75.0to80.0 80.0to89.0 89.0to102.0 Source:www.statsamerica.org,fundedinpartbytheU.S. CommerceDepartment'sEconomicDevelopmentAdministration.Work wasconductedbythePurdueCenterforRegionalDevelopment,theIndianaBusinessResearchCenteratIndianaUniversity'sKelley SchoolofBusiness,andotherresearchpartners.
CÊçÄãù-Lò½ IÄÄÊòã®ÊÄ IÄø
An ini a ve by the U.S. Department of Commerce Economic Development Administra on, Purdue University, and Indiana University has produced an “innova on index” for every county in the United States. Kentucky’s county-level results are illustrated on the map below, with the highest innovation index values anchoring the three angles of the urban triangle—the Louisville area, Northern Kentucky, and Faye e County. The index is based on four broad categories and includes 22 diff erent variables. The four broad categories include Human Capital, Economic Dynamics, Produc vity and Employment, and Economic Well-Being. Some of the variables include educa onal a ainment, high-technology employment, broadband adop on, venture capital investments, patent crea on, worker produc vity, proprietor income, the poverty rate, and per capita income. The highest ranked Kentucky county is Faye e at 101.8. Santa Clara County, California—which is Silicon Valley—and Broomfi eld County, Colorado—which is the Denver area—have the highest values in the United States at 125.4 each; Hancock County, Tennessee, which is located along the Kentucky-Tennessee border in the eastern region has the lowest index value in the country at 61.7. The index is scaled so that 100 is the U.S. average.
Entrepreneurship is a particularly promising vehicle for economic development, as refl ected in the January 2012 update of the Kentucky Cabinet for Economic Development Strategic Economic Development
Plan. Entrepreneurs help create new jobs, and generate wealth and new
growth. They are innova ve users of assets and resources and appear to be a cri cal mechanism for bringing new ideas and innova ons to the marketplace. The depth of entrepreneurship can be gauged by examining the value created by entrepreneurs in a region as measured by the ra o of self-employment income to the number of self-employed workers in an economy. Unlike breadth which measures the number of entrepreneurs in a region, depth examines the value. High-value entrepreneurs clearly earn more, add more value, and enhance regional growth and prosperity more than other entrepreneurs. Kentucky has generally lagged the United States and compe tor states in entrepreneurial depth. Since the early 1990s Kentucky’s average self-employment income has been below the U.S. and compe tor states; in 2013 Kentucky lagged the U.S. and compe tor states by approximately $5,700 and $2,700 respec vely.
EÄãÙÖÙÄçÙ®½ DÖã«
$0 $5 $10 $15 $20 $25 $30 $35 $40 $45 Constatnt 2012 $1,000s AverageSelfͲEmploymentIncome, Kentucky,CompetitorStates,andtheU.S.,1969Ͳ2013 (nonfarmproprietorincome/nonfarmproprietoremployment) US CS KYEÄãÙÖÙÄçÙ®½ BÙã«
Entrepreneurship is integral to the American Dream. Imagination, intelligence, and tenacity can transform a good idea into a thriving business or a global enterprise. The Kauff man Founda on produces an annual Index of Entrepreneurial Ac vity which is based on monthly data from the Current Popula on Survey (CPS). According to Kauff man, “capturing new business owners in their fi rst month of signifi cant business ac vity, this measure provides the earliest documenta on of new business development across the country.” In 2013, an average of 0.28 percent of the American adults (20 to 64 years old), or 280 out of 100,000 adults, created a new business each month. While Kauff man presents data for individual years, we use 3-year moving averages because of the vola lity of state-level percentages—as evidenced by the Kentucky data in the fi gure. The 2011-2013 average for the U.S., Kentucky, and compe tor states are 0.30%, 0.37%, and 0.30%, respec vely. As illustrated below, the overall trend is slightly upward for Kentucky.
0.00% 0.05% 0.10% 0.15% 0.20% 0.25% 0.30% 0.35% 0.40% 1996Ͳ98 1998Ͳ00 2000Ͳ02 2002Ͳ04 2004Ͳ06 2006Ͳ08 2008Ͳ10 2010Ͳ12 3Ͳ Year Moving Average IndividualsCreatingNewBusinesses, Kentucky,CompetitorStates,andtheU.S.,1996Ͳ2013 (percentofadults20Ͳ64creatinganewbusinesseachmonth) US CS KY
Innova on, as measured by the number of patents issued, is widely regarded as a measure of a state’s entrepreneurial energy. Research fi nds that innova on, along with educa on, has a signifi cant impact on a state’s per capita income. A study by the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland shows that states which spawn innova on, as measured by patents, can reap economic rewards that endure for genera ons. The authors conclude, “A state’s knowledge stocks (as measured by patents and educa on levels) are the main factors explaining a state’s rela ve per capita income.” In other words, Kentucky’s much lower-than-average patent stock—which has trailed the U.S. as well as the compe tor states for the last 50 years—along with lagging educa onal a ainment rates, are why the state’s per capita income has been languishing at just over 80 percent of the U.S. average for the last several decades.