!
" # # $
% & % ' #
% (
$ )
* + ,
-
.
/ * % 0
1&
2 0 ) 1 3
% /%!
$ #
/ 4 #
1 3 5 /
# $ $
6 '3 4
# & ' #
7 ' 480 0# -& 4
1 - ' 3 +
(9::; #0
<==> /% * %'
3 +
0
3
?@A==
. ! A@ 6
*
# <==>
,
%
0 ,, %
.
3 .
4 -% 0
, 6 '- ,
6 - %
%
. $ 0
- %
!
,
8 ,
,
$
B , ,
8 ,
B 8
, + 0
0B ,
$ ,6
,
, $ 0
0
99 0 ,
9< 0 C
- %
9> 0 + ,
<9 1 0
<99 +
<9< %
<9> (
<9@
#
<< ( % 0
<<9 ( 0
<> ( % 0
<>9
<>< '
<>> $0 D
<@ # #
<E -0
<E9 '
<E< '
<E> '
<E@ C .
<?< #
<A -
<; '
>9 0
>99
><
><9
><<
><>
><@ &
>>
>>9 *
>><
>@
>@9
>@< 1
>@>
>E
>E9 F
>E<
>E> $
>E@ +
>EE '
>? 8
>?9 '
>?< (
>?>
! " # $
%&
@9
@< +
@<9
@<<
@<@
@<E
@<? $
@> D 00
@>9 1
@><
@@ #
& ! " # $
E9
E<
E<9
E<< $
E<> '
E>
E>9
E>< $
9E
E>> '
E>@
2 )
E>E $ 2 )
E>? '
E@ 0 00
E@9 4
E@< '
' ( " #
?9
?< 0 .
?<9 .
?<<
?<> 4 0
?<@
?<E / .
?> -0
?>9 .
?@ # .
?@9 7
?@< .
?@> .
?E #
) ( " # )
A9
A<
A<9 #
A<< -
A<> 1
A<@
A<E 0
A<? #
A>
A>9 0
A><
A>>
A>@ #
% * )
;9 0 - % $
;99 '
;9< -
;< 0
;<9 '
;<< -
( +" )
$9 0
$< # # 0
$> %
$@
, +" %&
&9
&< %
'9
'< 3
'> 3
'@ 4
- +" )
9
99 1 .
9< + .
9>
< G
> & H '
9::E!
,# " .)
<9 $ 0 2 ,)
<< 7
I 90 , 6
0
<> 7
90 , 6
0
<@ $0 2 ,)
<E $ 0 2 ,)
<? <0 ,
<A ! , 0! ! !
,
<; C0 '-
<: ' '- , 6
<9= $ + "
<99 ' '- , 6
<9< -0 , 0 0
% ( %
'- , , 6 J9=
<9< -0 , 0 0
% ( %
'- , , 6 J9
<9< -0 , 0 0
% ( %
'- , , 6 J=9
<9< -0 , 0 0
% ( %
'- , , 6 J==9
<9> 6 , 6 ,0 ,
0 % (%
'- , , 6
, 6 <== # J9!
<9E 8 %0
( % , 6
,0, # J =E
<9? $ 2 ,) B
<9A ' ,0 , KJ I4!
<9; 0 ,
<9: 70 ,
<<= $
>9 8 ,
><
8
,
>>
8
,D ! % H $ 9:A@! $ 9:AE! %
9::E!L! 2 )
>@ F D
>E F D
>? 8 Æ 0
F
>A ,
,
@9 # >@E= G($7 !
@< 0
D ! . L ! .
@> $
@@ <;= 9AE 9<= M
0
2)!
D ! L!
6 & ,
0 , ! 6
6
6
@? $ ,
@A $
@; D ! '9
L! '9 ,
@: D ! =09L! =0E
@9= $
@99 4
@9< $ ))
@9> %#0>=
@9@ '
@9E 6 8 8
D @=
Æ
' ! ;E Æ
' !
9@=
Æ
' ! 6
6
6
6
@9? 4
8
E9 4 ,
E< ! !
9=
4J9;=== 2 A)
E> 1 # 9:?;!
E@ 0
2 A)
EE 4 ,
0
. @<
E? 0
L ! 2 99)L ! 2 9@)
EA 4 ,
E: 4 ,
E9= 4 ,0
0 8
/H'
9:?A!!
?9 # .
A9
!
A< #8 D 6
A> #8 D 6
A@ -, ! !6
6
AE
,, 6
A? 0
D
9:;=!
AA ,
Æ
'D 6 0
A; 0
D Æ
'
6
A: 0
D
0
E Æ
'
A9= F
8 D !
J>?==L!
J9=
A99 0
D
& H ' 9::E!
$9 # % " +
'9 4 ,
!
'< 4 , 0
9 ' , , ,
C# J ;:==
< - , " 6 C#
J ;:==
> ' , , C# 0
@ ' 0 6
6
>9 $ ,
@9
A9 ' 6,,
'9 $
'< $
Æ
'
'> $
Æ
'
'@ $
Æ
'
9 ' , C# 0
<
> 'Æ 6 . Æ & H
' 9::E!
!
"##
#
$ %
&# Æ
' %
& Æ
(%
' #
#
)
Æ
$*+
(
,
'
( #
Æ $-
'
Æ - . #
"#
/0
1
"
2
(
,
(
3
(%
.
4
, #
,
"5 (%/#
# 0
6
4
6
6
6
4
4
!
" "
4
"
' #
" & #
#
' $
. # $
#
2 %
&
&
4 &
'
"Æ & '
'
' Æ #
( 6 !
&
Æ 4 &
) Æ ! "##
)
Æ !
* !
,
+
7 !
4
,
( #
-
, !
.
!
7
.
,& !
(
.
'& /
#4 /
&
& /
& # Æ
&
, / #
&
0
#
# " "
. .
1 !
# (
.31
2 #
6# 3, #3 ,
# #
4
2
/ 0
2 # 3 3
3 3
$
4 8
3 5
# 3 6
6 -
5 - "
2 , 6 '
. 7 '
"8 2 93 '
5 4 2 9
5 2
"
( 2
3 .
$
Æ "
B
! 0
,
0 , , 0
, 0. 0 .0 0 ,!
,
L L L 6
L , 6 .
' 9::;!
' 0
''7 ! "
. 6!
Æ
'(
#(
C(
$ 6 Æ
"?= @= 06
''7 06 3
F
0
6 '6
2 )
6
* 6
06
L
8
L
$ 6
" !
.
.! * 6
Æ 6
I
. 0 ,
,
0 6 !
$ " D
6 <==
@== B 9= 9
E B 6 ,
6
6
. !
$ !
.
& 6
# 0
8 80
Æ $
#
Æ
H49:A=L
/ B9:;9! ' .
,!
0 ,
$ 0 ,
$ .
C + %
% ,
6 + 2,) 0
L 20,)
.
6 # ,
0D
0
$ !
0 ,
, ,
/ ,,
, ,
,
+ .
# $
8 "
% .
. !
+ ,, 6
+ ! * .
6
6 ! % #
" 0
Æ *
, 0
,0 .
Æ
$"0,
# % +
!
1
0 " + 0%
0 Æ
/ " + 0%
% $
( 9::;!
- % !
. Æ
# 0
( 9::;! ,
6
"!
- % , ,
6
B
0 , 6 % H
$9:A@! ,6
1 09@<=
Æ
'
.
;==
Æ
'
/ 0
Æ B
! *
8 B , 6
*
,
,
F ! 0
B ,
8 ( 4
9::;! ,0
0 ,
* 0
, 8
! % 9::E! 0
,
8 8
, 8 !
*
$
,
8 8
, * &
8
,
#
0
!
! '
0 H
% 9::A! 0
,
6
H% 9::A! 4
. 0
$
6 0
'
* )
0 '
8
#
$ 0
, ' 9:;<! '
9::?! . +
.
, '
+ , %
#
+ %
3 + 0,! ,
. 6
& 8
. I88 +
6
# $ # 8
. 0 8 "
0
,
% .
/ .6
6 6
+ +
. ! 3
. -
9 0
'-! 9==== ' 9:;<!
% #
8 " 0
Æ *
I8 8 0
0 , , ,
. "
B 0 . "
0 , 6!
+ %
#
$
/ + %
Æ 8 $
+ H * 9::?! %
8 Æ .
+ 8 "
8 Æ $
+ .
8 Æ )
1 9:;>! 8
+
8 Æ
- 8
8 "
% , *
B . 8
% ,
+ 8
8 0
6 6 8
- F H4 9::E! 8
,
6 / 208
) 0
6 2 )
+
8
# H 9::;! +
# 8
$
! $ 6
.
2 B )
! /
"
" -
4 ( 9::;!
"
2 ) 8
. + 0%
F %
. '
.
Æ
$. (% ,
6 ( ,6
, '-
6 2 )
, '-
.
(%
2- % )
$ H <===!
2(
% ) 6
8 .
,.
#8 !
6 08 !
"
- % 6
. - B 1 H 4 9:;9!
+
% #6
( 8
- B 1 H 4 9:;9! . .
+ . % "
6 %
% .
2 ) "
6
! B *
- B1H4 9:;9!.
6 6
6 $
* H <==>! (
%
2- % ) 2( % )
( .
8
0 8 6
, 0 3 H 4 9:A?!! - 0
" (%
0 '- , 6
. + 0
- 0 I8 8
" + 0% 1 9:;>!!
" ( %
, 6
8 ! + 8 0
I8 8 !
- I8 8
% + ! $
Æ
. 0
(% D
0 0
0 0 ,0 ,
, , 6
0 . # 0
8 0 .
0 0 ,0, ,
, 6 '-0 , , 6 %0
$ ,
0 . 6
% ,0 ,
0
0 0 ,0 , 0
6
$ %&
' 0 0 , 0 0
% 6 <9!
2 ,) $
- Æ 6
D
% 6 %
6
Æ
8
Æ B
, , 6 C & 8 ,
.
Æ
Æ
Æ
+ 0%
C 8
+. <> % .
2)
2 ) '
. 6
$ 0
C ) % . !
8 ,
D
!
!
. <@ 8
!
!
8 % 8
. <E!
"
! . <:
#
! . <9= %
' B
, C "
B Æ
Æ
,
Æ
#
.
#
! Æ
#
+
*
#
,66 +
#
+. <E <A <9= 60 8 .
6
+. <E .
+. <A <9=
.
<>
6
6
0
5 10 15 20 25
-1.5 -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5
x[m]
U, V , (U - V ) [ m s ] -1
(U-V)
(U-V)
(U-V) U
U U
V
V V
5 10 15 20 25
-1.5 -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5
x[m]
w, J , [s ] -1 ρ p
w
w
w
J J
ρ p ρ p
- <<D 7
I 90 , 6
0
! "
0
2 ) .
$
9
<
9
6 <<!
<
!
9
=E
! !
9
=
6 <> =
B .
6
B
6 B!
0 "
( 9:;@! 0 ,
5 10 15 20 25
-1.5 -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5
x[m]
U, V , (U -V ) [ m s ] -1
(U-V) U V
5 10 15 20 25
-1.5 -1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5
x[m]
w, J , [s ] -1 ρ p
w J
ρ p
-<>D 7
90,6
0
$
$
$
$
' 0 8
. . <9=!
$
$
$
$
% +
$
$
$
$
- . <9E! <9?! <9A! 0
.
! ,
+ . . <9;!
Æ
Æ
Æ
¼
¼
Æ
Æ
¼
%
!
¼
%
Æ
Æ
Æ
Æ
¼
¼
Æ
Æ
¼
%
!
¼
%
Æ
%
, 0
$
$
"
.
$ 0 ,6
(% ,
$ <98 . 9;
. ! <9 $
, . 9=
. . 0 6 !
& ! " '
0 ,
(%
, , 6
, , 6 6 <?
! , 0 . , 6
1.0
0.5
0.0
-0.5
-1.0
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0
x y
-<?D <0 ,
6
!
!
. <<@
. <9E
8 .
( 9:;@!
$9
"
B 0
! B 0
! /
#
. <<9 <<<
$
( % 0 . <9E <9?
<9A -
0 . $
0 ,
. <<@
+ 0
" # 6
0! -<A,
0. ,6#
(
$9!
. J =9<E
6<A! 0
6
$ 6 <A!
6 <A!
0 6 .
0
0 6 0
0 . , /
"
" 6
- 6 <A! .
0
$ 0 .
6 $ 6
2 )
2 ) 6
6 " (
% "
* H <==>!
6 !
( %
- B 1 H 4 9:;9!
"
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.0
0.5 1.0
x y
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 5.0
10.0
x ρ p
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.0
0.5 1.0
x y
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 5.0
10.0
x ρ p
0 ": 0 ":
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 0.0
0.5 1.0
x y
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 5.0
10.0
x ρ p
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 0.0
0.5 1.0
x y
-1.0 -0.5 0.0 0.5 5.0
10.0
x ρ p
0 ": /#0 0 ":
- <AD ! , 0 ! ! !
,
$ #
. $ 0 0
$#
. 28) 0.
(
0 % .
0
, 0
8 8 8 .
0 . 0
. . <E!
1
"!
"!
"!
"!
"!
!
#
!
"!
"!
6
0
! 20)
#
!
$ .
<9=
"!
#
"!
"!
$ . <A
"!
"!
+. <<; <<: <>= 0
6 6
! C
#
!
#
,#
- <;D C0 '-
* &
( % )
,0 , 1 H
$ 9:A<!- B 1H4 9:;9! ,
, ! 6
, $
, 8 .
<>9 # 6
, 6 '-
( %
1.667 1.500 1.333 1.167 1.000 0.833 0.667 0.500 0.333 0.167 0.000
0 %#
2.000 1.833 1.667 1.500 1.333 1.167 1.000 0.833 0.667 0.500 0.333 0.167 0.000
0%#
1.000 0.833 0.667 0.500 0.333 0.167 -0.000 -0.167 -0.333 -0.500 -0.667 -0.833 -1.000
0%$
1.000 0.833 0.667 0.500 0.333 0.167 -0.000 -0.167 -0.333 -0.500 -0.667 -0.833 -1.000
0%$
-<:D ' '- , 6
, 6
'- , . <>9 0
, 06
0 '- 6 <;
0 6 $ '-
6 6<:
- <9=D $ + "
( % )
0 6 '- 0
, 6 . .
, .
8 2 ) '- 6 $
. '-0
0 $ 8
02 ) 7) !
&
!
! 6
/ 6 08 0 .0
1.333 1.000 0.667 0.333 -0.000 -0.333 -0.667 -1.000 -1.333 -1.667 -2.000
0
#
2.000 1.667 1.333 1.000 0.667 0.333 -0.000 -0.333 -0.667 -1.000 -1.333 -1.667 -2.000
0
#
2.000 1.667 1.333 1.000 0.667 0.333 -0.000 -0.333 -0.667 -1.000 -1.333 -1.667 -2.000
0
#
2.000 1.667 1.333 1.000 0.667 0.333 -0.000 -0.333 -0.667 -1.000 -1.333 -1.667 -2.000
0
#
- <99D ' '-, 6
"
#
"
#
(
"
( '
'
#
.
+. <>@ . '-
6 G
- <99 '-0
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
!
6
( % )
"
!
B
! B
! $
$
$
-.
<<9 <<<
$
$
% . <9E <9? <9A
,
6 $> ! , . . <9;
. <>9 '-
. <>@! - #
<@ 0
$>! '- ,,6 9====
$ ( %
'- , , 6 " E==
0 6
+
%
+
+ ( %
0 ( %
6 <9< '-
.0 6
80
0
7 9::>! $@!
4 , 6 <9<0!
! 20
B ) ( %
,6 %
(%
- 6 <9< 0!! ,
2 ) 2 )
0B
2 ) $
- 6<9<0!! $
-<9<0! Æ
,
0B $ (%
%
( %
6<9>0!
,6 6<9<!8
# (%
'- , 6 8
0B 8
1.100 1.008 0.917 0.825 0.733 0.642 0.550 0.458 0.367 0.275 0.183 0.092 0.000
0 &: ;<= "##
1.100 1.008 0.917 0.825 0.733 0.642 0.550 0.458 0.367 0.275 0.183 0.092 0.000
0 &: ;<= 3"##
1.100 1.008 0.917 0.825 0.733 0.642 0.550 0.458 0.367 0.275 0.183 0.092 0.000
0 & :;<= "##
1.100 1.008 0.917 0.825 0.733 0.642 0.550 0.458 0.367 0.275 0.183 0.092 0.000
0 & :;<= 3"##
- <9<D -0 , 0 0 0
% ( % '-
,, 6 J9=
3.750 3.375 3.000 2.625 2.250 1.875 1.500 1.125 0.750 0.375 0.000
0 &:;= "##
4.500 4.125 3.750 3.375 3.000 2.625 2.250 1.875 1.500 1.125 0.750 0.375 0.000
0 &:;= 3"##
4.500 4.125 3.750 3.375 3.000 2.625 2.250 1.875 1.500 1.125 0.750 0.375 0.000
#0 &:;= "##
4.500 4.125 3.750 3.375 3.000 2.625 2.250 1.875 1.500 1.125 0.750 0.375 0.000
0 &:;= 3"##
- <9<D -0 , 0 0 0
% ( % '-
,, 6 J9
3.500 3.208 2.917 2.625 2.333 2.042 1.750 1.458 1.167 0.875 0.583 0.292 0.000
0 &:<;= "##
3.500 3.208 2.917 2.625 2.333 2.042 1.750 1.458 1.167 0.875 0.583 0.292 0.000
>0 &:<;= 3"##
3.500 3.208 2.917 2.625 2.333 2.042 1.750 1.458 1.167 0.875 0.583 0.292 0.000
&0 & :<;= "##
3.500 3.208 2.917 2.625 2.333 2.042 1.750 1.458 1.167 0.875 0.583 0.292 0.000
0 &:<;= 3"##
- <9<D -0 , 0 0 0
% ( % '-
,, 6 J=9
1.083 0.975 0.867 0.758 0.650 0.542 0.433 0.325 0.217 0.108 0.000
0 &: <<;= "##
1.300 1.192 1.083 0.975 0.867 0.758 0.650 0.542 0.433 0.325 0.217 0.108 0.000
0 &:<<;= 3"##
1.300 1.192 1.083 0.975 0.867 0.758 0.650 0.542 0.433 0.325 0.217 0.108 0.000
0 & :<<;= "##
1.300 1.192 1.083 0.975 0.867 0.758 0.650 0.542 0.433 0.325 0.217 0.108 0.000
0 &: <<;= 3"##
- <9<D -0 , 0 0 0
% ( % '-
,, 6 J==9
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 0.0
0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6
Normalised particle density ρ p / ρ p,0
y/R Osiptsov CFD
Osiptsov analytical Traditional CFD Traditional analytical
0 & : ;<
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 0.0
0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2.0 2.4 2.8
Normalised particle density ρ p / ρ p,0
y/R
Osiptsov CFD Osiptsov analytical Traditional CFD Traditional analytical
0 & :;
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 0.0
0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2.0 2.4 2.8
Normalised particle density ρ p / ρ p,0
y/R Osiptsov CFD
Osiptsov analytical Traditional CFD Traditional analytical
0 &:<;
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 0.0
0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2.0 2.4 2.8
Normalised particle density ρ p / ρ p,0
y/R Osiptsov CFD
Osiptsov analytical Traditional CFD Traditional analytical
0 &: <<;
-<9>D 6 , 6 ,0 , 0
0 % ( %
'- , ,6
,6 <== # J 9!
, , 6
,,
3 8
'- , 6 6 8
% ( % , 6
( * +
)
6 <9< <9> E==
(% 9==== %
.
6
8
6 <9@ 2 ) 6 <9<
. 9==== " <==
- <9E , 6
( %
E==
8 " <== %
9==== <==
E== $9====
(% %
8 %
" ( % "
%
6 +
* . % .
, , !
& 6
%
( % # Æ
6<9E 8 0
8 ( % * %
!
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 0.0
0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2.0 2.4 2.8
X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X
Normalised particle density ρ p / ρ p,0
y/R
Osiptsov:
200/500 particles
Lagrangian:
x 200 particles 500 particles 10000 particles
0 % 5
"## 3"##
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 0.0
0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2.0 2.4 2.8
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x
Normalised particle density ρ p / ρ p,0
y/R
Osiptsov: either grid, 500 particles
Lagrangian: regula r grid, 10000 particles
x
x Lagrangian: refined grid, 20000 particles
0 % "##
# # 3"##"##
##
-<9ED 8 %
( % ,6 ,0 ,
# J=E
% " *
( % . 6 '3 *
( " <==
9====
8 . (
% %
0 ,
6 <>!
" 8 8 . (
(
% 0
(%
'-0 , , 6
6 %
+ '3 (
. -
+ 5H%B 9:::!
>= Æ
+ ,
%
(Æ
, 0
# 8 <0 , (
" B
,
. ,
# $
6
( %
6 <9?! (9:;@!
8
, % !
)
/
- ,
0 ,!
( % !
* !
,0,
- B 1 H 4 9:;9L7 9::>!
- <9A ,0 ,
" , , -
<9A < ! "
<== " 9 > @ E ? A ;
- <9A
"
9
<>@E ?"
" A ;
" "
- <9A 0
A ; B
B 6
2 ,) . 2)
.
. 4 9:E?! - B 1 H 40
9:;9!!
! , * H <==>!
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0 -0.02
0.00 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.10 0.12 0.14 0.16
-0.004 -0.002 0.000 0.002 0.004
1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0
-8 -7 -6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1
( a)
( b)
( c)
x y
y
x
-0 .1 4 -0 .1 2 -0 .1 0 -0 .0 8 -0 .0 6 -0 .0 4 -0 .0 2 -0 .0 0 0 .0 2 0 .0 4 0 .0 6 0 .0 8
1 .0 1. 5 2 .0 2. 5 3 .0 3. 5 4 . 0 4 .5 5. 0 5 .5 6. 0
x J
- <9AD ' ,0 , KJ I4!
0 $ ; ?@ 8
0 0
0# #
, ,
# "
- <9; 8 0
, "
6 <9;
, !
/
( %
0
6 <9A
3.901
3.576
3.251
2.926
2.601
2.276
1.951
1.626
1.301
0.976
0.651
0.326
0.001
0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 0.0
0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6
y
ρ p
0 #4 # 4&
39.011
35.760
32.510
29.259
26.008
22.757
19.506
16.255
13.004
9.754
6.503
3.252
0.001
0 10 20 30 40 0.0
0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6
y
ρ p
0 #4# 4&
-<9;D 0 ,
'
Æ6 2)
$
%
+
0 !
2 )
,0 ,
(% !
- <9; ( % 0
! $
% +
. 0
6 <9;!
- <9; ,
"
6 '
6 6
2 )
-
$ ( % 0 ,
6 '-
/ % ' 3 - <9:
6 $ 0B
2 )
$
/
+ .
$!%
$
$!%
$
% B
!%
!%
+. <>A!
5.000 4.583 4.167 3.750 3.333 2.917 2.500 2.083 1.667 1.250 0.833 0.417 0.000
1.250 1.146 1.042 0.938 0.833 0.729 0.625 0.521 0.417 0.313 0.208 0.104 0.000
0 0
0 " :4 0": /# 0
- <9:D 70 ,
1.200 1.133 1.067 1.000 0.933 0.867 0.800 0.733 0.667 0.600 0.533 0.467 0.400
1.2 00 1.1 33 1.0 67 1.0 00 0.9 33 0.8 67 0.8 00 0.7 33 0.6 67 0.6 00 0.5 33 0.4 67 0.4 00
0 0
0 "
40#
- <<=D $
99< 6 $
6#
-<<=(%
. ,
() -
% 6 0 0
,
$ . , #
8 .
'3 () '-0
, 6
2 ) 6
0 ,
!
G,
,
, 6 ,! 0,
.! 0 ,
, !
6 6
-0 ,
! ,
$
8 0
,
D
&
Æ%Æ%
Æ
Æ
! Æ
Ý
B ' 9:;<! 0
, Æ
*
,
2 ) 2 )
. !
! D
&
,! D
&
'
!
' 9::;! 6 D
(
$ ,
$
$ +9::@!0
, &
&
, 2 0 ) ,
8 /
&
20
) Æ
, -&
,
20 ) 0
0
* 6 0
8 <==9!
0
0 0
0, 6
9::9!
0 - 9::@!
06 ,
6
9= <= ) 0 9==
! ,
, ,
0 , 0
!
0 , 6
, $
# , ! 6 D
. ,
, $ # ,
6
. >E! 0
# ,! D
&
&
6
! 0
.
. .
8
& , 0
# 6
D
0, ,
,, 0
0 B
6 , , 6
,
70 , &
+ ,
*
% ,
0, + %
< #
0
, 4 6 D
*
, *
/
-
C0#
. #
.
. ,&0& .0( &&(!. ' 9::;!
D
)
+
,
+
)
)
,
-
,
. >: D
+
0
, !
,
!
. >9= 6 D
6 . >E! $
+
# Æ
6 D
(
(
/ 6
$ !
# #
6
6
Æ 1 H $ 9:A<!
4
!D
6 (
N
(
O
&9
/ -
!
.
! 6
F /%-
.
# /%
/%
' 9:9=!D
(
(
/%
(
' )
6 6
, 6
$ ,
6 , 0
B H 9::=!
* ,
,L
, 0 .
0
#8 1
#8 9:?E!
4
#8 9:?E 9:?;!
, D
)
-
*
-
4
,
->9
, (
#8 )
1% 9:;:! C# ,
6
==@
1% 9::9! #8 ) H
X Y
F L F L
Gas Leading Particle Particle Leading Gas
Vrel Vrel
Ux < Vx Ux > Vx
Vrel
Vrel
Ux Ux
->9D 8 ,
9::=!
1 9::<! 6
&<! - , . >9?
# <==>!D
-
)
# 0
, / 9::A! 8
#8
#
7 .
,
.
.
"
,
1 09@<=
Æ
'
.
;==
Æ
' . .
"
)
0
!%
0
Æ
0
N
O $
Æ 6 D
/
0
*
)
D
/
*
!%
0
0
Æ
/
-
, 0
# ,
8 &
8
-)8 ,
D
$
$
Æ & 8 $ $
&
+ ) 8 F 9:>; <;?!
Æ D
$
1
&B )
1
)
' )
6
4 9:A:! &
. . D
,
%
)
%
* D
,
)
)
)
)
!%
$
!%
!%
, 6
& D
$
!%
# *
8$
D
&
*
$
8
, &
#
,
& .
" $
B
, & #
, ,
& 6 -) 8
, 2 8 )
, D
$
/
8 8
- 8
# &
*
$
!
$
*
*
!
$ 8
- 8 $ 6
,
,
.
' 2
,
, *
)
"
$
B 2
0
* 8 0. ,
! , ,
&
6 ,
.
Æ
- . ,
Æ 2)
8 2) ' 9:AEL 4
9:;>! ,
8 , . ><A
& 4 . >99 !
H % 9::A!
, . D
-
$
. ><;! 0
0
0.,
0.,
!
8 B
,
& .
8
, , D
$
$
, $
$
8
* $
$
$
! & 8 -
Æ
, !
$
*
$
, .
0.,
! Æ
8 $
!
(
4 9::99::<9::>! .
. 1 0&B .
-!
$ 59::A!
9::9! H % 9::A! 0
,
#
0 ,
,
6 " # H % <==9!
2 8) !
4 1 9::9!
&
, , ,
# <==>!D
+. >>< 06 /
2) D
/
0D
' $
+
#
9:@A! 4 9:AA!
H C9:A;! ,8Æ
. D
$
B
D
$
*
Æ 6 D
,.Æ
$
$
2 " 8)
#
9::>! $ 2 .) $
! H % 9::A!
$ $
D
$
0
D
*
4 <==<!
% 0
, C#
,
. >>A! *0
, 0
0 !
D
*
6 ! *
! ,
' "
$ , 6
0 0,
B
# , 8 8
# ,
,
6 D
Ý
!
,
C 8 8
D
3
$
' 0
3
&
D
*
*
0
4 , !D
,
$ #
,
D
- >< >>
'
Dimensionless particle relaxation time, τ p +
D im en sio nle ss dep o siti on velocit y , V d +
1 . x10 -2 1 . x10 -1 1 . x10 0 1 . x10 1 1 . x10 2
1 . x10 -6
1 . x10 -5
1 . x10 -4
1 . x10 -3
1 . x10 -2
1 . x10 -1
1 . x10 0
1 . x10 -2 1 . x10 -1 1 . x10 0 1 . x10 1 1 . x10 2
1 . x10 -6
1 . x10 -5
1 . x10 -4
1 . x10 -3
1 . x10 -2
1 . x10 -1
1 . x10 0
1 . x10 -2 1 . x10 -1 1 . x10 0 1 . x10 1 1 . x10 2
1 . x10 -6
1 . x10 -5
1 . x10 -4
1 . x10 -3
1 . x10 -2
1 . x10 -1
1 . x10 0
1 . x10 -2 1 . x10 -1 1 . x10 0 1 . x10 1 1 . x10 2
1 . x10 -6
1 . x10 -5
1 . x10 -4
1 . x10 -3
1 . x10 -2
1 . x10 -1
1 . x10 0
Liu & Agarwal (1974) Wells & Chamberlain (1967) + Leeming (1995)
Liu & Agarwal (1974) Sehmel (1968)
+ Schwendiman & Postma (1961)
Liu & Agarwal (1974) Friedlander & Johnstone (1957) ( τ p
+ /Sc 2 ) 1/3 =0 ( τ p
+ /Sc 2 ) 1/3 =10 -4
Liu & Agarwal (1974) Lee & Gieseke (1994)
+ +
+ +
+ +
+ +
+ +
+ +
+ +
+
+ ++
+ + +
+ +
+
+ +
- ><D
8 ,
Dimensionless particle relaxation time, τ p +
Dime n sio n les s d ep o si ti on v elo ci ty , V d +
1 . x10 -1 1 . x10 0 1 . x10 1 1 . x10 2 1 . x10 3 1 . x10 -6
1 . x10 -5 1 . x10 -4 1 . x10 -3 1 . x10 -2 1 . x10 -1 1 . x10 0
Leeming (1995) Re = 4000 Leeming (1995) Re = 20000 Liu & Agarwal (1974) Re = 10000 Liu & Agarwal (1974) Re = 50000 Agarwal (1975) Re = 6000
Dimensionless particle relaxation time, τ p +
Dime n sio n les s d ep o si ti on v elo ci ty , V d +
1 . x10 1 1 . x10 2 1 . x10 3 1 . x10 4 1 . x10 5 1 . x10 -6
1 . x10 -5 1 . x10 -4 1 . x10 -3 1 . x10 -2 1 . x10 -1 1 . x10 0
Liu & Agarwal (1974) Forney & Spielman (1974) X Ganic & Mastanaiah (1981) Re = 52500
Ganic & Mastanaiah (1981) Re = 54600 Andreussi (1993)
Farmer et al. (1970) Cousins & Hewitt (1968) Gusev et al. (1990)
Re=10 5 Re=10 4 Re=10 3
X X X X X X X
X X X
XX X X X XXX X X
X X
X X X X X
0 0
- >>D
8 ,D !
% H $9:A@! $9:AE! % 9::E!L ! 2
)
&
28 )
,
& 8 8 & 8
, & 8
$
8 #
& # 2
) 2 ) * & 8
$ 6 >< !
& B !
&
)
/ 9:;9!
, + &
Æ
&
)
, 8
8
!.
&
)
C 8 , 8 4
4 ,
8 &
&
)
6><
8 &! 8
#
, 8 9::E!
&
)
!
8
&
2 8 0 ) $
,
$
2 ) 0
,
+. >@9
5 H $ <===!
9===
<=== 8 ' . 28 )
3 & 2 8 0 ) 3
2 )
9::E! 7 9::=! 6 3
6
3 7
6 >>
4
4
- ><
2
) % H$9:A@!
.
! ->>%H $
9:A@!$9:AE! 7 H1 9:;9! % 9::E! $
4
- >>
/ )
6>< >>
>9
!"#$%&
- H 9:EA! 6
# 0 "
" 0
1 0
! 0
" 0
0 4 9<E== <====
Æ 8
0
,
6 4
!
# 9:?;
@>E! - H
,
0
.
- H <E @E Æ
>9 %I!
8
20,)
8
. .,
$ H % 9::A!
8 8
, , 6 8
8 6
' ( !"#)%&
/H' 9:?A!0
6
,
8
8
4*
4 L 4*
/ H ' )
6
6 ><!
# H 9:?9! , 8
'
Æ
/ H '
- 8
, /9:;9! +0#
9:;>!
* !"#)+&
#9:?;! 0
4
, .
, !
6 ,
. D
5
+
!%
6
5
, 6
1 D
8 8 " 0
2)!
#) 8
26 )
$ 0 L 0 0
*
! $
C 0 6 6
! 6
