CAPÍTULO IV: DISCUSIÓN
4.1. Percepciones sobre el nivel colectivo
Kindreds can be distinguished by a series of diagnostic features, including the
severity of the cation leak, the temperature dependence of the leak, the presence
or absence of stomatin, the phospholipid content of the membrane and the degree
of hydration of the cell. At present by these means eight variants in the UK can be
distinguished (Table 2.2). The variants to which we have access, and which will
be the main focus of the work in this thesis are: overhydrated HSt (OHSt),
dehydrated HSt (DHSt), cryohydrocytosis (CHC), familial pseudohyperkalaemia
Edinburgh type 1 (FPl) and familial pseudohyperkalaemia Falkirk/ Chiswick
type 2 (FP2), HSt Woking (Jarvis et al., 2001) and HSt Blackburn (Stewart and
Turner, 1999).
2.1.1 Overhydrated hereditary stomatocytosis (OHSt)
This is the most severe condition and will form the main focus of this thesis.
These patients have an extraordinarily high passive leak to Na^ and K^, with a
flux rate 20-40 times normal (Zarkowsky et al., 1968). The influx of Na^ exceeds
the efflux of K^. The NaK pump is stimulated by the high intracellular [Na^] but
cannot compensate for it (Morlé et al., 1989). This leads to grossly abnormal
swollen cells are osmotically fragile (Lux and Palek, 1995). Patients are
chronically jaundiced. Fortunately the condition is rare.
The integral membrane protein ‘stomatin’ is deficient from their cells
(Lande et al., 1982; Eber et al., 1989; Hiebl-Dirschmied et al., 1991; Stewart et
al., 1992). However, the protein was purified from a normal control and the gene
sequenced and was found to be normal in the patients (Wang et al., 1992).
During this work, the OHSt patients have been referred to as Brighton,
Manchester and Harrow. Unless it is stated otherwise, the patient Manchester
always refers to B-III-1 (see table 2.1 or figure 2.1).
2.1.2 Dehydrated hereditary stomatocytosis (DHSt)
This is the most common of the conditions. It is a haematologically milder
condition than OHSt. The fluxes to Na"^ and are only 2-3 times normal
(Stewart and Turner, 1999). The dehydration is probably due to the fact that the
increase in permeability to exceeds the augmentation in Na"^. Monovalent
cation pump activity is stimulated by the increased intracellular [Na^j but is
unable to compensate for loss. Cation and water depletion occur leading to
dehydration of the cells (Joiner et al., 1986).
The stomatin protein is not absent from the erythrocyte membranes from
excess of phosphatidylcholine (PC) and the condition is identical to that described
previously as a high phosphatidylcholine haemolytic anaemia (HPCHA) (Clark et
al., 1993).
Some European cases of DHSt have been associated with a transient, self
limiting, perinatal oedema (Entazami et al., 1996) (Grootenboer et al., 1998). All
DHSt cases tested so far map to a locus on chromosome 16q23-qter (Carella et
al., 1998).
2.1.3 Cryohydrocytosis (CHC)
This is the next most prevalent condition in the UK. It is characterised by a mild
anaemia, a reticulocytosis of about 5% and normal or close to normal levels of
haemoglobin (Miller et al., 1965). When fresh, the red cells display mild
dehydration with a high mean cell haemoglobin concentration (MCHC). If they
are left to stand at room temperature, they begin to lose and gain Na^ and
become overhydrated with a low MCHC. If they are left to stand in the cold,
these changes become very marked, with Na^ entry predominating over loss
(Coles et al., 1999a), leading to marked lysis if left overnight in EDTA or
heparin. Storage at low temperatures leads to an increase in intracellular [Na^], an
increase in cell hydration (Coles et al., 1999a) and a subsequent rise in the mean
Autohaemolysis on cold storage is particularly high and some of the
patients present with artefactually high plasma [K^ readings due to the loss of
into the plasma from red cells during storage. Because the storage falsely
suggests that the patients are hyperkalaemic, this phenomenon is termed
'pseudohyperkalaemia'. Patients are recalled to hospitals by anxious physicians
after routine plasma electrolyte estimations and are retested and found to be
normal when a repeat urgent analysis is performed. These effects can all be
attributed to the bizarre temperature dependence (section 2.4 and Figure 2.2) of
the NaV K'" leak (Stewart and Turner, 1999).
2.1.4 Familial pseudohyperkalaemia (a heterogeneous group)
Familial pseudohyperkalaemia (FPl and FP2) is characterised by erythrocyte
loss which is exaggerated in the cold. It is very mild with the haematology and
the leak at 37°C being virtually normal. Therefore, patients have only mildly
abnormal cells and little or no haemolysis or anaemia (Stewart et al., 1979;
Stewart and Ellory, 1985). The Edinburgh family (FPl) has a mildly dehydrated
condition (Stewart et al., 1979; Stewart, 1993) and maps to chromosome 16 along
with DHSt (lolascon et al., 1999). The Chiswick and Falkirk pedigrees (FP2)
(Haines et al., 2001a) show a similar combination of virtually normal
from the Edinburgh pedigree (FPl) by virtue of a shoulder-shaped temperature
dependence in the ‘passive leak’ to K.
2.1.5 HSt Woking
This is a unique pedigree and is the second most severe after OHSt (Jarvis et al.,
2001). The intracellular [Na^] and [K^] and the 'leak' influxes are more
abnormal than DHSt, while the temperature dependence of the flux is different
from Blackburn (see below) and cryohydrocytosis.
2.1.6 HSt Blackburn
This is another unique kindred, with an almost normal level of haemoglobin, 5-
8 % reticulocytosis, an identical flux to cryohydrocytosis (5-6 times normal)
showing a shallow slope temperature abnormality and frank anaemia (Coles et al.,
1999b). This condition can be differentiated from HSt Woking and
cryohydrocytosis by virtue of the temperature dependence of the cation leak,
which shows a 'shallow slope' abnormality.