4. Discussion
4.4 Therapeutic implications of MASTL regulation
On initial coding 39 concepts were identified (Table 16).
Table 16: Initial Coding: Concepts identified by Pregnant Teenagers (Focus Group 3)
No Concept No Concept No Concept
T1 Planning for future T14 Pregnancy unplanned T27 Fear of unknown, of being abandoned & alone T2 Friendship T15 Fear of weight gain T28 Pregnancy part of them – baby
perceived as “mine”
T3 Initial reaction to discovery of pregnancy – scared,
shocked, crying
T16
Pregnancy
T29
Views partner in terms of a
“provider”
T4 Pregnancy – special &
important
T17 Baby shared T30 Breastfeeding – embarrassing &
antisocial T5 ? pregnancy planned,
despite protestation
T18 Labour associated predominately with pain
T31 Parental reaction – anger, shock, disbelief. ?unsupportive
of pregnancy T6
Supportive partner
T19 Natural childbirth – but pain may determine choices
T8 Searching for information about pregnancy & fetal
development
T21 Social stigma of teenage pregnancy – fear of being
judged & labelled
T34
Centrality of Family
T9 Choosing names for baby T22 History of being bullied T35 Change in life-style T10 Parental reaction to
pregnancy
T23 Protective feelings &
behaviours
T36 TOP underlying reason for pregnancy T11 Rationale for parental
support
T24 Ambivalent partner T37 Immaturity – adolescence egocentricism T12 Support from parents T25 History of heroin abuse T38 Opinion & commitment to
education T13 Unreality of pregnancy
?immaturity
T26 Changed diet due to pregnancy
T39 Ways of speaking about the fetus
During core analyses certain concepts were identified as flawed, not being causal, challenging nor expanding the emerging themes and were as a result discarded (T17, 19 and 38). T19 and 38 were incorporated into other more dominant and definitive concepts, whilst T17 was abandoned as an isolated statement that was not truly representative of the participants feelings towards the fetus. Fifteen primitive categories were identified (Table 17).
Table 17: Core Analysis: Merged categories. (Focus Group 3)
Discovery of pregnancy distressing
Intergenerational Support Permanency of pregnancy
Positive perceptions of fetus
Behavioural signs of attachment Immaturity
Pregnancy planned Importance of a supportive partner
Friendship
Reactions to physical signs of pregnancy History of drug abuse and bullying Social stigma of teenage pregnancy
Pervasive effects of Termination of Pregnancy
Protection of the pregnancy / fetus
Perceptions of breastfeeding
Eight Key Concepts were identified (Table 18) which reflected the teenagers’ emotional and resulting behavioural responses to pregnancy. There were three powerful, dominant and interlinking concepts to emerge. The teenagers perceived pregnancy as special eliciting actions and behaviours that resulted in protection for the pregnancy. For all participants support was crucial. The eight Key Concepts are discussed within the chronological framework they occurred from the shocking discovery of the pregnancy to
Table 18: Key concepts: Pregnant teenagers (Focus Group 3)
No. Nascent themes
1 Teenage reaction to the discovery of pregnancy
2 Parental reactions to the news of pregnancy
3 ?Pregnancy planned
4 Pregnancy Special
5 Permanence / stability of pregnancy
6 Protection of the pregnancy / fetus
7 Importance of social support
8 Adolescence and pregnancy
The initial reaction was distress. The overwhelming emotions
described were shock, fear and incredulity.
“I was really scared I didn’t know
what! My head was all messed up. I couldn’t stop crying!”; “I was scared, I
thought this can’t be happening to me!”
It was commonly held that pregnancywas impossible, with participants claiming that the pregnancy was unplanned and unexpected.
Certainly for one participant it was totally unplanned as she had used
contraception.
“I was a week late and I thought I can’t be pregnant! I used protection both times”.
In fact she performed two pregnancy tests before she was convinced that the pregnancy was a reality. The emotion generally described was utter despair as they struggled with the very real possibility of angry parental reactions and the ultimate anxiety of their ability to copealone as teenage mothers.
“Oh God, I was like I’m not gonna have no-one. I’m gonna have no money, I can’t get a flat and I’m gonna be homeless”
. There was also concern expressed about the stigma and stereotyping of teenagemothers; this was compounded by the feeling that they had failed their parents and would bring social criticism on their families. One participant feared stigmatisation and people judging her pregnancy as a self-fulfilling
prophecy.
“I’m scared like people where I’ve actually grown up ‘cos I know the
first thing they’re gonna say is “she’s been on heroin and now she’s pregnant!”
. This participant believed that she came from a neighbourhood where teenage pregnancy was unusual and their family would be singled out for criticism and ridicule“ … it’s just that, like my brother ‘cos he was like “Oh my God what
are people going to think of this family”.
Although fear of telling parents wasParental reactions to the news of pregnancy were as the teenagers had envisaged negative. Two of the participants’ parents were separated and in subsequent co-habiting relationships. The teenagers
although living with one of their parents chose to inform both of their birth parents. Reactions included shock, disappointment, anger and disbelief. The adolescents’ birth fathers would not initially talk about the pregnancy and future. In fact the fathers chose to totally ignore their daughters for a
period of time:
“My dad … wouldn’t talk to me at first, he was like NO!”
;“My dad wouldn’t talk to me for about a week”
. One participant’s mother was fearful for her daughter’s future and encouraged her daughter to considertermination of pregnancy:
“My mum was like “you’ll wreck your life” and that”
. The disclosure of teenage pregnancy caused arguments and distress:“I used to shout at my mum ‘cos we used to have terrible arguments. Her and my Nan used to double deal me and start having a go”
.These arguments and discussions appeared necessary to vent anger, face the reality of unplanned pregnancy and to explore plans and coping mechanisms for the future. The participants made it clear that termination of pregnancy was not an acceptable option. With the need to ensure a healthy pregnancy the parents with whom the teenagers lived grudgingly accepted the inevitable and began to offer support.
“When your step-mum gets up with
your dad and says “look you’ve got to support her””
the result is“…they are
both fine with it, they both came around”
. One parent continued to be unable to either accept her daughter’s pregnancy or offer her support“… but my mom, she hasn’t really come round yet, so I doubt she ever will”
. For the participant without a boyfriend telling her parents had been particularlydifficult, she chose to conceal her pregnancy for 20 weeks before telling:
“I think I just hoped it wasn’t true, I’ve only ever had it once, it’s so unfair”.
Yet after a short period of distress and anger both parents offered full support, arranged antenatal care, attended with her and even attended the support group with her to encourage her to meet other pregnant teenagers.
The teenagers did not appear to have considered the fragility of pregnancy and the possibilities of miscarriage or congenital malformation.
They appeared to have an unshaken belief in the permanence and stability of pregnancy. They had already chosen their baby’s names. They were also
exploring and making decisions for the birth and childcare.
“I want to go through it
(labour)as naturally as I can”
;“There are hand-ones
(breastpumps)
which I’m gonna get so
my boyfriendcan feed as well”
. Although there were many months of pregnancy to traverse the teenagers were confidentlyplanning for the birth of their
“baby”
. This could be a counter reaction to the real threat of social termination that was the preferred option for their parents.The majority of the participants stated that their pregnancies were unplanned and a distressing discovery. However one participant as the discussion unfolded appeared to have been distressed only in the very
short-term and may have planned her pregnancy:
“I was really scared … I couldn’t stop crying, but then a couple of days after, it sort of sank in and I was really excited”.
This participant had the year before at the age of fourteenundergone a social termination of pregnancy. She had ultimately found this experience physically and psychologically devastating; during the group
discussion she repeated and emphasized her distress:
“Both physically and emotionally it’s horrible, so I couldn’t do it again”
. She clearly stated that this pregnancy was now beyond the nine week stage that marked the gestation when her previous pregnancy had been aborted and she appeared very happywith this:
“So I’ve never been this pregnant before!”.
Her boyfriend had supported her decision to continue with the pregnancy. It would appear that she has chosen her boyfriend with prudence, an adult who could both providefor a family and fulfil her romantic view of family life:
“He’s really supportive;
he’s got a job and everything. He’s 22, which is a bit old! … I love him … he’s got a flat and he’s well paid”.
She appeared to have considered the future.She had carefully chosen a partner who she considered reliable and financially stable, able to provide a home for their baby and herself. She also planned to continue her education, she had found and secured a place at a college
relatively early in pregnancy that had crèche facilities:
“I’m going to College for my last year at school, they already know. There’s a crèche there!”.
Her support mechanisms were being put into place, with her boyfriend moving nearer to her parental home. Her father and step-mother had decided toprovide all the practical support they could:
“My dad and step-mum are definitely going to support me the best they can and help me money wise and everything”
.The participants, once the initial shock reaction had been addressed, commonly viewed the pregnancy as special. The fetus was perceived as solely
belonging to the expectant mother:
I was really excited like, thinking I had a baby inside me”
;“I can’t wait to actually see my baby … it’s got a piece of me in it.”
The teenagers actively and eagerly searched for information about their developing pregnancy and were absorbed by the wonder of childbearing:“I sit there and think … how big is it, what organs are developing, what it is doing and everything?”
The signs of pregnancy were welcomed as positive signs that the pregnancy was progressing.“It didn’t sink in until I started to get morning sickness and then I thought yeah! I’m really pregnant!”
Information was eagerly sought from books and parents, with resulting changes to diet and life-style to obtain and maintain a favourable intra-uterine environment for their
“baby”
.A significant and enduring concept throughout the interview was the protection afforded to the pregnancy through the teenager’s decisions, actions and behaviour. From the initial confirmation of pregnancy the
participants were determined to protect their pregnancy and actively resist any parental pressure to terminate their pregnancies. One participant
counteracted her mother’s argument that teenage motherhood would
“wreck her life”
with personifying the fetus arguing“… for God’s sake this is your grandchild!”
The same bargaining tool was used to encourage and rationalise active support from parents. The participants have actively soughtinformation about pregnancy, in particular the facts regarding a safe and healthy intra-uterine environment to ensure optimum progress for their fetus. Smoking had been considerably reduced, alcohol consumption stopped and the participant that had been a drug abuser had remained off drugs for nearly four months. Diet appeared particularly important. Foods with potential to harm either the pregnancy or fetus had been rigorously
eliminated from their diets. This extended to ensuring that infection was not ingested through inadequately cooked meat with one teenager having refused to eat meat at a family barbeque for fear of catching toxoplasmosis.
To the participants the importance of social support was
paramount. Their obvious lack as young teenagers of financial independence to provide the means to adequately care for a baby was of immense concern
to them. The teenagers appeared to need both the approval and support of their parents in order to realistically believe that their childbearing
experience would be successful. However for one participant, she had initially more support from her boyfriend and his mother. She had found it very difficult to tell her mother. Following the initial period of shock,
disappointment and anger the parents did offer the desired support. For one teenager her mother’s acceptance of the pregnancy and unconditional support was essential. Her mother had helped her overcome her heroin habit. During
this time they became very
“close”
, developing and building a“great trust”
. Pregnancy had initially affected this relationship and the participant felt shehad
“let her family down”
. In support of the centrality of the teenagers’mother to the continuity of the pregnancy, is that the mother became a
valued source of information and advice:
“I don’t want to breast feed … my mum never at all”
. To this participant her family were important; she also discussed the influence of her father, brother and grandmother. For the participant that may have planned her pregnancy her support was to be both from family and her boyfriend. The boyfriend was to be the main support.His continuing support was crucial to the decision not to terminate this pregnancy. For the teenagers support needed was more than social; due to their dependent status their needs were more extensive embracing social,
a boyfriend, her family were providing all the encouragement and assistance.
They had never encouraged her to abort the fetus and were pro-active in ensuring she accessed adequate antenatal care. It was only when the support was forthcoming that the teenagers felt they could look forward to with any
confidence becoming parents