuel assembly
Main Challenges for NNRA Main Challenges for NNRA
•• Public acceptance Public acceptance
•• Type of reactors to license Type of reactors to license
•• Training of personnel Training of personnel
Advantages and disadvantages of fuel Advantages and disadvantages of fuel reprocessing
reprocessing
•• Is spent fuel a waste or resource? Is spent fuel a waste or resource?
•• Contentious due to proliferation and security concerns Contentious due to proliferation and security concerns
Nuclear Education and Training Nuclear Education and Training
••
Renewed and growing interest in nuclear power globally has made Renewed and growing interest in nuclear power globally has made the acquisition and preservation of nuclear knowledge and training a the acquisition and preservation of nuclear knowledge and training a sine qua non for sustainability of the nuclear energy growthsine qua non for sustainability of the nuclear energy growth
••
Both developed and developing countries experience NKM problemsBoth developed and developing countries experience NKM problems••
Developed countries suffer from ageing resource persons for Developed countries suffer from ageing resource persons for effective knowledge transfer and preservationeffective knowledge transfer and preservation
••
Developing countries have capacity building, brainDeveloping countries have capacity building, brain--drain, inadequate drain, inadequate access from the centres of “competence to centres of growth”access from the centres of “competence to centres of growth”
Labor / Skill-to-Craft
Technical / Engineering
Operations
Management Staff / Project Managers Vocational Programs
Other Industries (Transition Programs)
Engineering Programs (Universities) (Existing)
Engineering Programs (No Current Program)
Transition Program for Degreed Engineers
Model of Curriculum
Partnership Programs (Nuclear Industry
-University Relationships) Accreditation Program
(W ANO, INPO)
Transition Model
Partnerships (Potentially International)
Transition Model
Developing and Maintaining the Nuclear Developing and Maintaining the Nuclear Workforce
Workforce
Challenges for new builds Challenges for new builds
••
International politicsInternational politics••
Human Resources (trainers, technical staff)Human Resources (trainers, technical staff)••
Knowledge ManagementKnowledge Management••
Time Horizon Time Horizon••
Language and cultural barriers for international initiativesLanguage and cultural barriers for international initiatives••
Embedding safety culture in all areasEmbedding safety culture in all areas••
FundingFunding••
Standardization & AdministrationStandardization & AdministrationLessons learnt Lessons learnt
••
Canada has robust nuclear education institutions and nuclear industry that Canada has robust nuclear education institutions and nuclear industry that has covered almost all the nuclear fuel cyclehas covered almost all the nuclear fuel cycle
••
Nuclear education and knowledge management is a serious impediment to Nuclear education and knowledge management is a serious impediment to nuclear renaissance most especially for developing countriesnuclear renaissance most especially for developing countries
••
Licensing of NPPs is a Herculean task that requires a multidisplinary Licensing of NPPs is a Herculean task that requires a multidisplinary regulatory Authorityregulatory Authority
••
Effective public communication is very vital to the development and Effective public communication is very vital to the development and sustenance of nuclear power programsustenance of nuclear power program
••
Language is an important factor in nuclear education, technology transfer Language is an important factor in nuclear education, technology transfer and trainingand training
••
Cooperation between regulators and operators through internship creates Cooperation between regulators and operators through internship creates synergy and enhances competence of regulatory authoritiessynergy and enhances competence of regulatory authorities
••
The forum issues unraveled a host of challenges for the present and future The forum issues unraveled a host of challenges for the present and future use of nuclear energyuse of nuclear energy
Recommendations Recommendations
••
NNRA Should Embrace the Multilateral Design Evaluation Program( NNRA Should Embrace the Multilateral Design Evaluation Program(MDEP) to enhance multilateral cooperation and knowledge in MDEP) to enhance multilateral cooperation and knowledge in design and regulation of nuclear reactors
design and regulation of nuclear reactors
••
The NNRA may wish to establish a unit for international cooperation The NNRA may wish to establish a unit for international cooperation for capacity building and technology transferfor capacity building and technology transfer
••
The NNRA may wish to explore areas of nuclear cooperation with The NNRA may wish to explore areas of nuclear cooperation with the Canadian stakeholders in nuclear energy on capacity building the Canadian stakeholders in nuclear energy on capacity building for its regulators amongst othersfor its regulators amongst others
••
The NNRA may wish to considers the ten forum issues for its weekly The NNRA may wish to considers the ten forum issues for its weekly seminarsseminars
••
The NNRA may wish to explore areas of cooperation with the WNUThe NNRA may wish to explore areas of cooperation with the WNU••
The NNRA may wish to send its Regulatory Personnel to CERT The NNRA may wish to send its Regulatory Personnel to CERT Zaria for a long term internshipZaria for a long term internship