DIRECTOR JURIDICO

The Castillo had returned to Spanish rule in the 1783 Treaty of Paris that ended the American Revolution, but a mere forty years later, Spain was ready to peacefully cede Florida to the United States government. On July 10, 1821, the Spanish flag was lowered and a twenty-three-star American flag was raised.143 As the United States military took control of Fort Marion, newcomers to Florida had their first look at the Spanish fortress. Most eyewitnesses were deeply impressed by the coquina architecture of the fort. James Grant Forbes, writing in 1821 said, “On entering this old town from the sea, the grandeur of the castle of Fort St. Mark’s [the English name for the fort] presents itself, and imposes a degree of respect from travelers.” He claimed that the bronzed and squamated structure could be, “justly deemed one of the handsomest in the western hemisphere.”144 _{He failed}

to remark upon the Indian labor that went into the fort’s construction. The fort was evidence of Spanish presence alone.

Yet not every newcomer stood in awe at the walls of the fort, however spectacular its architecture had once been. Charles Vignoles, British engineer, in 1823 wrote that in St. Augustine, “buildings crumbled into ruins over the heads of the indolent Spaniards, and the dirt and nuisance augmented in every lot.”145 A.M. Fuller, journalist, saw the United States as more forward-looking than Spain, capable of transforming acquired land

143 _{Luis Arana and Albert Manucy, The History of Castillo de San Marcos, St. Augustine, Florida (St.}

Augustine: Historic Print & Map Co., 2005), 55.

144 _{James Grant Forbes, Sketches, Historical and Topographical, of the Floridas; More Particularly of East}

Florida, a facsimile reproduction of the 1821 edition (Gainesville: University of Florida Press, 1964), 85.

145 _{Charles Vignoles, Observations Upon the Floridas, a facsimile reproduction of the 1823 edition}

into profit. The United States was set to expand and all who impeded it would fall: “The indolent don must no longer stand in the way of Florida’s development. It was manifest destiny; and he yielded to it.”146

Even though these men were less than laudatory of Spain, Vignoles and Fuller still wrote about the Spanish influence on Florida. In the Castillo de San Marcos, Vignoles saw the slothful, languid legacy of Spanish architecture, contrasting an old Spanish past in Florida with the American modern age. What he, again, did not see was the Indian labor that had largely built the fort’s walls. He did not see the Indians who had lived and worked side by side with the Spaniards for two centuries.

For health reasons, New Englander Ralph Waldo Emerson spent the winter of 1827 in St. Augustine and began his first book of poetry on this trip.147 He went alone and felt very isolated during his stay, a fact heightened because St. Augustine in the 1820s, having only recently been handed over to the United States, made Emerson feel as if he were in a foreign country, studded with stone ruins.148 The American flag flying over Fort Marion comforted Emerson. Everything else in Florida jarred him: he

described the locals as lazy, noticed the Catholic graveyard was much more revered than the Protestant, and observed a slave auction for the first time.149 The foreign land he described he saw as distinctly Spanish, not belonging to any indigenous tribe. He jotted down a poem entitled “St. Augustine” in his journal. To him, the fort remained

archetypal of Spain: “I saw St. Mark’s grim bastions, piles of stone/Planting their deep

146 _{A.M. Fuller, “A Bit of Old History,” The Chautauquan; A Weekly Newsmagazine 15 (1892): 208.} 147 _{Patricia C. Griffin, “Ralph Waldo Emerson in St. Augustine,” El Escribano: The St. Augustine Journal}

of History 32 (1995): 113-114.

148 _{Griffin, “Ralph Waldo Emerson in St. Augustine,” 119.}

foundations in the sea,/And speaking to the eye a thousand things,/Of Spain, a thousand heavy histories.”150

When the fort was handed over to the United States, however, visitors began to take note of it as not only symbolic of Spain’s empire, but the founding of America as European-Americans knew it. Also in Ralph Waldo Emerson’s poem, he lauded the town as the founding place of what is now the American Empire: “Here is the old land of America/And in this sea girt nook, the infant steps/First footprints of that Genius giant- grown/That daunts the nations with his power today.”151 _{This magnificent fort, a}

precursor to a great nation, had to be preserved.

On its transference to the United States, St. Augustinians wanted this fort to become useful. The region was in the midst of the Seminole Wars after all. The local consensus seemed to be that it should be a military barracks. In 1833, as reported in papers communicated to the House of Representatives, a local gentleman from St. Augustine wrote to a congressional delegate from Florida a bid on the necessity and cost of repairing Fort Marion. The concerned gentleman noted how the fort was going rapidly to ruin, with its walls at one or two points tumbling into the sea. Once the United States acquired St. Augustine, money went into the barracks at the old Spanish monastery, but not to the fort.152 _{The local argued that maintaining the fort would keep up a work of art}

and allow American soldiers a place to live, for at the moment the fort served as an army jail and a magazine. Its usage as a magazine was never ideal because of the moisture in

150 _{Ralph Waldo Emerson, “St. Augustine,” in Griffin, “Ralph Waldo Emerson in St. Augustine,” 129.} 151 _{Emerson, “St. Augustine,” in Griffin, “Ralph Waldo Emerson in St. Augustine,” 130.}

152 _{“On the necessity and cost of repairing Fort Marion, San Augustine, Florida. Communicated to the}

House of Representatives, January 24, 1833.” 22nd _{Congress, 2}nd _{Session. American State Papers 020,}

many corners of the fortress.153 As this was 1833, a time of heightened numbers of slave revolts in the south (for example Nat Turner’s), the man also argued the spot integral to fortify in case of a slave uprising, able to grant asylum to the women and children of St. Augustine. The local community as a whole lamented that the Spanish better maintained the fort than had the United States until this juncture: “It is impossible that any true Floridian can behold the present state of that model of fortification without regret, when even the stranger looks but to admire and sympathize in its decay.”154 There was an early desire for local pride in the building. Most Americans thought Spain had taken better care of the Castillo, and vowed to rectify this. They had in mind the former imperial glory of Spain, and sought in small ways to reinstate the fort’s dignity and prestige.

In 1835, Congress appropriated $20,000 to repair Fort Marion and reconstruct the St. Augustine seawall. According to the House Report, the goal in instituting these funds was to restore the fort to the condition it had been in when the Spanish handed it over to the Americans. Although the fort had no active role in maritime defense in the 1830s, Congress deemed that to be no reason it could not be restored.155 In fact, it was soon to be needed as a holding facility for prisoners of war.