testing laboratories
Robert W. Góra Institute of Physical and Theoretical Chemistry Wrocław University of Technology
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results Key factors determining correctness and reliability of the
results
ISO/IEC 17025 standard identifies the key factors that determine the correctness and reliability of the tests and/or calibrations performed by a laboratory. These include:
• technical competence of personnel,
• accommodation and environmental conditions,
• validation of the methods,
• traceability of measurements,
• calibration and maintenance of the test equipment,
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results
6.89 Personnel
• The laboratory management shouldensure the competenceof all its personnel performing specific tasks. Competence of staff should bereviewed and re-assessedon a regular basis.
• The laboratory should have apolicy and procedures for identifying training needsand providing training of personnel. The goals in this respect should be clearly formulated.
• The laboratory should use personnel who areemployed by, or under contract to, the laboratoryand maintain current job descriptions for managerial, technical and key support personnel involved in tests and/or calibrations.
• Staff should be qualifiedon the basis of appropriate education, training, experience and/or demonstrated skills, as required.
• Personnel should be authorizedto perform particular types of sampling, test and/or calibration, to issue test reports and calibration certificates, to give opinions and interpretations and to operate particular types of equipment.
• When using staff who are undergoing training or are contracted, appropriatesupervisionmust be provided.
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results Accommodation and environmental conditions
• The laboratory should ensure that theenvironmental
conditions do not invalidate the resultsor adversely affect
the required quality of any measurement.
• The laboratory shouldmonitor, control and record
environmental conditionsas required by the relevant
specifications, methods and procedures or where they influence the quality of the results.
• Depending on the technical activities concerned, due
attention should be paid, for instance, to:
• biological sterility,
• dust,
• electromagnetic disturbances and electrical supply,
• radiation,
• humidity and temperature,
• sound and vibration levels.
• There must beeffective separationbetween neighboring
areas in which there are incompatible activities toprevent
cross-contamination.
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results
6.91 Some Specific Considerations for Chemical and
Microbiological Testing26
In the case of chemical analysis, thecross contamination
between samples and possible environmental contamination of
samplesare likely to be the key concern – particularly for the
substances which are being tested for at trace levels. Although, it is quite common to monitor the temperature of
chemistry laboratories, this is rarely necessary.In practice, the
variations in modern borosilicate volumetric glassware over a temperature range in which personnel will be comfortable is negligible relative to other sources of uncertainty of
measurements.
The only reason for monitoring the temperature is that data will be affected if a specific range of temperature is not observed. This might be the case for some precision scientific instruments. For instance the ICP-MS environment must be free of dust, corrosive vapors and vibration, and maintained at a cool and stable
temperature (typically 18-23◦C with less than 2◦C drift per hour).
26Complying with ISO 17025. A practical guidebook. United Nations
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results Some Specific Considerations for Chemical and
Microbiological Testing27
The following general rules should be observed for good practice in general chemical testing work:
• Only very diluted solutions of standards necessary for the equipment calibration should be ever introduced into areas where the samples are being handled and processed.
• Precautions should be taken to avoid spillage of standards.
• The preparations (and possibly testing) of samples containing high levels and low levels of the same targets should be carried out in well separated rooms with their own glassware.
• Enforce good housekeeping and tidiness by general management pressure.
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results
6.93 Some Specific Considerations for Chemical and
Microbiological Testing28
In the case of microbiological laboratories, the potentialspillage should also be easily contained and thoroughly cleaned up. Impervious bench tops with good seals against walls and floor and around fittings such as sinks are expected and floors should be continuous sealed surfaces.
Microbiology laboratories will often need to beair-conditioned
with split type units and all windows sealed to prevent opening.
Entry to the laboratory should always bedouble doored with a
vestibuleand changing/washing area.
28Complying with ISO 17025. A practical guidebook. United Nations
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results Some Specific Considerations for Chemical and
Microbiological Testing29
The laboratory must keep the reference cultures of organisms for control purposes. The following precautions help to avoid contamination:
• Clear segregation of samples, references and media storage.
• Segregated area for handling the references, ideally with a laminar flow cabinet.
• Dedicated laboratory coats and footwear with a changing area where staff can wash.
• A planned cleaning regime for the laboratory, covering benches, floors, windows, light fittings, ventilation grills, air conditioners, water baths and autoclaves.
• Documented procedures for dealing with spillages and records of spillages and action taken.
• Monitoring temperature and humidity: limits need not be stringent but humidity above 50% and temperatures above 25◦C can lead to problems of mould growth.
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results
6.95 Test and calibration methods and method validation
Selection of Methods
• The laboratory should use appropriate test or calibration
methods (including methods for sampling)which meet the
requirements of the clientand, where possible,methods
published as national, regional or international standards, by reputable technical organizations or in relevant
scientific texts or journals.
• If it is necessary to employ non-standard methods, these
should be fullyvalidated and documentedto show that
they are appropriate and fit for purpose. These must be also agreed with the client.
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results Laboratory-Developed and Non-Standard Methods
For new methods, procedures should be developed containing at least the following information:
• appropriate identification and scope,
• description of the type of item to be tested or calibrated,
• parameters or quantities and ranges to be determined,
• apparatus and equipment, including technical performance requirements,
• reference standards and reference materialsrequired,
• environmental conditions required and any stabilization period needed,
• description of the procedure, including preparation of items, calibration and adjustment of the equipment before the use and the methods of recording the results,
• criteria and/or requirements for approval/rejection, data to be recorded and the method of analysis and presentation,
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results
6.97 Validation of methods
• Validation is the confirmation by examination and the
provision of objective evidence that the particular requirements for a specific intended use are fulfilled.
• In order to confirm that the methods arefit for the intended
use, the laboratory must validate:
• non-standard methods,
• laboratory-designed/developed methods,
• standard methods used outside their intended scope, and amplifications and modifications of standard methods
• Although it is not necessary for the laboratory to validate
standard methods used within their intended scope,the
laboratory must confirm that it can properly operate
standard methodsbefore introducing the tests or
calibrations. If the standard method changes, the confirmation should be repeated.
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results Validation of methods
• The validation should be as extensive as it is necessary to
meet the intended requirements. Generally it should demonstrate:
• the scope of applicability in terms of samples and numerical range,
• selectivity,
• robustness in use,
• accuracy, precision and bias,
• linearity, detection limit (LOD), and limit of quantitation (LOQ)
• limit of repeatability and/or reproducibility,
• the expanded uncertainty for a specified level of confidence.
• The laboratory shouldrecord the results and the
procedureused for the validation, and astatement as to
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results
6.99 Estimation of measurement uncertainty
• Calibration and testinglaboratories should have and apply procedures for estimating uncertainty of measurements.
• However, in certain cases the nature of the test method may preclude rigorous, metrologically and statistically valid, calculation of measurement uncertainty. In these cases the
testing laboratory should at least attempt to identify all the components of uncertainty and make a reasonable estimation.
• When estimating the uncertainty of measurement, all uncertainty components which are of importance in a given situation should be taken into account usingappropriate methods of analysis.
The Guide to the Expression of Uncertainty in Measurement
(GUM)30is recognized by EA as the master document on
measurement uncertainty.31.
30Guide to the Expression of Uncertainty in Measurement. BIPM, IEC, IFCC,
ISO, IUPAC, IUPAP, OIML. International Organization for Standardization, 1995.
31EA-4/16 (rev.00), EA Guidelines on the Expression of Uncertainty in
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results Control of Technical Records . . . Again
• All calculations and data transfers in the laboratory must be subject to appropriate checks in a systematic manner.
• Anyin-house softwarefor acquisition and processing of data (including spreadsheets)must be documented and validatedfor the intended use.
• Procedures forprotecting the datashould be established and implemented.
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results
6.101 Equipment
ISO 17025 requires a complete history of each piece ofequipment, understood to encompass any items which may affect the validity of measurements or calibrations. This includes the detailed records of the following activities required by this standard:
• Checks and calibrationscarried out before the equipment is placed in
service and its unique identification.
• Checks carried out tomaintain confidence in the calibration statusof the
equipment, according to a defined procedure.
• Authorization of personneland provision of any relevant instructions and
manuals which should be readily available for use.
• Documentation and implementation of theprocedures for handling, use
and maintenance of the measuring equipment.
• Service of the equipmentthat has been shown to be defective or outside
the specified limits and analysis of the potential influence on previous
tests and/or calibrations (control of nonconforming work).
• Indication of the status of calibration.
• The equipment should be under permanent control of the laboratory.
When, for whatever reason, it goes outside its direct control it must be
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results Equipment records
ISO 17025 specifically requires maintenance of the following records for each item of the equipment and its software:
• the identity of the item of equipment and its software,
• the manufacturer’s name, type identification, and serial number or other unique identification,
• checks that the equipment complies with the specification,
• the current location, where appropriate,
• the manufacturer’s instructions, if available, or reference to their location,
• dates, results and copies of the reports and certificates of all calibrations, adjustments, acceptance criteria, and the due date of the next calibration,
• the maintenance plan, where appropriate, and maintenance carried out to date,
• any damage, malfunction, modification or repair to the equipment.
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results
6.103 Metrological Traceability
“Metrological traceability is property of a
measurement result whereby the result can be related
to a reference through adocumented unbroken chain
of calibrations, each contributing to the measurement uncertainty.”a
aVIM, International vocabulary of metrology — Basic and general concepts
and associated terms. Joint Committee for Guides in Metrology (JCGM).
Measurement traceability in Testing and Calibration Laboratories
Laboratories are required to implement a calibration system which ensures that the results of any tests or calibrations performed are comparable with those of any other laboratory.
The key element of such a system is themetrological
traceabilityof any measurement through anunbroken chain of
comparisonsto a recognizedinternational standard for the
measurandin question which, wherever possible, is required to
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra Introduction and Historical Outline From Statistical Process Control to Total Quality Management ISO 9000 standards Conformity Assessment QMS in Calibration and Testing Laboratories Technical requirements for calibration and testing laboratories
Personnel and Environmental Conditions Test and Calibration Methods Equipment and Measurement Traceability Sampling and Handling of Test and Calibration Items Quality Assurance of tests and calibrations. Reporting the results Calibration Hierarchy.
There is an establishedcalibration hierarchy.32
At theinternational level, decisions concerning theInternational System of Units (SI)and the realization of the primary standards are taken by theConférence Générale des Poids et Mesures (CGPM).
The Bureau International des Poids et Mesures (BIPM)is in charge of coordinating the development and maintenance of primary standards and organizesintercomparisonson the highest level.
TheNational Metrology Institutes (NMI)are the highest authorities in metrology in almost all countries (in Poland GUM). In most cases they maintain thenational standardsof the country which are thesources of traceabilityfor the associated physical quantity in that country.
TheAccredited Calibration Laboratoriesprovide calibration services according to their scope of accreditation, identifying the specified measurands and theirbest measurement capabilityi.e. the smallest uncertainties that can be achieved with the suitable measuring devices. Theirreference standardsare compared, at appropriate intervals, with reference standards of NMI.
Quality management systems Robert W. Góra