Teoría de los juegos y selección de teorías

7HRU˜•D GH ORV -XHJRV \ 6HOHFFL˜

RQ GH 7HRU˜•DV

)HUQDQGR 7RKP˜

H

&ODXGLR 'HOULHX[

'HSWR GH (FRQRP˜•D

'HSWR GH ,QJ (O˜

HFWULFD

*,,$ *UXSR GH ,QYHVWLJDFL˜RQ HQ ,QWHOLJHQFLD $UWL‘FLDO ,&,& ,QVWLWXWR GH &LHQFLDV H ,QJHQLHU˜•D GH &RPSXWDFL˜RQ

8QLYHUVLGDG 1DFLRQDO GHO 6XU

$OHP _ %DK˜•D %ODQFD _$5*(17,1$ FODXGLR#DFPRUJ

3DODEUDV &ODYH ,QWHOLJHQFLD $UWLILFLDO /˜RJLFD \ 7HRU˜•D GH OD &LHQFLD 7HRU˜•D GH ORV -XHJRV

-897,.9

/DV WHRU˜•DV FLHQW˜•‘FDV SXHGHQ FRQVLGHUDUVH FRPR H[WHQVL˜RQHV GH ODV WHRU˜•DV O˜RJLFDV HQ ODV TXH VH LQFRUSRUD XQ FRQMXQWR KHWHURJHQHR \ SRVLEOHPHQWH LQFRQVLVWHQWH GH FRQRFLPLHQWR WHQWDWLYR OH\HV HPS˜•ULFDV FRQMHWXUDV KLS˜RWHVLV DX[LOLDUHV HWF 'LFKR FRQRFLPLHQWR HVW˜D RUJDQL]DGR SRU PHGLR GH XQD MHUDUTX˜•D TXH UHSUHVHQWD XQD GLPHQVL˜RQ SUDJP˜DWLFD TXH WLHQH HQ FXHQWD ORV SRVLEOHV EHQH‘FLRV HQ HO XVR GH GLFKR FRQRFLPLHQWR SRU PHGLR GH SDWURQHV GH LQIHUHQFLD HQJOREDGRV GHQWUR GH OR TXH XVXDOPHQWH VH GHQRPLQD P˜HWRGR FLHQW˜•‘FR 6LQ HPEDUJR HV HVSHUDEOH TXH D SDUWLU GH XQ PLVPR FRQMXQWR GLVSRQLEOH GH FRQRFLPLHQWR WHQWDWLYR GLIHUHQWHV LQYHVWLJDGRUHV DGRSWHQ GLVWLQWDV MHUDUTX˜•DV SRU OR TXH HO FRQMXQWR GH FRQFOXVLRQHV D TXH DUULED FDGD XQR HV WDPEL˜HQ GLIHUHQWH (VWH IHQ˜RPHQR GD RULJHQ D OD FRH[LVWHQFLD GH GRV R P˜DV WHRU˜•DV FLHQW˜•‘FDV GHQWUR GH XQD PLVPD GLVFLSOLQD GRQGH FDGD PLHPEUR GH OD GLVFLSOLQD HOLMH HQWUH ODV GLYHUVDV DOWHUQDWLYDV SRU PHGLR GH DOJ˜XQ PHFDQLVPR GH VHOHFFL˜RQ

7HRU˜•D GH ORV -XHJRV \ 6HOHFFL˜

RQ GH 7HRU˜•DV

,QWURGXFFL˜

RQ

* 0 - 0 / 3 !8'9'$1 * 4 / 0 ! $, ., 3 4 0 . 0. :;1 < , . - , / 3, 0, - 4 0 1 1 * 0 1 ( , 4 , . & , .- 3 4 + - 1 ( 3 =. , 0 0 & 4 0 - 1 * 4 , 0 , +/ , - 0 , 4 ! . 0 , 3 &$ - 1

( 0. . 0 43 , *5 :#;1 * 43 0. 3 3 - 3 1 ( +, & / 3 . - / :>;1 7 0 5 4 3 , =. - 4 1 ( +, ?@ !0. 0$ , 0 + 4 1 , - - 4 . + & ?@1 7 , - + &3 ?4@ ! +, ., 1$ - 4 ?@ , - 1

@ / 1 * 0. 0 1 ( , - 4 8& :";, - 41 * & 43 - 1 * 43 0 ? @ - =. 0 , 0 .1 7 , , + -0 &1

.5 5 \ OD WHRU˜•D GH OD FLHQFLD

2 , +, 0 . - 4 + / 4, , / / 4 1 * 43 / 0. 1 ( / .1 * 3 1 * 4 0 + 1 2 0 4 && 1 ( / 4 / 1 - / 4 . !11, $, &0 4 0 1 0, / . 0, / 1 ( 0 4 1

7 0 :A;1 2 . 4,

, .

- 0 & 1 ( - - 5, VH LQWHUSUHWD FRPR ?HV XQ KHFKR HPS˜•ULFDPHQWH REVHUYDEOH TXH HO REMHWR HQWLGDG IHQ˜RPHQR , WLHQH OD SURSLHGDG FDUDFWHU˜•VWLFD FLUFXQVWDQFLD 5 1RUPDOPHQWH ORV HQXQFLDGRV GH HVWH QLYHO DVXPHQ OD IRUPD GH OLWHUDOHV GH EDVH GRQGH WDQWR ORV SUHGLFDGRV TXH UHSUHVHQ WDQ SURSLHGDGHV FDUDFWHU˜•VWLFDV HWF \ ORV W˜HUPLQRV TXH UHSUHVHQWDQ REMHWRV HQWLGDGHV HWF VRQ REVHUYDEOHV (O VHJXQGR QLYHO HVW˜D FRQVWLWXLGR SRU JHQHUDOL]DFLRQHV HPS˜•ULFDV

% & & !.$

1

% * / %

/ *& 0 + / 1 2 % % % 3 4$ 5 & && & 3 * / C 0 / 0 && * /

0 1 / 1> 1

/ & / ' ' 6 + !"$ % ! 7& * * &

F & H *

F 8

F H 3 & & (

1 && /) !9$ % * * % & 1 /

% % & * / * 5 * * ' & ( / * :&: : ( * & / ; ( * 0 6 & * & * ;0

.5 5

\ ORV

S

URJUD

P

DV GH LQ

Y

HV

W

LJDFL˜

RQ

* / + * * " # /

* L *

* *

% ! 0

< <

<

# <

* <

& * *

'HILQLFL˜

RQ

'DGR XQ FRQWH[WR . 3 HO FRQRFLPLHQWR O˜RJLFRPDWHP˜DWLFR \ ORV SULQ

FLSLRV LQWHUQRV XQD (VWUXFWXUD (SLVW˜HPLFD (.3 HV XQD HVWUXFWXUD GH FRQRFLPLHQWR

(.3 — + * ( & ! GRQGH + HV XQ FRQMXQWR FRQVLVWHQWH GH FRQRFLPLHQWR LQWHQVLRQDO

WDO TXH 3 C + * HV XQ FRQMXQWR ‘QLWR GH FRQGLFLRQDOHV GH OD IRUPD  !ƒƒ ‘ ( HV XQ FRQMXQWR FRQRFLPLHQWR SDUWLFXODU \ & HV XQ FRQMXQWR GH KLS˜RWHVLV DX[LOLDUHV UHSUHVHQWDGDV FRPR FRQRFLPLHQWR WHQWDWLYR GH OD IRUPD OL GRQGH O VRQ OLWHUDOHV GH EDVH H L FRUUHVSRQGH D

XQ FULWHULR GH DFHSWDFL˜RQ &XDQGR HO FRQWH[WR TXHGH FODUDPHQWH GH‘QLGR QRV UHIHULUHPRV D XQD HVWUXFWXUD HSLVW˜HPLFD VLPSOHPHQWH FRPR (

$ GLIHUHQFLD GH XQD WHRU˜•D O˜RJLFD HQ XQD WHRU˜•D FLHQW˜•‘FD H[LVWH QHFHVDULDPHQWH XQD HV WUXFWXUDFL˜RQ MHU˜DUTXLFD GHO FRQRFLPLHQWR &RPR HV SRVLEOH HQWUHYHU XQR GH ORV HOHPHQWRV HVHQFLDOHV HQ QXHVWUD IRUPDOL]DFL˜RQ GH ORV SURJUDPDV GH LQYHVWLJDFL˜RQ FRQVLVWH HQ UHSUH VHQWDU HVWD UHODFL˜RQ GH SUHIHUHQFLD HSLVW˜HPLFD GHQWUR GH ORV HOHPHQWRV GH FRQRFLPLHQWR HQ XQD WHRU˜•D (V GHFLU HO SURJUDPD GH LQYHVWLJDFL˜RQ SRVHH XQ FULWHULR GH FRPSDUDFL˜RQ £ TXH OH SHUPLWH GHFLGLU VL XQD SLH]D GH FRQRFLPLHQWR HV SUHIHULEOH D RWUD SRU VX LPSRUWDQ FLD HSLVW˜HPLFD /RV ˜XQLFRV FRQMXQWRV GH FRQRFLPLHQWR ‘UPH HV GHFLU DTXHOODV SLH]DV GH FRQRFLPLHQWR TXH QR SXHGHQ VHU HQ SULQFLSLR FXHVWLRQDGDV VRQ . \ (

'HILQLFL˜

RQ

'DGD XQD HVWUXFWXUD HSLVW˜HPLFD (

.3 HQ XQ FRQWH[WR .3 XQD 7HRU˜•D 7

WDO TXH ‘ 7 7£‘ 'H HVD PDQHUD 7 TXHGD UHWLFXODGD EDMR £

(V LPSRUWDQWH GHVWDFDU DOJXQRV SXQWRV GH HVWDV GH‘QLFL˜RQHV &DGD WHRU˜•D VHOHFFLRQD HQXQFLDGRV GHO FRQMXQWR WRWDO GH FRQRFLPLHQWR + * ( & ! TXH HV HQ SULQFLSLR GH‘QLEOH GHQWUR GH XQD GLVFLSOLQD (VWRV HQXQFLDGRV FRPR YLPRV QR WLHQHQ HO UHTXLVLWR GH VHU FRQVLVWHQWHV HQWUH V˜• VLQR TXH FDGD XQR GH HOORV GHEH VHU VLPSOHPHQWH FRQVLWHQWH FRQ . > ( $ HVWH VXEFRQMXQWR GH HQXQFLDGRV VH OH DVLJQD DUELWUDULDPHQWH XQ RUGHQ SDUFLDO £ TXH OR HVWUXFWXUD (O RUGHQDPLHQWR GHSHQGHU˜D HVWUDW˜HJLFDPHQWH GHO FRQWH[WR GHQWUR GHO FXDO IXQFLRQH OD WHRU˜•D 'H HVD PDQHUD HQ XQD GLVFLSOLQD SXHGHQ FRH[LVWLU YDULDV WHRU˜•DV VXVWHQWDGD FDGD XQD SRU XQD HVWUXFWXUD HSLVW˜HPLFD GLVWLQWD TXH OD MXVWL‘FD

(O VHJXQGR SDVR HQ QXHVWUD IRUPDOL]DFL˜RQ FRQVLVWH HQ GH‘QLU D XQ SURJUDPD FRPR XQD WHRU˜•D TXH SURJUHVD HQ IXQFL˜RQ GH GHWHUPLQDGRV SURFHGLPLHQWRV GH LQIHUHQFLD 8QR GH ORV DVSHFWRV P˜DV LPSRUWDQWHV FRQVLVWH HQ GHWHUPLQDU FX˜DO HV HO FRQMXQWR GH FRQFOXVLRQHV TXH VH MXVWL‘FDQ D SDUWLU GH XQD WHRU˜•D 7 WDQWR HQ HO FRQWH[WR GH SUHGLFFL˜RQ FRPR HQ HO GH H[SOLFDFL˜RQ 2WURV SURFHGLPLHQWRV GH LQIHUHQFLD UHODFLRQDGRV FRQ ODV FRQWUDVWDFLRQHV QHJDWLYDV OD FRPSDUDFL˜RQ GH WHRU˜•DV R OD MXVWL‘FDFL˜RQ GH QXHYR FRQRFLPLHQWR HQ IXQFL˜RQ GH XQD ?O˜RJLFD GHO GHVFXEULPLHQWR VHU˜DQ SUHVHQWDGDV HQ OD VHFFL˜RQ VLJXLHQWH $OJXQDV GH ODV LGHDV SUHVHQWDGDV HQ HVWD VXEVHFFL˜RQ VH EDVDQ HQ HO VLVWHPD ?3 GH UD]RQDPLHQWR SODXVLEOH > @ HO FXDO HVW˜D D VX YH] LQVSLUDGR HQ ORV WUDEDMRV GH 5HVFKHU >@ \ 5RRV >@ 'DGR TXH ODV WHRU˜•DV QR VRQ QHFHVDULDPHQWH FRQVLVWHQWHV OD LGHD HVHQFLDO HV TXH ODV FRQFOXVLRQHV GH XQD WHRU˜•D VRQ OD FRQVHFXHQFLD GHGXFWLYD GH ORV FRQMXQWRV P˜D[LPDPHQWH FRQVLVWHQWHV GH OD PLVPD

'HILQLFL˜

RQ

'DGD XQD WHRU˜•D 7 \ XQ VXEFRQMXQWR 7 — 7 OD ,PSRUWDQFLD

(SLVW˜HPLFD GH 7 VH GH‘QH FRPR HO FRQMXQWR I 7 M ‘ 7‘£J GH FRWDV LQIHULR UHV GH 7 EDMR £ 'DGRV GRV VXEFRQMXQWRV GH XQD WHRU˜•D 7 \ 7 GLUHPRV TXH 7 HV

HSLVW˜HPLFDPHQWH P˜DV LPSRUWDQWH TXH 7 GHQRWDGR FRPR 7£7 VL \ V˜ROR VL FDGD HQXQ

FLDGR HQ 7 HV DO PHQRV WDQ LPSRUWDQWH HQ 7 FRPR FDGD HQXQFLDGR HQ 7 SHUR H[LVWH SRU

OR PHQRV XQ HQXQFLDGR HQ 7 TXH HV HVWULFWDPHQWH P˜DV LPSRUWDQWH TXH FDGD HQXQFLDGR HQ

7

'DGD XQD WHRU˜•D 7 !FX˜DO HV HO VXEFRQMXQWR FRQVLVWHQWH GH HQXQFLDGRV GH 7 GH PD\RU LPSRUWDQFLD HSLVW˜HPLFD" /D VROXFL˜RQ DTX˜• SURSXHVWD FRQVLVWH HQ FRQVLGHUDU OD LQWHUVHFFL˜RQ GH WRGRV ORV FRQMXQWRV JHQHUDGRV EDMR GLVWLQWDV H[WHQVLRQHV OLQHDOHV GH £

'HILQLFL˜

RQ

'DGD XQD WHRU˜•D 7 ( £ ! XQD ([WHQVL˜RQ /LQHDO O GH £ HV XQD

UHODFL˜RQ TXH FRQWLHQH D £ \ TXH LQGXFH XQ RUGHQ OLQHDO HQ (

(MHPSOR

6XSRQJDPRV TXH WHQHPRV ORV HQXQFLDGRV ( ID E FJ \ TXH OD UHODFL˜RQ GH

SUHIHUHQFLD HQ ( HVWDEOHFH TXH IE£D F£DJ (QWRQFHV WHQHPRV GRV H[WHQVLRQHV OLQHDOHV SRVLEOHV SDUD £ XQD HQ OD FXDO F£E \ RWUD HQ OD FXDO E£F

'HILQLFL˜

RQ

'DGD XQD WHRU˜•D 7 (

.3 £ ! \ XQD H[WHQVL˜RQ OLQHDO O GH £ XQ

6XEFRQMXQWR 0˜D[LPDPHQWH &RQVLVWHQWH 60& GH 7 FRQ UHVSHFWR DO FRQWH[WR .3 HV XQ FRQMXQWR (O _{TXH VDWLVIDFH}

_{$EXVDQGR GH OD QRWDFL˜RQ XWLOL]DUHPRV VXEFRQMXQWRV GH OD HVWUXFWXUD HSLVW˜HPLFD FRPR SDUWH GHO DQ}

(O_{— (}

(O_{> . > 3 C"}

 (O_{‘ ( (}O_‘£

((O Ÿ ( — ( (> . > 3 C"

(V GHFLU XQ 60& HV XQ VXEFRQMXQWR GH OD HVWUXFWXUD HSLVW˜HPLFD ( GH OD WHRU˜•D TXH HV FRQVLVWHQWH FRQ ORV SULQFLSLRV GH OD PLVPD LQFRUSRUD ODV SLH]DV GH FRQRFLPLHQWR GH PD\RU LPSRUWDQFLD HSLVW˜HPLFD GH OD WHRU˜•D \ HV PD[LPDO HQ HO VHQWLGR GH TXH QR SXHGH DJUHJ˜DUVHOH QLQJXQD SLH]D GH FRQRFLPLHQWR GH OD WHRU˜•D VLQ TXH SLHUGD VX FRQVLVWHQFLD

/D LQWHUVHFFL˜RQ GH WRGRV ORV 60& GH 7 HV XQ VXEFRQMXQWR GH ( 6L FRQVLGHUDPRV D ORV FRQGLFLRQDOHV HQ GLFKD LQWHUVHFFL˜RQ FRPR LPSOLFDFLRQHV PDWHULDOHV \ D OD LQIRUPDFL˜RQ SODXVLEOH FRPR OLWHUDOHV REWHQHPRV OD 6XEWHRU˜•D (VF˜HSWLFD 7 GH 7 FRQ UHVSHFWR DO

FRQWH[WR . 3 ! \ D OD UHODFL˜RQ GH LPSRUWDQFLD HSLVW˜HPLFD £ 'LFKD VXEWHRU˜•D HVW˜D GHQWUR GHO OHQJXDMH GH OD O˜RJLFD FO˜DVLFD (O FRQMXQWR &7 GH &RQFOXVLRQHV SUHGLFFLRQHV R H[SOLFDFLRQHV GH XQD WHRU˜•D 7 HQWRQFHV HV OD FODXVXUD GHGXFWLYD GH VX VXEWHRU˜•D HVF˜HSWLFD MXQWR FRQ HO FRQWH[WR HV GHFLU &7 7KI. > 3 > 7J

(V LPSRUWDQWH PHQFLRQDU TXH H[LVWH SURFHGLPLHQWR HIHFWLYR GH SUXHED SDUD GHWHUPLQDU VL XQD VHQWHQFLD GDGD HVW˜D HQ HO FRQMXQWR GH FRQFOXVLRQHV GH XQD WHRU˜•D

'HILQLFL˜

RQ

'DGD XQD WHRU˜•D 7 (

.3 £ ! \ XQD FRQVXOWD T WDO TXH QL . > 3 C T

QL . > 3 C T (QWRQFHV GH‘QLPRV

)XQGDPHQWR T WLHQH IXQGDPHQWR VL H[LVWH XQ FRQMXQWR GH IXQGDPHQWR (1 — ( WDO

TXH (1 > . > 3 C T

'XGD T HVW˜D HQ GXGD VL H[LVWH XQ FRQMXQWR GH GXGD (/— ( WDO TXH (/> . > 3 C T

$FHSWDFL˜RQ T HV DFHSWDGR VL WLHQH IXQGDPHQWR \ QR HVW˜D HQ GXGD R ELHQ VL (/£(1

HV GHFLU OD LPSRUWDQFLD HSLVW˜HPLFD GH VX FRQMXQWR GH IXQGDPHQWR HV PD\RU TXH OD GH VX FRQMXQWR GH GXGD

(VWD GH‘QLFL˜RQ HV HIHFWLYDPHQWH FRPSXWDEOH \D TXH LQFXUUH HQ XQD GREOH UHFXUVL˜RQ \ ODV LQYRFDFLRQHV D GHPRVWUDELOLGDG +RUQ DO UHDOL]DUVH SRU HQFDGHQDPLHQWR KDFLD DWU˜DV VH FRPSXWDQ FRQ W˜HFQLFDV HVW˜DQGDU GH SURJUDPDFL˜RQ HQ O˜RJLFD (O VLJXLHQWH WHRUHPD PXHVWUD TXH HO SURFHGLPLHQWR GH DFHSWDFL˜RQ GHVFULSWR HV FRUUHFWR \ FRPSOHWR FRQ UHVSHFWR D OD GH‘QLFL˜RQ GH FRQFOXVLRQHV GH XQD WHRU˜•D

7HRUHPD

'DGD XQD WHRU˜•D 7 (

.3 £ ! T HV DFHSWDGD FRQ IXQGDPHQWR Ÿ (1 — (

VL \ VROR VL T SHUWHQHFH D OD LQWHUVHFFL˜RQ GH WRGRV ORV VXEFRQMXQWRV P˜D[LPDPHQWH FRQVLV WHQWHV GH 7 EDMR GLVWLQWDV H[WHQVLRQHV OLQHDOHV GH £

'HPRVWUDFL˜RQ

6L T SHUWHQHFH DO FRQMXQWR &7 GH FRQFOXVLRQHV HQWRQFHV . > 3 > 7M T \ SRU OR WDQWR

. > 3 > (O_{M T SDUD WRGD 60& (}O _{TXH VH REWLHQHQ HQ WRGD H[WHQVL˜RQ OLQHDO O GH OD UHODFL˜RQ}

£ /XHJR HQ WRGD 0&6 (O _{GH 7 FRQ UHVSHFWR DO FRQWH[WR . 3 ! H[LVWH DOJ˜XQ FRQ}

MXQWR GH IXQGDPHQWR (O

VWDO TXH . > 3 > (OV M T (Q GLFKR FDVR VXSRQJDPRV TXH H[LVWH XQ

FRQMXQWR GH GXGD Ÿ (G— ( WDO TXH HQ FRQMXQFL˜RQ FRQ HO FRQWH[WR . 3 ! LPSOLTXHQ

O˜RJLFDPHQWH D T 6L QR H[LVWHVH XQ FRQMXQWR GH GXGD (GGH WDOHV FDUDFWHU˜•VWLFDV HQWRQFHV T

HVWDU˜•D IXQGDPHQWDGD \ QR HVWDU˜•D HQ GXGD SRU OR TXH T VHU˜•D DFHSWDGD 4(' 6L H[LVWH XQ FRQMXQWR GH GXGD (G HQWRQFHV GDGR TXH 7HV FRQVLVWHQWH SRU KLS˜RWHVLV HQWRQFHV GHEH

VHU TXH (O_G£(O_VHQ WRGD H[WHQVL˜RQ OLQHDO O GH £ \ HQ FRQFHFXHQFLD HQ OD UHODFL˜RQ £ PLVPD VH GHEH FXPSOLU (G£(V (Q GLFKR FDVR T HV DFHSWDGD GDGR TXH VX FRQMXQWR GH IXQGDPHQWR

HV GH PD\RU LPSRUWDQFLD HSLVW˜HPLFD TXH VX FRQMXQWR GH GXGD HQ WRGD H[WHQVL˜RQ OLQHDO GH OD UHODFL˜RQ £ 4('

(VWR FRPSOHWD OD SULPHUD PLWDG GH OD GHPRVWUDFL˜RQ

6XSRQJDPRV TXH T HV DFHSWDGD FRQ XQ FRQMXQWR GH IXQGDPHQWR (V WDO TXH Ÿ (V — 7

(Q GLFKR FDVR VXSRQJDPRV TXH H[LVWH XQ FRQMXQWR GH GXGD (G WDO TXH Ÿ (G — ( \

TXH MXQWR FRQ . \ ( LPSOLTXHQ O˜RJLFDPHQWH D T 1XHYDPHQWH VL QR H[LVWLHUD XQ FRQ MXQWR GH GXGD (G HQWRQFHV (V VHU˜•D FRQVLVWHQWH FRQ HO FRQWH[WR . 3 ! \ SRU OR WDQWR

. > 3 > 7 LPSOLFDU˜•D O˜RJLFDPHQWH D T VLQ FRQWUDGLFFL˜RQ 4(' 6L H[LVWH XQ FRQMXQWR

GH GXGD (G HQWRQFHV GDGR TXH SRU KLS˜RWHVLV T HV DFHSWDGD HQWRQFHV VH GHEH FXPSOLU TXH

(G£(V (Q GLFKR FDVR GH DFXHUGR D OD GH‘QLFL˜RQ HQ WRGD H[WHQVL˜RQ OLQHDO O VH GHEH

FXPSOLU OD FRQGLFL˜RQ (O

G£(OV (QWRQFHV VH VLJXH TXH (V GHEH SHUWHQHFHU D WRGDV ODV 0&6

GH ( FRQ UHVSHFWR DO FRQWH[WR . 3 ! \ FRQVHFXHQWHPHQWH D OD VXEWHRU˜•D HVF˜HSWLFD 7

TXH HV OD LQWHUVHFFL˜RQ GH WRGDV GLFKDV 60& 3RU ‘Q OD VXEWHRU˜•D HVF˜HSWLFD GH 7 MXQWR FRQ HO FRQWH[WR GHEHQ LPSOLFDU O˜RJLFDPHQWH D T VLQ FRQWUDGLFFL˜RQ 4('

6HOHFFL˜

RQ GH

W

HRU˜•DV

+, - . + - /

'HILQLFL˜

RQ

'DGD XQD HVWUXFWXUD HSLVW˜HPLFD (

.3\ XQ FRQMXQWR GH Q DJHQWHV

$ 0 ILJ % ™ L ™ Q FDGD DJHQWH L WLHQH XQD SUHIHUHQFLD £L TXH GHWHUPLQD FX˜DO HV

VX FRQMXQWR GH FRQVHFXHQFLDV P˜D[LPDPHQWH FRQVLVWHQWH 60& R WHRU˜•D 7L HOHJLGD (O

FRQMXQWR 7 0 I7 M7 HV 60& GH (.3J GHQRWD WRGDV ODV WHRU˜•DV FRQVLVWHQWHV SRVLEOHV GH

ODV FXDOHV HQ XQ GHWHUPLQDGR PRPHQWR FDGD DJHQWH L HOLJL˜R 7L 7 'HQRPLQDUHPRV

SHU‘O 3 0 17 „ „ „ 732 73 DO FRQMXQWR GH HOHFFLRQHV VLPXOW˜DQHDV GH ORV Q DJHQWHV 'H

HVD PDQHUD H[LVWHQ M73_{M SRVLEOHV SHU‘OHV FDGD XQR GH ORV FXDOHV EULQGD DSR\R D OD HOHFFL˜RQ}

VRFLDO GH SRU OR PHQRV XQD WHRU˜•D

'HILQLFL˜

RQ

'DGD XQD HVWUXFWXUD HSLVW˜HPLFD (

.3FRQ VX FRQMXQWR 7 GH 60& R WHRU˜•DV

\ XQ FRQMXQWR GH DJHQWHV $ FDGD XQR FRQ VX SUHIHUHQFLD £L HQWRQFHV HO SURFHVR GH HOHFFL˜RQ

VRFLDO GH WHRU˜•DV SXHGH UHSUHVHQWDUVH FRQ XQ MXHJR 6 K$ 7 I£LJL (Q 6 VH HVWDEOHFH

XQD FRUUHVSRQGHQFLD

Ÿ 7Q 7

WDO TXH XQD GHWHUPLQDGD WHRU˜•D 7V _{HVW˜D HQ FRUUHVSRQGHQFLD FRQ R FRQGLFLRQD SDUD OD}

HOHFFL˜RQ GH XQ SHU‘O GDGR 3 7L 7Q VROR VL 7V HV OD P˜DV IUHFXHQWH HQ GLFKR

SHU‘O HV GHFLU

7V Ÿ7L 7Q VROR VL SDUD WRGD 7 7V MIWWWL WWWVJM š MI7L 7 JM

+DVWD DTX˜• QR WHQHPRV FULWHULRV JHQHUDOHV SDUD ODV SUHIHUHQFLDV GH ORV DJHQWHV SRU ORV SHU‘OHV I£LJL1 FULWHULRV TXH GHEHQ DGHP˜DV VHU GLVWLQJXLGRV FXLGDGRVDPHQWH GH ORV

FULWHULRV SDUWLFXODUHV TXH XWLOL]D FDGD DJHQWH SDUD HOHJLU VX WHRU˜•D D SDUWLU GH OD LQIRUPDFL˜RQ GLVSRQLEOH 3DUD LOXVWUDU HVWH SXQWR FRQ XQ HMHPSOR HQFRQWUDUHPRV XQD HVWUDWHJLD TXH GHEH VHJXLU XQ DJHQWH SDUD SHUWHQHFHU D OD WHRU˜•D PD\RULWDULD

(MHPSOR

'DGR XQ SHU‘O 3 7 7_Q \ XQ DJHQWH L XQD HVWUDWHJLD TXH GHEH

VHJXLU L SDUD SHUWHQHFHU D OD WHRU˜•D PD\RULWDULD GDGDV ODV HOHFFLRQHV FRQMXQWDV GH ORV GHP˜DV DJHQWHV 3SL 7 7LS 7L 7Q HV JHQHUDU ODV VLJXLHQWHV SUHIHUHQFLDV

7L 7SL ›L 7VL 7SL

WDO TXH

MI7M 7VLJMLM ! MI7M 7LJMLM

R VH FXPSOH TXH

MI7M 7VLJMLM MI7M 7LJMLM SHUR 7L ›L7VL

/DV VXSRVLFLRQHV LPSOLFDQ TXH ORV DJHQWHV DFW˜XDQ GH DFXHUGR D ODV FUHHQFLDV TXH WLHQHQ UHVSHFWR GH ODV SUHIHUHQFLDV GH ORV GHP˜DV (VWDV FUHHQFLDV UHSUHVHQWDQ ODV FRQMHWXUDV TXH ORV DJHQWHV UHDOL]DQ DFHUFD GH OD HVWUXFWXUD GHO MXHJR 'DGR TXH QRUPDOPHQWH HO SURFHVR GH GLVFXVL˜RQ FLHQW˜•‘FD HV S˜XEOLFR HV MXVWR DVXPLU TXH ODV SUHIHUHQFLDV GH FDGD DJHQWH VRQ FRQRFLGDV SRU ORV GHP˜DV $SDUWLU GH WRGRV HVWRV HOHPHQWRV HV SRVLEOH SUHGHFLU TXH OD VLWXDFL˜RQ GHWHUPLQD XQ HTXLOLEULR >@

'HILQLFL˜

RQ

8Q SHU‘O _{L Q} HV XQ HTXLOLEULR GH 1DVK VROR VL SDUD WRGR

DJHQWH L QR H[LVWH _L WDO TXH L Q L L Q

3URSLHGDG 'DGD XQD HVWUXFWXUD HSLVW˜HPLFD _.3FRQ VX FRQMXQWR 7 GH 60& R WHRU˜•DV \ XQ FRQMXQWR GH DJHQWHV $ FDGD XQR FRQ VX SUHIHUHQFLD £L HQWRQFHV HO SURFHVR GH HOHFFL˜RQ

VRFLDO GH WHRU˜•DV WLHQH XQ HTXLOLEULR GH 1DVK 7 7Q WDO TXH 7L 7M SDUD WRGR SDU

GH DJHQWHV L M 'HPRVWUDFL˜RQ

&RQVLGHUHPRV XQ SHU‘O 7V ₇V _{3DUD WRGR DJHQWH L VH FXPSOH TXH MI7}

M 7VJMLM

Q ƒ HV GHFLU QR KD\ RWUD WHRU˜•D 7L WDO TXH MI7M 7LJMLM š MI7M 7VJMLM /XHJR

7 7Q 7Q£L7V 7V SDUD WRGD WHRU˜•D 7L OR TXH SRU GH‘QLFL˜RQ VLJQL‘FD

TXH 7V ₇V _{HV XQ HTXLOLEULR GH 1DVK}

$KRUD VXSRQJDPRV TXH H[LVWH RWUR HTXLOLEULR GH 1DVK 7 7L 7Q WDO TXH SDUD

SRU OR PHQRV GRV DJHQWHV GLVWLQWRV L M VH FXPSOH TXH SUH‘HUHQ WHRU˜•DV 7L 7M GLIHUHQWHV

(Q HVWD VLWXDFL˜RQ SXHGHQ GDUVH GRV FDVRV

” ([LVWH XQD WHRU˜•D 7V _{7 WDO TXH MI7}

M 7V 7LJMLM ! MI7M 7LJMLM

3RU OR WDQWR 7 7L 7Q £L 7 7V 7Q 3HUR ˜HVWR HV DEVXUGR

GDGR TXH SRU VXSRVLFL˜RQ 7 7L 7Q HUD XQ HTXLOLEULR GH 1DVK

” 6H FXPSOH TXH MI7M 7LJMLM ! MI7M 7LJMLM

(QWRQFHV SDUD WRGR M WDO TXH 7M 7LVH FXPSOH TXH 7 7L 7M 7Q £M

7 7L 7L 7Q 3HUR WDPEL˜HQ HV DEVXUGR GDGR TXH SRU VXSRVLFL˜RQ

7 7L 7M 7Q HUD XQ HTXLOLEULR GH 1DVK

8Q HMHPSOR VHQFLOOR SHUPLWLU˜D LOXVWUDU HVWRV FRQFHSWRV

(MHPSOR

([LVWHQ WUHV DJHQWHV L M DQG N &DGD XQR SXHGH HOHJLU HQWUH WUHV WHRULDV

7 I7 7 7J &DGD DJHQWH WLHQH XQ RUGHQ GH SUHIHUHQFLDV

L 7£L 7 £L 7

M 7 £M 7 £M 7

N 7 £N 7£N7

/RV ˜RUGHQHV GH SUHIHUHQFLDV HQWUH ORV SHU‘OHV SXHGHQ UHSUHVHQWDUVH SRU PHGLR GH XQD IXQFL˜RQ GH SDJR   WDO TXH VL SDUD XQ DJHQWH L \ SDUD ORV SHU‘OHV 3 \ 3 _{VH FXPSOH TXH}

3 £L3 HQWRQFHV  3 \  3 'H HVD PDQHUD VH SXHGHQ DJUXSDU ODV SUHIHUHQ

% & ! '( % )

% % %

%

(Q HO HMHPSOR VHaQDODGR HO SHU‘O % % % DVLJQD XQ SDJR D WRGRV ORV DJHQWHV

7DPEL˜HQ VH REVHUYD TXH ORV SHU‘OHV TXH VRQ HTXLOLEULR GH 1DVK DVLJQD XQ SDJR D WRGRV ORV DJHQWHV VRQ DTXHOORV HQ TXH H[LVWH XQD WHRU˜•D KHJHP˜RQLFD

&RPR PXHVWUD HVWH HMHPSOR XQD VROXFL˜RQ QR GHVHDGD SRU OD PD\RU˜•D HQ HVWH FDVR %

SXHGH VHU WDPEL˜HQ HOHJLGD (VWH UHVXOWDGR HV LQGHVHDGR SHUR OD ˜XQLFD PDQHUD GH HYLWDUOR HV SRU PHGLR GH XQD GHFLVL˜RQ FRQMXQWD GDGR TXH QLQJ˜XQ DJHQWH WLHQH LQFHQWLYR SDUD GHVYLDUVH LQGLYLGXDOPHQWH GH OD GHFLVL˜RQ GH OD PD\RU˜•D 3HUR XQD FRDOLFL˜RQ HV GHFLU XQ VXEFRQMXQWR GH SXHGH FRRUGLQDUVH \ DSDUWDUVH FRQMXQWDPHQWH GHO UHVXOWDGR LQGHVHDGR /D QRFL˜RQ GH HTXLOLEULR GH 1DVK LQPXQH D ODV FRDOLFLRQHV HV XQD SURSXHVWD SDUD UHSUHVHQWDU SHU‘OHV HVWDEOHV IUHQWH D FDPELRV LQGLYLGXDOHV R FRQMXQWRV >@

'HILQLFL˜

RQ

8Q SHU‘O % %_L 7_Q HV XQ HTXLOLEULR GH 1DVK LQPXQH D ODV

FRDOLFLRQHV VROR VL QR H[LVWH XQ VXEJUXSR $ Ÿ $ \ XQ SHU‘O 7 7L 7Q_L$ WDO

TXH 7 7L 7Q £L 7 7L 7Q_L$

6L SURSRQHPRV FRPR VROXFL˜RQ HVWH WLSR GH SHU‘OHV HQWRQFHV HQ HO HMHPSOR DQWHULRU W W W \D QR HV P˜DV XQD VROXFL˜RQ HVWDEOH GDGR TXH OD GHFLVL˜RQ FRQMXQWD GH L M \ N

SXHGH OOHYDUORV D HOHJLU W W W FRPR PHMRU VROXFL˜RQ 0˜DV D˜XQ HO RWUR HTXLOLEULR GH

1DVK W W W SHUPLWH XQD GHVYLDFL˜RQ SRU SDUWH GH OD FRDOLFL˜RQ IRUPDGD SRU L \ N OD

FXDO OOHYD QXHYDPHQWH D W W W OD FXDO FRQVWLWX\H HO ˜XQLFR HTXLOLEULR GH 1DVK D SUXHED

GH FRDOLFLRQHV 3HVH D TXH HVWH PRGHOR GH VROXFL˜RQ SDUHFH P˜DV DGHFXDGR WDPEL˜HQ WLHQH OD GHVYHQWDMD GH TXH SXHGHQ H[LVWLU FDVRV VLQ HTXLOLEULRV LQPXQHV D ODV FRDOLFLRQHV _6LQ

HPEDUJR HVWH WLSR GH VLWXDFLRQHV HV FRQVLVWHQWH FRQ ORV HMHPSORV KLVW˜RULFRV DOJXQRV GH ORV FXDOHV IXHURQ PHQFLRQDGRV P˜DV DUULED

&

R

PS

DUDFL˜

RQ GH

W

HRU˜•DV \ OD H

Y

ROXFL˜

RQ GH XQ

3

URJUD

P

D

(O FULWHULR GH FRPSDUDFL˜RQ GH WHRU˜•DV GHQWUR GHO FRPSRUWDPLHQWR GH XQ SURJUDPD VH EDVD HQ OD UHODFL˜RQ GH LPSRUWDQFLD HSLVW˜HPLFD GH FDGD XQD (V GHFLU DQWH WRGR ODV WHRU˜•DV D FRPSDUDU GHEHQ WHQHU XQD HVWUXFWXUD HSLVW˜HPLFD FRP˜XQ FRPSDUWHQ HO PLVPR FRQRFL PLHQWR SHUR GL‘HUHQ HQ OD LPSRUWDQFLD TXH OH DVLJQDQ D FDGD HQXQFLDGR 6L ODV WHRU˜•DV

_{3RU HMHPSOR FDVRV DQ˜DORJRV DO SUREOHPD GH ODV PD\RU˜•DV F˜•FOLFDV TXH VRQ VXE\DFHQWHV D OD SDUDGRMD GH}

%&

% '

# ]D DO SURJUDPD D HYROXFLRQDU GH PDQHUD GH DVLPLODU OD QXHYD HYLGHQFLD

(MHPSOR

6HD OD WHRU˜•D 7 ID D !ƒƒ EJ IJ ! (VWD WHRU˜•D SUHGLFH E !4X˜H VXFHGH

VL E QR VH REVHUYD HV GHFLU VL KD\ HYLGHQFLD FLHUWD TXH E" (Q HVWD VLWXDFL˜RQ VH SXHGHQ GDU YDULRV FDVRV

(Q HO SULPHUR VH FUHD XQD WHRU˜•D 7 ID E D !ƒƒ EJ ID£E D£D !ƒƒ EJ ! 6HJ˜XQ

7 OD FDXVD GHO IUDFDVR HV GHELGD D D TXH QR HVW˜D GHELGDPHQWH MXVWL‘FDGD SHUR D !ƒƒ E

VH SXHGH VHJXLU PDQWHQLHQGR HV P˜DV FUHD OD SUHVXSRVLFL˜RQ GH TXH D OD FXDO KDEU˜D TXH FRUURERUDU

(Q HO VHJXQGR FDVR VH FUHD RWUD WHRU˜•D 7 ID E D !ƒƒ EJ ID£E D !ƒƒ E£DJ !

6HJ˜XQ 7 OD FDXVD GHO IUDFDVR HV GHELGD D D !ƒƒ E TXH HVW˜D IDOVDGD SRU OD HYLGHQFLD SHUR

HO GDWR D VH SXHGH VHJXLU PDQWHQLHQGR (O DEDQGRQR GH OD OH\ HQ HVWH FDVR LPSOLFD HO DEDQGRQR GHO SURJUDPD

3XHGHQ H[LVWLU FDVRV HQ ORV TXH VH DJUHJDQ KLS˜RWHVLV DX[LOLDUHV F SDUD SURWHJHU D OD ?OH\ GH VHU IDOVDGD FUH˜DQGRVH XQD WHRU˜•D 7 ID F E D !ƒƒ E D F !ƒƒ EJ IJ ! 6HJ˜XQ 7

OD FDXVD GHO IUDFDVR HV GHELGD D TXH D !ƒƒ E VLVWHPDWL]D VROR XQD SDUWH GHO FRQRFLPLHQWR SHUR GHEH H[LVWLU RWUD OH\ D F !ƒƒ E TXH OD FRPSOHWD SDUD OD VLWXDFL˜RQ SDUWLFXODU F

(Q HVWH ˜XOWLPR HMHPSOR SRGHPRV YHU OD HYROXFL˜RQ IRUPDO GH QXPHURVRV FDVRV KLVW˜RULFRV OD UDGLDFL˜RQ GH IRQGR GHO XQLYHUVR OD GHULYD FRQWLQHQWDO OD PHF˜DQLFD UHODWLYLVWD \ PXFKRV P˜DV GRQGH VH SDUWL˜R GH XQD WHRU˜•D 7 WUDGLFLRQDOPHQWH DFHSWDGD OD FXDO IUDFDVDED HQ DOJXQRV FDVRV SDUWLFXODUHV (Q HVWD VLWXDFL˜RQ VLHPSUH VH GHVHD HYLWDU OOHJDU D OD WHRU˜•D 7 GDGR TXH LPSOLFD SHUGHU XQD OH\ FRQVWLWXWLYD GHO SURJUDPD SRU FDXVD GH XQ UHVXO

WDGR SDUWLFXODU HO FXDO VL ELHQ HV HYLGHQFLD TXH GHEH VHU WHQLGD HQ FXHQWD SXHGH HVWDU GLVWRUVLRQDGD SRU HUURUHV PHWRGRO˜RJLFRV R VLVWHP˜DWLFRV R VXMHWD D HIHFWRV QR FRQRFLGRV

(Q ORV HMHPSORV KLVW˜RULFRV OD OH\ QXQFD IXH DEDQGRQDGD SURWHJL˜HQGRVH DO SURJUDPD UHFKD]DQGR ORV GDWRV \ EXVFDQGR QXHYRV FDVR 7 R ELHQ FXDQGR ˜HVWRV GDWRV VH FRUUR

ERUDEDQ HQ IRUPD DEUXPDGRUD DOJR TXH OOHYDU˜•D DO FDVR 7HQ IRUPD LQHYLWDEOH EXVFDQGR

FRQGLFLRQHV SDUWLFXODUHV \ QXHYDV OH\HV TXH OD FRPSOHWDUDQ FDVR 7 /D VLWXDFL˜RQ P˜DV

VHQFLOOD SHUR OD PHQRV SURJUHVLYD HV LQWHQWDU LU VLHPSUH KDFLD OD VLWXDFL˜RQ WLSR 7 \ HQ

HVH VHQWLGR HV TXH HVWDPRV HQ XQD VLWXDFL˜RQ VLPLODU D OD GHO (MHPSOR GRQGH HQ SULPHUD LQVWDQFLD WRGRV ORV DJHQWHV UD]RQDGRUHV HOLJHQ HVWD WHRU˜•D \ HO SHU‘O HV LQPXQH D FRDOLFLRQHV (V LPSRUWDQWH GHVWDFDU TXH DTX˜• H[LVWH XQ DVSHFWR PHWRGRO˜RJLFR DO TXH SRGHPRV GH QRPLQDU PHWDHVWUDWHJLD GDGR TXH IXHU]D OD HOHFFL˜RQ GH XQD GHWHUPLQDGD HVWUDWHJLD SDUD GHIHQGHU DO SURJUDPD (Q OD SU˜DFWLFD ˜HVWR SXHGH YROYHUVH LQVRVWHQLEOH SRU OR FXDO HV QHFH VDULR LQWHQWDU LU KDFLD OD VLWXDFL˜RQ 7 JHQHUDQGR QXHYR FRQRFLPLHQWR VL HV TXH VH GHVHD

&

RQFOXVLRQHV \

W

UD

E

D

M

R

I

X

W

XUR

! # # & !' # ! $ # $ ! (

# $ ) $ * + $

* # $ # , (

5

H

I

HUHQFLDV

-./ 0 0 0 , 1 2 & , 3 4 5 & I (FRQRPLF 7KHRU\ ^

+ # #,! -. /0 *

1"( 2 & '& !! "( '!!,!!!

* 3 4 ! " # $ % &, 1 !! -. /0 5*

5 3 4 6, &, 7( 8 9 % *+* *

3( :%!0 & '" ;$< 9 =! ;! ;( *

&,! :, " ( 7 5>

70! ) "( ?%!@ !! >

> 70! % ( * & + $ "( ?%!@ !! 5

2, ',@ ', 7( ;A ( ,!& ! ! ! BC +

: & " 4,! 7 *

+ -,! !, " # '3.$4 -. /0 5 -,! !, %. ( D 3 , 5

* - ! ; 7( 8 !( ., !! :.( !" * BC5>

5 ' #,"0 3 &,@ '! ',! 9! : ;. ' ( ! /.0 + % (! ++ -,$4 ;!

3 # ; " !" @ $ %!" 12 -!$ - ! $ (! > =! ;!