3. METODOLOGIA
3.1. TECNICAS E INSTRUMENTOS PARA LA RECOLECCION DE INFORMACIÓN
Media may be thought of as a key factor in the constitution of the public sphere where people ‘make sense’ of the world, discuss the information they receive and participate in rational decisions concerning political and public issues (McGuigan, 1996).
Music, because of its powerful influence on society (discussed in Part 1), is considered a
kind of mass media which is worth an analysis in this thesis. According to Wood (2009),
media portrays gender in both traditional and non-traditional ways and music, and more
importantly, lyrics, can function as social mirrors providing the listener with a description
of the world they live in and an aide to the construction of their social identity (Seitz,
1991). Although consumers tend to believe that media does not affect them, media affects
our upbringing, identity, and relationships with others (Wood, 2005). Music can be
recreational, educational, social, emotional, therapeutic, or spiritual (Hays et al., 2002) and
has an important effect on our lives. Pop music is distributed through more media than any
other form of popular culture. “The space a musical artist occupies in popular culture is
33 This word has been blended by Nieto (2012). The original in the article by Rossi (2007) was “streetscape”.
multi-textual. Lyrics, interviews, music and videos together create a collage, often finely
planned, out of which we are supposed to form impressions” (Perry 2003, 141). The accent here is put on the music imagery presented to the general public, not only in the lyrics but
also in video clips, record sleeves, etcetera, and its effect on people.
Mundy (1999: 224) suggests the term “music video aesthetic” at work across a range of contemporary cultural forms, including television, cinema and advertising. Thus
the link between the production of music and visual texts works on a number of levels.
One of those contemporary forms of visual texts that music mingles with is pornography
and sex. In the neo-liberal context of celebrating individual freedoms, and a context of
wider access via the internet, pornography has become increasingly de-regulated (Sears
2011). With this de-regulation, images from the media sphere of pornography are
mainstreamed and normalised in the everyday cultural realm, a process that has been called
pornification (Attwood 2006; Paasonen et al, 2007). Authors like McNair (2002) Attwood
(2006) or Paasonen et al. (2007) discuss the close relationship between sex and the media
in the twenty-first century. Sex has become much more culturally visible– more a public
than a private self-expression– and media of all kinds have become central in how sexual
identities and lifestyles are understood and maintained (Attwood, 2011). As McNair (2002:
87, 98) has argued, these developments are also part of a media trend that foregrounds
lifestyles, ‘reality’, interactivity and confession; a form of ‘striptease culture’ that can be understood as part of a broader preoccupation with self-revelation, exposure and ‘public
intimacy’.
The constant sexualisation of women by themselves and by men in songs, leads to
talk about an increasing pornification both verbally and visually: it appears that the
aesthetics of the porn industry is hijacking other sectors of everyday life, such as music
stardom” (Levande, 2007: 308). The use of the Internet for sex, love, and culture,
demonstrate a reframing of porn for younger audiences as part of a new ‘smart sex culture’ (Attwood, 2010), as will be explained below. Porn is now being distributed in quite
different commercial and generational communities. A wide range of media texts
(pornography, music videos, celebrity publications, etc.), goods (toys, clothes and
accessories) and practices (pole exercise, ‘sexy’ dancing), are considered to have a new
and pernicious impact on young people (Attwood, 2011).
Magazines depict representations of the ‘perfect’ woman as very thin and attractive, and the ‘perfect’ man as strong and athletic. One of the effects is the pressure on women and men (and particularly on teenagers) to live up to unrealistic representations of their
bodies or their relationships. The vast array of airbrushed images claiming that super slim
women have the ‘perfect beach body’ lead young readers to believe that there is no other image worth aspiring to (Brooks, 2008). Talbot (1998) states that:
Women actively participate, spending on it [femininity] their creative energies and time, as well as their money. Fashion and beauty standards are shaped by the manufacturing, advertising, fashion and magazine industries, which offer a range of material and symbolic resources for creating femininity. In participating in consumer femininity, a woman constructs herself as an object requiring work, establishing a practical relation with herself as a thing. This work is always required: no one can approximate the kinds of appearance offered without effort and expense (Talbot, 1998: 172).
Machin & Thornborrow (2003) show that, for example, Cosmopolitan magazine creates a
fantasy world, where women acquire power through the clothes they wear and places they
frequent, but also through sex, seduction and social manoeuvring. Every individual who
appears in the magazine is performing a role, or ‘acting up’. Readers are supposed to know
Parallelisms with this situation in magazines can also be found in the world of
music. As Whiteley (2000: 218) points out, it seems that media coverage is identifying and
constructing a more tabloid-defined audience with an interest in sexual rather than musical.
“Pop music is intimately connected with the pornography industry as today’s pop stars embrace and exalt the joys of porn” (Paul, 2005). Now, record labels and the strip-club industry are working in tandem. If the record is successful in a strip club, it is a good
indicator it will sell (Mitchell 2006: 29-30). Levande (2007) remarks that pop stars have
recently become an advertising claim to sell other products. For example, music celebrities
endorse products and sell their own cosmetics and clothing lines. Levande keeps on developing this idea and deduces the following: “If actual products can be assigned to pop stars, then so can ideologies” (2007: 301), an apparently true enough statement to be
convincing and agreeable for this study.
But why the abandonment of romance in favour of foreplay, condoms and sexual
pleasure both in magazines and music?. McRobbie (1999: 53-55) points out that romance
has withered away and is now an outdated code for constructing the dominant narrative of
female sexuality. This has now been replaced by much more overtly sexual material. The
explanation provided by publishers and academics alike is that sex sells more copies and
increases benefits. McRobbie (1999: 130) claims that breaking down the myth of romantic
love, which most women have been exposed to in popular culture (and music), has been
necessary for survival and for participating in a much crueller and disappointing world. It
is important “to be mindful of the way that record companies are also active in this process
of sexualisation of music, taking an important role in shaping the image of artists, in
seeking market position and addressing audiences” (Machin, 2010: 28). The big record
companies are interested in profit maximisation and artists might be manipulated by their record labels, seduced by monetary gain and therefore ‘sell out’. Worst of all, some bands
and artists become the product of a label, deliberately designed and marketed to appeal to
particular listeners (Machin, 2010: 29). CDA studies the effect of big companies and the
media on the discourse of marketing and product sales to convey ideas and messages. The
media (as influential social agents in our postmodern times) play an important role in
setting the parameters of what constitutes expected gendered behaviour (for women much
more stringently than for men). Therefore, the presence of sexualised messages in lyrics is
worth discussing.