Una extensión de la máquina abstracta de Warren para la argumentación rebatible.

(1)

8QD H[WHQVLuRQ GH OD PuDTXLQD DEVWUDFWD GH :DUUHQ

SDUD OD DUJXPHQWDFLuRQ UHEDWLEOH

$OHMDQGUR - *DUFurD

*XLOOHUPR 5 6LPDUL

*UXSR GH ,QYHVWLJDFLuRQ HQ ,QWHOLJHQFLD $UWLnFLDO *,,$ 'HSDUWDPHQWR GH &LHQFLDV GH OD &RPSXWDFLuRQ

8QLYHUVLGDG 1DFLRQDO GHO 6XU

$Y$OHP ^ %DKurD %ODQFD $5*(17,1$ ID[

HPDLO FFJDUFLD#FULEDHGXDU JUV#FULEDHGXDU

#08:203

/D PuDTXLQD DEVWUDFWD GH :DUUHQ R :DUUHQV $EVWUDFW 0DFKLQH ZDP HV XQD PuDTXLQD YLUWXDO TXH FRQVLVWH GH XQD DUTXLWHFWXUD GH PHPRULD \ XQ FRQMXQWR GH LQVWUXFFLRQHV GLVHaQDGDV HVSHFLDOPHQWH SDUD OD HMHFXFLuRQ GH 3URORJ $FWXDOPHQWH OD ZDP KD FRQYHUWLGR HQ HO HVWuDQGDU GH IDFWR SDUD OD LPSOHPHQWDFLuRQ GH HVH OHQJXDMH

/D YHQWDMD GH WHQHU XQD PuDTXLQD DEVWUDFWD PD HV TXH GDGR XQ SURJUDPD ! HQ XQ OHQJXDMH / HO SURJUDPD ! SXHGH VHU WUDGXFLGR D LQVWUXFFLRQHV GH OD PD \ OXHJR HMHFXWDU VREUH OD DUTXLWHFWXUD GH OD PuDTXLQD YLUWXDO GLFKDV LQVWUXFFLRQHV /D PD SXHGH LPSOHPHQWDUVH FRPR XQD PuDTXLQD YLUWXDO R GLUHFWDPHQWH VREUH XQD PuDTXLQD UHDO R GLVHaQDUVH XQ QXHYR SURFHVDGRU FRQ OD DUTXLWHFWXUD GH OD PD GLVHaQDGD (Q HO FDVR GH OD ZDP HVWDV WUHV DOWHUQDWLYDV KDQ VLGR GHVDUUROODGDV

/D DUJXPHQWDFLuRQ UHEDWLEOH HV XQD IRUPDOL]DFLuRQ GHO UD]RQDPLHQWR UHEDWLEOH HQ HO FXDO ODV FRQFOXVLRQHV REWHQLGDV SXHGHQ VHU UHFKD]DGDV DQWH OD DSDULFLuRQ GH QXHYD HYL GHQFLD 8Q DUJXPHQWR SDUD XQD FRQFOXVLuRQ . FRQVWLWX\H XQD SLH]D GH UD]RQDPLHQWR WHQWDWLYD TXH XQ DJHQWH LQWHOLJHQWH HVWuD GLVSXHVWR D DFHSWDU SDUD H[SOLFDU . /D SURJUDPDFLuRQ HQ OuRJLFD UHEDWLEOH HV XQD H[WHQVLuRQ GH OD SURJUDPDFLuRQ HQ OuRJLFD TXH FRQWLHQH WRGDV ODV FDUDFWHUurVWLFDV GH OD DUJXPHQWDFLuRQ UHEDWLEOH

(Q HVWH WUDEDMR VH SUHVHQWD OD H[WHQVLuRQ GH OD ZDP SDUD REWHQHU XQD PuDTXLQD DE VWUDFWD SDUD OD SURJUDPDFLuRQ HQ OuRJLFD UHEDWLEOH 3DUD HO GLVHaQR GH OD QXHYD PuDTXLQD DEVWUDFWD VH FRQVWUX\uR XQD QXHYD DUTXLWHFWXUD GH PHPRULD \ XQ QXHYR FRQMXQWR GH LQVWUXFFLRQHV FRQ FDUDFWHUurVWLFDV HVSHFLDOHV SDUD OD DUJXPHQWDFLuRQ UHEDWLEOH

_{)LQDQFLDGR SDUFLDOPHQWH SRU OD 6HFUHWDUurD GH &LHQFLD \ 7uHFQLFD 8QLYHUVLGDG 1DFLRQDO GHO 6XU}

(2)

,QWURGXFFLuRQ

1 >. ! "? ;< < 44 ; 7 < < 6 = 6 ; 8 < 6 8 ( 6

* 44 = 6 * 4 8 $ 6 : $ 7 6 4 $ 4 6 < 7 ( : '7 6 4 $ (< 7 '8 * 4 7 < ;

1 >-? ' = 4 6 ' < ' / < 44 < ; 44 ( ; 7 ;

1 >@ @ .? = 6 < 44 < 6 ;( = 1 44 SOU ;/ 7 7 * -@@ A 2 9 8 : 6 6 7 8 > % ? * 9 56 4 2 ZDP 2 3 4 5' 7 ' 8 : >? 1 8 6 4 PD 6 ! 8 / ! P 7 8 4 6 6 ' 1 PD 6 4 6 9 6 PD 9 * ZDP ' >$?

(3)

* 4 4 8 44 >@ , @ . $? 1 44 = 6 < / 44 < 6 ;( = 1 44 ; 7 7 < ;

* 8 44 BOC BDC BzDC 17 >-? * (4 BzC

7 BC ; * (4 B C 4 <

LH D D zD 7 zD D D 8 7 ;

BO S SQC Q w % O 7 SL

(4 ; QD% BO C 7 6 O B C 4

; BO > P> S S_QC S_L 6 *

(4 B> P> C < 6 <

44 LH ; 6

6 1 BO > P> $C 4 0 B< /

$ 4 < OC * QD% BO > P> C 7 6 O ; ;

8 8 0 6 7 6 ; 44

* 6 6 8 7 ' 8 P P 8 7 6 P * (4 BMz C 4 B 44 C = 44 P 3 3 Mz P 8 4 44 8 4 44 * 8 6 4 6 8 ' 7

* 48 ; / 7 6 ; BzDC ;

BDC 44 * 4

Bz > P> C B > P> z C 1

; 4 7 48 ; /

* 6 < ;

8 Bz > P> z C

B > P> C ; 8 /

; 7

(4)

>

> P

> P>

> P> > P> >

> P

E4 6 44

B C 7 B C 4 44 B C 7 B C

1 44 '4 6 44 / : ; 6 : 4 8 44 7 < '' < ; 6 ; 8

0 ; 8 7 8 4 8 60 *= 44

7

" 4 8 8 6

4 6

* 8 = 44 B C 7 B C 4 B C 7 6

B C

B C 7 7 B C

D > P> F > P>

* '7 4 0 BC = 7 BC : ; B > P> C ( B > P> C

4 ( 1 6 ' 8 < ; 44 / < < ; '4 40

(5)

0 8 6

7 = 4 6

* 4 7

0 7 =

4 60

7 0

( 6

46

6 8 = 6 < : '7 6 4 1 4 6 <

0 K$ KL 0

6 46 4 7 4 (< 4

6

46 Q Q * 4 K$ KL

7 (< 7 ' 6

( 4 Q Q K$ KL K$ KL

K$3 K3L

7 K$ KL 4 +

K$ KL (< ' '8 Q Q D >

Q Q? 7 *

7 L L /

; L L ;

6 8 7 , 8

;

4 4 ( / 4 0

+ L L ( 6 4

L L 6 7 L> L>

6 7 , 4 6 7 ,

" Q Q 4 4 L L

0 1 4 K$ KL 6

/ / ;0

'8 K$ KL

K$ KL

'8 4 '8 6

(6)

; B C 8 /

: 7 =

6 / 4 :

8 4 ; B C

6 4 *

<

4 7 8 B C

' 4 8 * BC B C 6 B C B C : ; ;

0 0

* 8 8 6 = 6 8

* 8 8 6 6 =

" * 8 8 6 6 / 46 , * 8 8 4

6 8 7 44 0 6 < 8

1 56 4 2 2 3 4 5' > % ? ' 8 * 48 48 6 4 44 < : 4 4 5 4 > ? 7 >?

1 6 4 6 6 7 8 9 8 1 7 8 4 6 4 * (4 1 6 4 6 4 6 9 6 * ' >$?

(7)

!

S WU\ PH HOVH ( ( WUXVW PH " DOORFDWH

DOORFDWH DOORFDWH SXW YDULDEOH ; $

JHW YDULDEOH ; $ JHW YDULDEOH ; $ FDOO S

SXW YDOXH ; $ SXW YDOXH ; $ GHDOORFDWH

FDOO T FDOO V SURFHHG GHDOORFDWH GHDOORFDWH

SURFHHG SURFHHG ( UHWU\ PH HOVH ( V MXVW PH DOORFDWH DOORFDWH

JHW YDULDEOH ;$ JHW FRQVWDQW D $

SXW YDOXH ;$ GHDOORFDWH

FDOO U SURFHHG GHDOORFDWH

SURFHHG

)LJXUD &uRGLJR ZDP GHO SURJUDPD GHO HMHPSOR

/D HMHFXFLuRQ GHO FuRGLJR ZDP FRPLHQ]D VLHPSUH HQ OD HWLTXHWD ?" 2EVuHUYHVH TXH HO PRGHOR GH HMHFXFLuRQ GH OD ZDP FRQVLVWH VLPSOHPHQWH HQ XQD FRQVXOWD TXH OODPD \XQ KHFKR R FDEH]D GH XQD FOuDXVXOD TXH HVSHUD VHU OODPDGR &RPR ODV FOuDXVXODV D VX YH] WLHQHQ FRQVXOWDV HVWR SURGXFH HO HQFDGHQDPLHQWR KDFLD DWUuDV EDFNZDUG FKDLQLQJ GH FOuDXVXODV 3DUD HMHFXWDU HO SURJUDPD OD ZDP SRVHH XQ UHJLVWUR OODPDGR ! TXH DOPDFHQD OD GLUHFFLuRQ GH OD LQVWUXFFLuRQ HQ FXUVR 'HVSXuHV GH HMHFXWDU FDGD LQVWUXFFLuRQ HO UHJLVWUR ! HV LQFUHPHQWDGR D nQ GH GLVSRQHU GH OD GLUHFFLuRQ GH OD VLJXLHQWH LQVWUXFFLuRQ VDOYR FXDQGR VH HMHFXWD OD LQVWUXFFLuRQ FDOO TXH PRGLnFD DO UHJLVWUR ! DVLJQuDQGROH OD GLUHFFLuRQ GHO FuRGLJR GHO SUHGLFDGR D HMHFXWDU $GHPuDV GH ! H[LVWH XQ UHJLVWUR ! TXH DOPDFHQD HO SXQWR GH UHWRUQR GH XQD OODPDGD HVWR HV OD GLUHFFLuRQ VLJXLHQWH D OD LQVWUXFFLuRQ FDOO /DV LQVWUXFFLRQHV DOORFDWH \ GHDOORFDWH VRQ ODV HQFDUJDGDV GH PDQWHQHU HQ HO VWDFN HO HO SXQWR GH UHWRUQR \HO YDORU GH ODV YDULDEOHV TXH GHEHQ SUHVHUYDUVH FDGD YH] TXH VH OODPD D XQD QXHYD FOuDXVXOD YHU nJXUD 8QD SDUWLFXODULGDG GH ORV SURJUDPDV OuRJLFRV HV TXH SXHGH KDEHU YDULDV FOuDXVXODV TXH GHnQDQ XQ PLVPR SUHGLFDGR (VWD FDUDFWHUurVWLFD UHTXLHUH GH XQ PHFDQLVPR GH EDFNWUDFNLQJ HO FXuDO HVWuD LPSOHPHQWDGR HQ OD ZDP XWLOL]DQGR ODV LQVWUXFFLRQHV WU\ PH HOVH UHWU\ PH HOVH \ WUXVW PH ODV FXDOHV FUHDQ SXQWRV GH HOHFFLuRQ TXH VRQ JXDUGDGRV HQ HO VWDFN YHU nJXUD \HQ HOORV VH DOPDFHQD OD LQIRUPDFLuRQ TXH GHEH UHVWDXUDUVH HQ FDVR TXH XQD FOuDXVXOD IDOOH \GHED EXVFDUVH RWUD IRUPD GH SUREDU OD FRQVXOWD (Q HO HMHPSOR OD FRQVXOWD WLHQH uH[LWR JUDFLDV D OD WHUFHUD FOuDXVXOD TXH GHnQH D S

(8)

SGO "!2& #$ )

FRGH KHDS VWDFN WUDLO SGO

3 &3 6 +% + % ( 7 5

0 (

* $ +

;M 2

KHDS $L

1 ) $ " $ . $ . /$ $ # KHDS$ LGHQW

$ KHDS , $ ' KHDS $ / . , KHDS

/ ) 3 / I"W WQ#

I Q 4 4 4Q 4L

I Q

( ( DQWHULRU

( &3 &RQWLQXDWLRQ 3RLQWHU ( FDQWLGDG 1 GH YDU SHUPDQHQWHV ( 3ULPHU YDULDEOH SHUPDQHQWH

(1 1uHVLPD YDULDEOH SHUPDQHQWH

% FDQWLGDG 1 GH SDUuDPHWURV % SDUuDPHWUR

%1 SDUuDPHWUR 1

%1 &( FRQWLQXDWLRQ HQYLURQPHQW %1 &3 FRQWLQXDWLRQ SRLQWHU %1 % YDORU DQWHULRU GH % %1 %3 SUuR[LPD FODXVXOD %1 75 SXQWHUR DO WUDLO %1 + SXQWHUR DO KHDS %1 % UHJLVWUR GHO FXW

5

(9)

8QD PuDTXLQD DEVWUDFWD SDUD OD SURJUDPDFLuRQ HQ OuRJLFD UHEDWLEOH

- ) - "6) * 3!#$ 7 +

/ 2 $ $ * $ 2 "$ #8 !! "# 8 $ !!

&RQVWUXFFLuRQ GH DUJXPHQWRV

' $ $ ) $ / 2 $ * )

( 6 $ 6 9 "$# $

3URSRVLFLuRQ :;< 6 $ 6 > $ 6 > "$#

) $ ! ' $ > P> $ ) 6>IJ

$ $ 6 (

/$ "# > P>

$$ 6 > "$# > IJ (

$ _$$

6> "$_{# "$}_{# $}

$ / $ !! 9 + !!

(10)

= L Q ) $ ! $

L #_ _Q 9

. #_ -

:<

$ / - ) 2 $ * 2 "# $ / "0# , $

"# 9 L Q

L #_ _Q _Q

!!

:;< 6 6>IJ 6>IJ !

" # > P> $ $

6 > "$_{# > IJ}

( > P> $

$ $ 6 > "$_{# > IJ $ >}

6 > "$_{# > IJ}

( /$ ) $ $ %% / ) ! $ !

(11)

( " ) ># ) ( /$ - . )2 $ $ $ $ ) .$ )

! ! "#$ ! ! %$ &' "() ! # ! *'+,-$

! ! *'+,-$ ).( * / 0 ( ! ! %$ ,- ! *) $

! *) $ ( ! ! $

! % $ %!$

! *) $ ! ! *'+,-$ ( ! % $ ( %!$

> = )

- $ * $ $ !! $ ' $ !! $ ! , " ) ># $ ' $ !! $ $ $ ! ! " ) ?# $ !! $ ) " >0#

' / / $ $

' '

" " #!

#!

(12)

* $ 9 $ ( / / $ - / - $ )

$% &' ()* +#(# $ $% *&( &' ()* +#(#

- ) ? !, - $ 0

% z 1 2 3

4 +

% 4 +

4 +

4 + %

%

, z + 4

%

% , %

? !, - * $ . ( /$ 2 $ . $ ) 9 $ $ .$ ) " ) ?# (! $ ) / %%

+ $ $ $ $ $ !! - !! $ $ !! " ) ?# !!$ $ !! $ !! $

(13)

8 @ 1 " # !! $ / 2 ) !! - $ /01 !! $ / 2$ ! " # / $ $ /01 - $ ) 1 / / " / ! %%# , 1 2 " $ # * $ %% ! !!

/ "# ' ) !! 1 =) "0# ' !! "# ( !! "># ' !! "?# 1 !! / ) $ $ $ )$ +

! "& 5# %! ".# &' () ! &' . 2) +".#

).( ).(

+*&()6& 78$ *$

).)6'78& *& $ (*&()6).)6.78& 78+$ ).)6'78 !!). *)$ )*).)6.78 !!). $

).)6'78) !*$ 9.&, () ' +( " :* (# -)+;6<=7*'$ %"+5)<>#$ ' * ) + *<$

)>.+6)7*+67$ ( ?2 $ )*)<$ ,- '*) $

( %$ ( %$

'*'<$ &' ' ).( 33$

( %$ ($ %!

( ! $

,PSOHPHQWDFLuRQ GH ODV LQVWUXFFLRQHV VDYH VXEWHUPV \ XQLI\ VXEWHUPV

(14)

& VDYH VXEWHUPV SQ & ' SQ WKW ( SQ )FSH FSU* + ) ! * $ ),* + WKW WKHDS )-* + VWDFN WKW $ VDYH IDFW SQ WKW $ ).* & WKHDS SQ

& VDYH IDFW SQ ) * SOU # VDYH IDFW SQ MDP ! WKW ! ) *

( ! + KHDS WKHDS # " " ! !

& WU\ PH HOVH 4 XQLI\ VXEWHUPV +W SURFHHG

% /XQLI\ VXEWHUPV +W0 )! * $ ! 1 +W WKW

(MHPSOR 2 $ SOU -, $

/KX\HYRODQGRFRFR0 WKW

! WKHDS #

, KX\HYRODQGR 3. .45 FSU 5

- YXHOD 36 .7, FSU ,

. DYH 33 .8- FSH

-6 JDOOLQD 3 . . FSU .

WU\ PH HOVH / WU\ PH HOVH /

XQLI\ VXEWHUPV XQLI\ VXEWHUPV

SURFHHG SURFHHG

WU\ PH HOVH / WU\ PH HOVH /

XQLI\ VXEWHUPV XQLI\ VXEWHUPV

(15)

( ' !

' ()( )

) )(*( *

( ! ) ) ) # ) * ) * & / )0 $ ( $ ! ) 6.*

( ! 9 : ! # + ; , - ' % ! 8 ! + ) ' /<0 *

" DOORFDWH FRPLHQ]R GH OD FRQVXOWD FuRGLJR MDP GH OD FRQVXOWD FDOO TQ LQWHQWD FRQVWUXLU HO DUJXPHQWR SUHSDUH WR GHIHDW SUHSDUD SDUD EXVFDU GHUURWDGRUHV SXW FRQVWDQW GHIHDW $ LQWHQWD SUREDU TXH

FDOO QDI QR H[LVWHQ GHUURWDGRUHV

VKRZ DQVZHU VL WLHQH uH[LWR PXHVWUD ODV UHVSXHVWDV GHDOORFDWH

HQG TXHU\ nQ FRQVXOWD

= 8 &

% & + % & $ $ + + + & ! $ &

(16)

% 2 ! $ " "

K

.50

K

! "

# # $

$ K

!

$ % """

K3

#$

= 7 & ,& ,

; $ K DUJXPHQWR FRPSOHWDGR $

$._{$ 6}

$ K 6 > $

$._&RF)$._*

$.

>7? 6HD 6 HO FRQMXQWR GH V GH XQ \ K$ KL XQ DUJXPHQWR ([LVWH

XQ FRQWUDDUJXPHQWR K$ KL HQ XQ SXQWR GH FRQWUDDUJXPHQWDFLuRQ S &RF)$.* VL \ VuROR VL H[LVWH XQD GHULYDFLuRQ $ SDUD K HQ GHVDFXHUGR FRQ XQ VXEDUJXPHQWR GH K$ KL HQ XQ SXQWR K &RF)$.

* TXH VH REWLHQH XWLOL]DQGR DOJXQDV LQYHUWLGDV FRQ ODV FRQGLFLRQHV HVWDEOHFLGDV 2 $ ' $

&RF)$._{* #}

:

&RF)$._{* ;}

K &RF)$._{* K # :}

$ ;

(17)

% ! 7 ,&

, ; L

)F_{* $}

! L ,& $

, :

L $

-

- % . L

. L

/ 0 ) ! 4*

. % L

6 ; $ ) ! 4*

3 % ) ! 4* !

( ) '! * !

8 % ,1 : $

7 2 $ ,1 ,1 &

4 ; ,2 ! ; ! % $ @A,

&'()*+,'* - . &'()*+,'* -/& 0. 123*14 56& " . 7(' 2 (

1275. +( 146215"*1&4& #56. 1!2. ,2 5. *+ -.

8"3* /1! 9 ,0 1+ ( 7 +( 3:23*141!6& " .

:2/3*141!6& " #0 5 .

7 2)/11::0. &'()*+,'* - ! /&70.

1!21!#. 3*14 56+ 2&7. *+ . *+ - !.

37 7 "* : ; ;. *+ - .

= 4 ,&

(18)

" " $

% ! $ ! # ) * ! $ ) *

% ; ! / 0 ! ! ! #

( ! $ )3* ( ! ' 4 ! ! 4

4 4(3( 4 ' 4(3(

+ ! % ! ,5 $

! < ! < ! = ! = 1

= = 1

< ; ;

<

; ;

! = 1

(19)

2 ; ( ( $ ! ! # ) * ) * + ) * ) * C

37 (

"* 8'3 */> ?3>0

*?* 37 ( - ! 1+ ( "* 8'3 */> +*?)(()3+(>0

*?* 37 - (' "* 8'3 */> ( >0

*?* 37

"* 8'3 */> 3+*)3?(>0 *?* 8'3 */> +*?)(()3+(>0.

= ,, B

% , , , ( ( $ : ! : ( + $ , , , % ! ,,

&RQFOXVLRQHV

(20)

% & '()* + :DUUHQV DEVWUDFW PDFKLQH D WXWRULDO UHFRQVWUXFWLRQ ,-. / 00 "

%& 1 /# ," 2Q WKH $FFHSWDELOLW\ RI $UJXPHWV DQG LWV )XGDPHQWDO 5ROH LQ 1RQPRQRWRQLF 5HD VRQLQJ DQG /RJLF 3URJUDPPLQJ" /" - " 2 3 " ' - 4-23'-5 00!" %!& 6) '" 2" 3#7 3" -" 8 6" 9" 0DNLQJ $UJXPHQW 6\VWHPV &RPSXWDWLRQDOO\

$WWUDFWLYH 3URF ;,,, ,QW &RQI RI WKH &KLOHDQ 6RFLHW\ IRU &RPSXWHU 6FLHQFH 2FWREHU >@ *DUFurD $ - 8QD DSUR[LPDFLuRQ D OD SURJUDPDFLuRQ HQ OuRJLFD UHEDWLEOH GR :RUNVKRS HQ $VSHFWRV

7HRULFRV GH OD ,QWHOLJHQFLD $UWLnFLDO $7,$ %DKurD %ODQFD 2FWXEUH GH

>@ *DUFurD $ - \ 6LPDUL * 5 &RPSLODFLuRQ GH SURJUDPDV OuRJLFRV TXH XWLOL]DQ OD QHJDFLuRQ SRU IDOOD 8QD H[WHQVLuRQ GH OD PuDTXLQD DEVWUDFWD GH :DUUHQ HU &RQJUHVR $UJHQWLQR GH &LHQFLDV GH OD &RPSXWDFLuRQ %DKurD %ODQFD 1RYLHPEUH GH

>@ *DUFurD $ - \ 6LPDUL * 5 'LIHUHQWHV IRUPDV GH KLSuRWHVLV GH PXQGR FHUUDGR HQ OD SURJUDPDFLuRQ HQ OuRJLFD UHEDWLEOH 6HJXQGR &RQJUHVR $UJHQWLQR GH &LHQFLDV GH OD &RPSXWDFLuRQ &$&L& 8QL YHUVLGDG 1DFLRQDO GH 6DQ /XLV 1RYLHPEUH GH

>@ *DUFurD $ - \ 6LPDUL * 5 (O FULWHULR GH HVSHFLnFLGDG HQ OD SURJUDPDFLuRQ HQ OuRJLFD UHEDWLEOH 7HUFHU :RUNVKRS $UJHQWLQR VREUH $VSHFWRV 7HuRULFRV GH OD ,QWHOLJHQFLD $UWLnFLDO $7,$ 8QLYHUVLGDG 1DFLRQDO GH 6DQ /XLV 1RYLHPEUH GH

>@ *DUFurD $ - /D 3URJUDPDFLuRQ HQ /uRJLFD 5HEDWLEOH VX GHnQLFLuRQ WHuRULFD \ FRPSXWDFLRQDO 7HVLV GH 0DJLVWHU HQ &LHQFLDV GH OD &RPSXWDFLuRQ 8QLYHUVLGDG 1DFLRQDO GHO 6XU $JRVWR GH %DKurD %ODQFD $UJHQWLQD

>@ /OR\G - : )RXQGDWLRQV RI /RJLFDO 3URJUDPPLQJ QG HGLWLRQ 6SULQJHU9HUODJ

>@ /RXL 5 3 'HIHDWV DPRQJ DUJXPHQWV D V\VWHP RI GHIHDVLEOH LQIHUHQFH &RPS ,QWHOO >@ /RYHODQG ' $XWRPDWHG 7KHRUHP 3URYLQJ $ /RJLFDO %DVLV 1RUWK +ROODQG 1HZ <RUN >@ 1XWH 'RQDOG %DVLF GHIHDVLEOH ORJLF LQ ,QWHQVLRQDO /RJLFV IRU 3URJUDPPLQJ (G E\ /XLV )DULaQDV GHO

&HUUR &ODUHGRQ 3UHVV ^ 2[IRUG F

>@ 3RROH ' 2Q WKH &RPSDULVRQ RI 7KHRULHV 3UHIHUULQJ WKH PRVW 6SHFLnF ([SODQDWLRQ 3URF RI WKH WK ,QW -RLQW &RQI RQ $UWLnFLDO ,QWHOOLJHQFH

>@ 3UDNNHQ + /RJLFDO 7RROV IRU 0RGHOOLQJ /HJDO $UJXPHQWV 3K' 7KHVLV 9ULMH 8QLYHUVLW\ $PVWHU GDP +RODQGD -DQXDU\

>@ 6LPDUL * 5 &KHVaQHYDU & , DQG *DUFurD $ - 7KH 5ROH RI 'LDOHFWLFV LQ 'HIHDVLEOH $UJXPHQWDWLRQ ;,9 ,QW &RQI RI &KLOHDQ &RPSXWHU 6FLHQFH 6RFLHW\ 1RYHPEHU

>@ 6LPDUL * 5 DQG /RXL 5 3 $ 0DWKHPDWLFDO 7UHDWPHQW RI 'HIHDVLEOH 5HDVRQLQJ DQG LWV ,PSOHPHQ WDWLRQ $UWLnFLDO ,QWHOOLJHQFH ^

>@ 6LPDUL * 5 \ *DUFurD $ - $ .QRZOHGJH 5HSUHVHQWDWLRQ /DQJXDJH IRU 'HIHDVLEOH $UJXPHQWDWLRQ ;;, &RQIHUHQFLD /DWLQRDPHULFDQD GH ,QIRUPuDWLFD &DQHOD %UDVLO $JRVWR

>@ 9DQ 5R\ 3HWHU / &DQ /RJLF 3URJUDPPLJQ ([HFXWH DV )DU DV ,PSHUDWLYH 3URJUDPPLQJ" 3K' 7KHVLV %HUNHOH\ 8QLYHUVLW\

>@ 9UHHVZLMN * 6WXGLHV LQ 'HIHDVLEOH $UJXPHQWDWLRQ 3K' 7KHVLV 9ULMH 8QLYHUVLW\ $PVWHUGDP +RODQGD 0DUFK

>@ :DUUHQ 'DYLG + ' &RPSLOLQJ 3UHGLFDWH /RJLF 3URJUDPV 9ROXPHQHV \ '$, 5HVHDUFK 5HSRUWV 1UR 0D\R GH

>@ :DUUHQ 'DYLG + ' $Q $EVWUDFW 3URORJ ,QVWUXFWLRQ 6HW 7KHFKQLFDO 1RWH 65, ,QWHUQDWLRQDO 0HQOR 3DUN &$ 2FWREHU