SUBCAPÍTULO VI: LA VARIACIÓN DE LA TENENCIA, JUSTIFICADA
6.2. Razones que justifican la utilización del SAP como causal para variar
6.3.1. En la jurisprudencia
PREMIER GRADE LEADING POINT SCORERS
Surname First Name Club Try Conversions Penalty Drop Goal Total
Collis David Brothers 8 43 11 159
Milroy Marshall Gold Coast 10 35 8 1 147
Stains Nathan Sunnybank 13 28 121
Mandrusiak Tyrone Souths 1 27 17 110
Burton Kris Norths-QUT 2 14 16 86
Lyons Chris University 34 4 80
Dunn Courtney Gold Coast 14 70
McCarthy Shaun Wests 2 18 8 70
Sauer Anthony Brothers 13 65
FINALS RESULTS
Premier Grade Finals
Major Semi-Final Gold Coast d Sunnybank 28 17
Minor Semi-Final University d Brothers 35 13
Preliminary Final University d Sunnybank 44 30
Grand Final Gold Coast d University 24 18
Lower Grade Grand Finals
Premier 2nd Grade Sunnybank d Gold Coast 40 12
Premier Under 19 Brothers d GPS 31 24
Division 1 1st Grade University d Logan City 23 19
Division 1 2nd Grade Souths d Easts 26 15
Division 1 3rd Grade University d Easts 26 10
Division 2 1st Grade Woogaroo d Black Rhinos 18 14
Division 2 2nd Grade Black Rhinos d Brisbane Harlequins 17 15
Division 3 1st Grade Browns Plains d Everton Park 9 5
Division 3 Normanby Cup St Leo's Old Boys d Easts Longhorns 13 12
Division 3 Wyatt Cup Logan City d PIDA 16 13
Division 1 Colts 1st Grade University d Brothers 24 22
Division 1 Colts 2nd Grade Brothers d GPS 35 14
Division 2 Colts 1st Grade Souths d Redlands 37 19
Division 1 Women University d Norths-QUT 18 17*
* Grand Final awarded to Norths-QUT on appeal for breach of Competition Rules
PREMIER GRADE COMPETITION POINTS
Team Play Win Lost 4+Tries Lst-7 Draw For Against Points
Gold Coast 16 13 3 11 2 0 672 292 65 Sunnybank 16 11 5 14 0 0 623 427 58 University 16 11 5 10 2 0 627 301 56 Brothers 16 11 5 8 2 0 547 338 54 Souths 16 9 7 5 2 0 410 370 43 GPS 16 7 9 7 3 0 417 439 38 Wests 16 5 11 5 4 0 351 449 29 Easts 16 5 11 5 2 0 402 455 27 Norths-QUT 16 0 16 1 0 0 169 1147 1
WELSBY CUP HORSLEY CUP
Sunnybank Gold Coast
XXXX Medal COLT OF THE YEAR
BROTHERS
The 2004 season was one of the most successful years in the past decade for Brothers rugby.
Player retention and strengths have been continually improving across all Grades and Colts teams. The dedication and enthusiasm shown by all coaches, managers and team volunteers created a winning environment throughout the Club.
We were rewarded with winning the Premier Grade pre-season competition, The Athenian Cup. Apart from helping our cash flow, the win against Easts set the scene for the rest of the rugby year.
Colts 1, 2 and 3 were minor premiers; Colts 1 and 3 won the premiership against GPS; Colts 2 were narrowly defeated 24-22 by University.
Division 1, 3rd Grade missed out on the finals on for and against (2 points) after finishing equal fourth on the table.
Division 1, 2nd Grade looked good in round one but with injuries and a couple of close results, fell away in round two.
Division 1, 1st Grade were knocked out in the preliminary final.
Premier 2nd Grade – did not make semi-finals. Normanby Cup – did not make semi-finals.
Premier 1st Grade were instrumental in bringing back the crowds to Crosby – they played superb attacking rugby, their defence was excellent. They were defeated by University in the knock-out semi-final at Ballymore.
Congratulations to all players, coaches, managers and volunteers – thank you for your tremendous efforts.
Congratulations to the following players who were selected for representative honours:
• Elton Flatley – Australia
• David Croft – Australia
• Elton Flatley, David Croft, Sean Hardman – Queensland Reds Super 12
BR O T H E RS R U G B Y CL UB F AC ERE E T DO CE RE QUEENSLAND R UGBY ANNU AL REPOR T 2003 – 2004
CLUB REPORTS
32
2004 Doughty Shield Easts 773 University 764 Brothers 685 Wests 587 Souths 579 Sunnybank 575 GPS 469 Gold Coast 421 Logan City 345 Redlands 166 PIDA 150 Murrumba 134 Black Rhinos 132 Wynnum 118 Norths-QUT 116 Beenleigh 114 Woogaroo 98 Brisbane Harlequins 83 Riverview 79 Ipswich 67 Browns Plains 61 Bayside Barbarians 61 St Leo's 61 Everton Park 49Gold Coast Eagles 48
Medicals 48 Brisbane Irish 45 Beaudesert 38 Vet Science 28 Pine Rivers 24 Lismore 17 Kenmore 17 Twin Rivers 5
QUEENSLAND R UGBY ANNU AL REPOR T 2003 – 2004
33
• David Croft, Anthony Sauer, David Collis, Darren Murphy, Zane Hilton, Brendan Gabbett – Queensland XV
• Tahjon Milata, Scott Daruda – Australian Under 19 (World Cup)
• Damien Steele, Alistair McLay, Mitchell Barnaba, Nathanuel Gendle, Lachlan Burke –
Queensland 19 (B’s)
• Anthony Sauer, Damon Murphy, Simon Price, David Collis, Darren Murphy, Zane Hilton –
Australian Barbarians
• Gerard Leyden – Australian University
A personal thank you to Paul Mills – Paul did an outstanding job throughout the year and hopefully in our Centenary year he will be rewarded with the
2005 premiership.
The club facilities are still under review, the Board is currently considering proposals
from Sports Medicos, Day-care operators and our current lessee – Derek Hume – Crosby’s at Brothers.
With respect to the grounds, the training and warm-up facilities are currently being extended, the new areas will be filled, top soiled and seeded and will be ready for season 2005.
With our junior club, we continue to work closely in terms of cost sharing for our grounds and facilities, continue to seek economies of scale where appropriate and generally are working more closely together for the benefit of all parties.
2005 is Brothers’ Centenary Year – it will be a special year. Our events committee has been operating for some time under the chairmanship of Dick McGruther. Programmes are going into place and will involve kicking off the year with the Fish Festival (February); other events will include Team Reunions, Dinners, Back to Crosby
events, traditional Brothers versus University match and much more. John Druery is compiling a Centenary Book – the 100 Years of Brothers. The Centenary Year will finish off with the tour to Argentina and Ireland.
In conclusion, I want to thank all members of the Board, players, coaches, managers, volunteers and supporters for all your hard work and dedication.
Thank you for the privilege of being President of Brothers Old Boys Rugby Club
Ross McKellar
EASTS
It was another very successful year for the Tigers both on and off the field.
The Senior club fielded 14 sides in the Brisbane competition while the Junior club had over 700 players and developed a strong satellite club called Riverside based at Bulimba.
While the results of the Premier Grade were not indicative of their effort, six other Senior sides contested semi-finals with three of them going through to Grand Finals. Unfortunately, all lost their Grand Finals. Easts Longhorns, Division One 2nd grade and Division One 3rd grade were the Grand Final sides.
The strength of the club can be summed up by the fact that for the second year running, Easts won the Doughty Challenge shield to be crowned as the champion club in Brisbane.
The Premier grade side was a very young one this year and the improved results in the last few weeks have set a good platform for a successful 2005. A highlight of the season was beating Grand Finalists
University 24-20 in the second round. This game showed the potential of the side and should give them confidence for the future.
Several Easts players made representative sides this year. A special mention to Gene Fairbanks who has been contracted for the next two seasons to the ACT Brumbies. Other representative players were:
AUSTRALIAN 7’S
• Ben Mowen • Gene Fairbanks
QLD A
• Ben Mowen • Ben Spearritt
Australian U-19’s
• Sean Fell • Dom Fuller • Matt Brandon
QAS U-19’s
• Chris Hanley • Sam Satui • Lachlan Morgan • David Lucas • Sean Fell • Ian Suela
• Dom Fuller • Matt Brandon • Ben Greentree
QLD WOMEN’S TEAM
• Selena Worsley • Ari Lambert • Crystal Murray • Mel Dark
Off the field, the club continues to work on its facilities to cater for the large number of teams that we have. A real positive has been the approval of a $50,000 grant from the Brisbane City Council to light Field 3 for training. This will be a huge help to the club.
Finally, I would like to thank all of the Coaches, Managers and other volunteers for their efforts throughout the year. Ryan O’Grady, our development officer and Natalie Coward, our clubhouse manager also deserve special mention for their efforts throughout the year. I would also like to thank David Eagle who finished as the club’s Rugby Manager in June. David
has been with the club for three years and we wish him well in his new venture.
Grant Hanhan President
GOLD COAST BREAKERS
Setting standards is the Breakers ethos and the Club certainly achieved that this year.
After contesting and losing Grand Finals in 2001 and 2003 against the Canberra Vikings the Gold Coast Breakers Premier 1 team, after taking out the minor
premiership, defeated University 24 – 18 in a very hard fought Telstra Premier Rugby Grand Final to cap off a fantastic season.
G OL D CO AS T RUGBY UNION