La autodeterminación
Mar Morón VelascoADVERTIMENT. La consulta d’aquesta tesi queda condicionada a l’acceptació de les següents condicions d'ús: La difusió d’aquesta tesi per mitjà del servei TDX (www.tdx.cat) ha estat autoritzada pels titulars dels drets de propietat intel·lectual únicament per a usos privats emmarcats en activitats d’investigació i docència. No s’autoritza la seva reproducció amb finalitats de lucre ni la seva difusió i posada a disposició des d’un lloc aliè al servei TDX. No s’autoritza la presentació del seu contingut en una finestra o marc aliè a TDX (framing). Aquesta reserva de drets afecta tant al resum de presentació de la tesi com als seus continguts. En la utilització o cita de parts de la tesi és obligat indicar el nom de la persona autora.
ADVERTENCIA. La consulta de esta tesis queda condicionada a la aceptación de las siguientes condiciones de uso: La difusión de esta tesis por medio del servicio TDR (www.tdx.cat) ha sido autorizada por los titulares de los derechos de propiedad intelectual únicamente para usos privados enmarcados en actividades de investigación y docencia. No se autoriza su reproducción con finalidades de lucro ni su difusión y puesta a disposición desde un sitio ajeno al servicio TDR. No se autoriza la presentación de su contenido en una ventana o marco ajeno a TDR (framing). Esta reserva de derechos afecta tanto al resumen de presentación de la tesis como a sus contenidos. En la utilización o cita de partes de la tesis es obligado indicar el nombre de la persona autora.
WARNING. On having consulted this thesis you’re accepting the following use conditions: Spreading this thesis by the TDX (www.tdx.cat) service has been authorized by the titular of the intellectual property rights only for private uses placed in investigation and teaching activities. Reproduction with lucrative aims is not authorized neither its spreading and availability from a site foreign to the TDX service. Introducing its content in a window or frame foreign to the TDX service is not authorized (framing). This rights affect to the presentation summary of the thesis as well as to its contents. In the using or citation of parts of the thesis it’s obliged to indicate the name of the author.
LA CREACIÓN ARTÍSTICA EN LA EDUCACIÓN DE LAS
PERSONAS CON
DISCAPACIDAD INTELECTUAL
LA AUTODETERMINACIÓN
Tesis doctoral de Mar Morón Velasco
21
CAPÍTULO PRIMERO. REFERENTES TEÓRICOS PARA UN PROYECTO EDUCTIVO
(I) MODELOS PEDAGÓGICOS Y PSICOLÓGICOS
Sinopsis capítulo primero
* ) " X _ & 'k " ) ^ W ~ ' " / W ) & /& /#^ ( ( " (( ( >> w ( ((^'W W" "~("W "W ( / ( "'/ W { (( ( (""~ "" w " w ^ w& ((^((>>~ ^(&/""9) "~w& ~ #" &"W"(
22
1.1.- EVOLUCION DE LAS CONCEPCIONES SOBRE EDUCACIÓN Y SU INFLUENCIA EN LA PRÁCTICA '=(>H>"(>>~ ~&^( & 3 ~ 9) / ")"" ( " " /&W/ (""^~^ ( ' w " w w w 'W ~ ) " X ~ ~X)=~ " /W Ww) ="W )"~) & /=) ~/((^ ~w^" w" w= ( W ~ ~ / ~ ( &" /"~/ ( / ~ supone su estudio.» !N"`;[?;] ~" /)~(^~ ) _!N" `;[k H / = QW/W(~~&(~
23 ("(>>) ^/" ^ (&( " ~~W") )"9(&~() ) W ~ ~ W / ~ /=~ " ( w ~" 56`[;?]< #=&W)1?(~ w(W~^"( 9_W)<<U?8k ^ X / W '2 w ! + , _<<`k ^w(^~( " ( ~&~~= ^! W & '<<`?8[ ' _<<`k = ((^ w ~ ~ / X _k"~( 7&((^ w*&"~ (^~("~"&~ /_k" ( 1 Fernando HernándezW*((#@@''3@ ?; G "_`]```8k !"'+ < _``k& ) ; _``]k+I_<<<k 2 María Acaso/ '@@''3#%
24 ((^ ) ~ W W W " /W ( ~/~ W Ac<<`?RU ( "(_& wk ^ ( ( / w 7 ) (^ _k ~ w~~W" /(=& "~)" / / " w 9 "~/ X_<<]k9W 7 _k~(=^" * ) ( )X'^ ~ ~ W W &W " *(/) = =X &~"w~ ((/W^) & ~ & && ( ( /(^~="~ *(%&X<<U?[8 /)~~W ^& ~ " " ( ~ 3(w~"
U /~/ " ~)K#3 _<<;k w ~ X ~ ~ & " ( " " ^ " //~W =^~ ) / ( ""^~ & ) ~ &( 5^%X<<]?R] # ( ~ " /(w7/&9 W & ^( "X(? "W"*( ?&w&( w /(^ " W " & ) & /&(w" & (?/ "w "/ "" ~ & ( W ~ w ( >> " %*((56!"#$ 3 Victòria Camps/"^=3' @
; %&'())""7&* +/ Q(( = W & 9)) ' (("
1.2- MODELOS EDUCATIVOS Y TEORÍAS PSICOLÓGICAS REFERENCIALES
1.2.1- La Escuela Nueva ( ( ((^=9 9 ~ ) " & & ( "&~("& )(&"&&&~^)"( ~^(/^"&&~^" &9 $4%())``;?88 Los precursores { U Q " *)) { /=*& / W " w 4 Adolphe Ferrière_57)][``;<k*((*<9 ( ?"9 ) X^^^" = ~"9" }?! `<! ++`;! G `]?0 ``! + 0); + )
5 Lev Nikoláyevich Tolstói_Q]]`<k/W(
""~ = /"=7K/( 5&"%& (
[ w " ) ((^ " " ^ " { w / " * X " ~ ( " ~ 7 ( ( ( _/ & ( " k ( ( wW ][ ) w " ( " '{ ? { X ~ ' & ( # & & " W ~ X X )' <<U?; {X = /Rousseau6"! &) & & " ^ )"() ))"&" H~W"(~ ^~~9)"W~) W( &(~W /~^((( & ~ ) X " )W &=/)#W( W""/) W~( Q`[8?[;[[ 6 Jean-Jacques Rousseau_57)[[[]k= /"= ^/H "=( QW ""7^"(Q / ^"*"7 W? y +.
] *Q9&" ~"7 ^")~/) ( ^ W ( " Pestalozzi7[]<K9~w W~w^/ X ~ ) 9 " "~^( _&k)() ~X "7XWW? " 9 ( X W " ") 7 &&w ("&& ~ (" /~/~W &~~ &~~^ WKWW WW"= =~~ w~"w ")"^/" ~"" *))`]]?] *)) _`]]k ~ ) / " _^)k! 9~~ _k7 w" 9~9_Qk (( ~ = 9) & ~ 9 ~ " /) ( " *))
7 Johann Heinrich Pestalozzi_&7)[R;@((7)][k"(( ~((X7)9 " / 9) Q/ ((^ ( &
` " X /) " ^ (~W ~/? *)W ~ 9 w " 9" 99~ "~&_*))~ 9k '=)(" ( X *WX9 9)w_ k H " 9)"( ~/ #~/~& X" H/9 7?/" W9)W "( (^ *W() w"( KW9 / 3 # ~9~^ ! ~ = W / = & &W ( " ( *))%&X<<U?`
8< ((^ *)) & ~ & _"k()9 = "~9 ~"" **))&) "/XX9)&( W 9 &)/" (9 X9)=7 W"(9) =?W~=( ~""= *)) (( "(~ ()W9 = *)) ( ~ ( / _ &k ? _^k_) k"W_k
Fröbel, Decroly, Claparède, Freinet, Montessori y las hermanas Agazzi
'`Rw X ~ ~ "7 ( ")~~ &* ~ ~ " ~ ~^9 ~?
31 '(_k 7 }/ ) Q/) & ~ wX }((~/~ ~9" ')/ 7 w ( ( ? Friedrich Fröbel8((W" (9 ~9X"(_`]`k *(/w ~)^ 9" W /!" 9(X &"~& X~") "^ / """""( `]` %&WX9W '~(= ' W ( 9 ("_]8U]U<k7"9W /"9"W ~ w ^ (
8Friedrich Fröbel._}N&'[]7)]U;k(~
({ /W ?9)^ *))
32 " 9 " /)W"/( (?/W(~ ("9)"/ ^( ~)W~97 ( ~^9X( ( " ( ( / ( " ~9 X ( ) )~9&/?) /( ( " ~ W ~ &^)(9 &^) * " ^ / ( ~ / 9 ( ) " &) " Ovide Decroly9_][`8k"~X (/H(9"9!" X = ( / ~ = / / /")9~ HX( (9" 9Ovide Decroly_Qw@X(][`83@X(k(( " ~=(7 %@" (^"~^'(?K "<"< 9 -`<] + G % &`U! L @L`U!@L @O L`[
33 WX!"? w( ( (9" _Q"/!N"k !" ( ~ / ~ ( / ~ ) =/~ ^(!"()~9^ 9 _ w ( k " ( ~ ((/(9~W &(X"~(<"U'W )X" 9 * !" " "W( "/7(( /() (9 ~( X!"(^ 7 9) / " " XW~^) 7( X9w~" (~()(/ ~()? "w
La obra de Eduard Claparède10 _][8`R<k " (
10Eduard Claparède_57)][8`R<k ("((
34 5((^ ( ( (~"X 9( *" (^((^^#$~ " ( _#$`;Uk7(/ *( { ~ w (^ w ~ & / ^/~=W /=/~( 9 ) 9~ "(^~9( /( #$`;U?8]8 9_ {11 _]`;`;;k ((^ 9 "/ "(( ( w 56 " ~ X ~ X X'w~X/w" )/X~"~ &w"X? w= 7(`[`? _`[8`[`k(X~/)/ ~w "" ~ ( (3"W*(^^& ((^ (^ / () *(^ `<; ` / HQ&"H# 9_ {_]`;`;;k/&7( ?)"(
8U ( ~ ) " W W ) 'W)") ~"&~" Xw^(~"" )W ~ & )~^ "w " ((^ " ~ ~ ( "/ ( w~)/ w ~)9w "=() w_k~ /"ww } w( ~ w # " = w " ( " '^ () & W) X~)w 9 X"~ w w / " ( W / 7w /"
8; '&XX " * " ? = Ww(?W "&/!~ (w " " ^/ ^ " ~""/ / ((^ ( ~ ((/)"9) 5("'XW " Maria Montessori12 = X ~ = / ( / " & ~ ) " ^~ X/ ~ ( w / " " ~ " ( % ~ "]`]#({^w " 9]`]"`<<9 ^~ '= ~ 9 ~ " ~ ( ~& (" %"X/H" 7X(_W/ ^k)
12 Maria Montessori_H][<`Uk/( (^R9"W
(^"3Q%XH]`; #^*~W3Q '(^"
8[ &7X(_ k " X % ( ~ 9 ~ w 9~( ~9W % *((^ #= " X =w"=`<[(#9 7 ) Q 7 ) W W _&( " k (97&)"(~9( / )*9_k) &""X")X( "%^#R" U9"'^7 )9"( ~9(~ X" '(X( (%? 9) importantes. 7 9 799"X 7/ "W &(~ 7=(w "=" ? ^9~9 ~ " / w " / W)
8]
9 (^_? w&W((k %W_(H"7X(k
&Rosa y Carolina Agazzi13 / ^ /
9 @ ~ / " / / ~ X ( ( ' 7 X " 9 " X ' / X % " ^( & 9 ~ ~ X ) & ' & " ) 7? #9X %(^() K 9?&"w ^() K(^?("/~ "/ K?X" {( (")"X ? W?~9"~9 "W^) "~&9"("~
8`
/9
9?^="^9 ordenar sus cosas y su espacio.
!X())((? 'W 9 ^ ~ ( 9) ( W(~ 7)~&("? 79W"/&((^( " /(^ ( " W _) k/w( " ) Q&) & ~ ^ / ( ( ~&(~~ w(~(9^" ( 7W/? ? " / objetos. ?w " 8 ?(7( "
R< '()) 9 " ( / &(( ""(&( ~9")"( 9"~9""W~9 X9`8<(" (X&/ ( ("&( () X ~/ )) " "^9 W/~3X *() WQ~" !N"`;[?;R
La Pedagogía Waldorf. Una educación para la libertad
((^+/(= /
y educador Rudolf Steiner14/+/
/9&~ &~/= +/ ^ 9 7 ^=W&W /WwWW"W
14 Rudolf Steiner_'];`UkW"=(7~
9 &w (J~& " =&=5&?? < + _]];k" + _]`[k`<R7( 7X'"'#/? "
41 '=~W (" X" # ( +/ ~ ~ W " ~ % @( (3J+Q0=^? ~w7 /( ~X"( " 9" /~ X" %@(#"QN<<?U; /("(&"(W !/~/^~9W / " / " " /~/)? "( +/ &/ = ("^~9 /9_(9 k" =~" 9 ~ w( / / 9)~/~( _ ^/k / ( X ^ ! 8R ( 9 &X(^"~
42 ^=/3+/ ( ( / "~( '^ ((^ &" & ""9" "W7/ Ww ! = 7 & ^ ""(&) ?/9)"X7 9 ~ 9 9 X / ( " ( & ^ " ^ ( " ((^ ~ ") "^&"<<<WR<^~X+/ ~9) ~(W~ &(+//)& ((^ #"QN<<?U;
1.2.2.- Escuela Moderna. Ferrer i Guàrdia, las Escuelas Summerhill y la Escuela Paideia
43
@"~Francesc Ferrer i GuàrdiaU.
' ( ~ "%~^ 9 " " / X ( " 7 ~ " ~ * ) &"~(^ () ~ W ~ " " ? ~ 9 & " ((~( W/9/ "&& ~ &X w9~ ( ( & W ~ ~W&~ " / &&"~& " &"/) ~ W & /"~ / / ) ^ ~ & 56`[;?]; ((^56(9?)W W~"W wW"(7W 9) &("W"&Ww
15 Francesc Ferrer i Guàrdia_'@]U``<`@k^"
@]]8^/Q(( K{9^/ ^Q)7w*^ ]];{ ; @ " &~@`<`<`& ( "5%7{W({ ~^("H("/
44 w " (W)&Ww /() /"& W % 56 ? / / = " ^ X / (W "~"/X" Ww 9)/~(" XXW(^9 3 /w { 9 " 'w " / ()w~)~"~) /) }() % ) / )/&W/=~ /~/ ? " 9)%56 = ( " ~ " ~ X " / " " "/ (3 % ~ "w X W 9 & ( ^ (
RU 9&W ' / " 56X/((^9 W /~" & 56 3 W / ()"( 9)(//= ~"/WW %"( ( ( ~ % _% 7&k 33 " / / " ~X(/(" & 3 W~&/~ )~W ~/W"//)( ~w?& ~7W ?(/ ~ ~(= 9W W ~ " )W9) 56`[;?[< 9 " (>>(/((^ ("(& ( ( ! Paideia `[] %X ~ "/"(" X9){X
R; (((9 primaria. # X " Summerhill/`~XAlexander Sutherland Neill16 _H(k 7 / ~ /~9&(/ &&~9((^ " ~ ~ & K " 9 ~( ("~& ~W~ ) Q " W ^ ( " W ( &)9"~(& " 7& / ( /( ( ("wW" "w_W" &(k"(
{X"( Escuela Barbiana de L. Milani17
_H`8`;[k~/ 9W/ W~& ~"("wW/( &) ( "(
16 Alexander Sutherland Neill _H(]]8`[8k(X{
((^/7& /!/
17 Lorenzo Milani _ `8`;[k " (( @
_X`R`k"/~9( ? 7 & ; 7&9 ; &U ! 8 )
R[ / " "( *^9&# (~7H( " ("7~ &" w( (( " ~(/ " W/( {&&() () /`]`~(" ""8<^"W8<< ^/ X((^ */Z[ >>&}~? %~{~~:~H~ Maslow, Rogers ' wW~ /( #~~( " /& 9 ;< ( _ %JJ"K"(J"k&X~}" )(/ "
Para Jerome Bruner18) "
(_"~k"/ )(= "() w" WW/ "~(w)"
18 Jerome Bruner,_NJ`U`]]k ((7*(^3
`;</##(3H(^(} ?K < +_`[k+& " _`]Rk G_`];k
R] /)^("/ @=) / ~X ()^ )" }X^?^() / )" / ~ =~ ~" (XW/9) )(_+@"Q`[;k?9 " ( ( " " ~ &""(^ @_`]]k&(W " 9 "@&/*(/ w w (~ ~ ((~ ( * ^~/( _ (k Ivan Illich19 W ~ / /"(/ 7 W 7 !) _`[k "^ "^H& /)" 19 Ivan Illich_K`;<<k^^W" ^(7//^ /"")(^ ( ~"
R` "/ Makárenko20 ( `< ( #()~ ~ / ? = ( ^ w( " " %JWJ" ~( " 7( %JWJ / " ^ (( W ~ & ( " )" ) / %JWJ~"() ~ & ~=&" ("&("Ww( W~=w(W ( ""~9&)/ W/) P. Freire21 )~( X /^ "~^"/ )w " " ~
20 Antón Semiónovich Makárenko _3 ]]]`8`k (( `<U ) /#/^~ == ="^"&{/ /&X/(#5J
; "+"J
21 Paulo Freire_@`k/ )"&5! ``w~/
"~"="(^ (`R;!! "#7 7*{~ Xw~ (^ ?
U< (" ~ " % W( ) ( ( ( ! " ~~X W((W ~XW ~" w"~" ~_*``<k W/ w W & W ^ = 9W ~ ^ )& "}& "w & ~ ~/ ~"W &)W W(( ( ~ ~ ( " X _``<?88k Piaget22 / w & ~ ( (" ((^_(^ (Xk~ (W(W~ ^~*(=~ () ~("(X" X "X 22 Jean Piaget_7)]`;5`]<k (w= / (7"@(^ 3&{3&*(^7 W*/*H(#H_#H (k'/@##H(^5X5"( &7(^/" ^(
U " X~~ w*(X(X ( ( ~ W & " = & W"= " (/)(~ *(( 9"~"/(" " Vygotsky23 = ~ " ( "" (K"(J"!* w~ ^ w9" ~"~9^(" 9W ~ K"(" / ( / ^~ ) " / " ("( ( W ( " / " W ~ & & " ) = ( "() ( "=(( "^ K"(J"_``]k=(w" / "(X((/
23 Lev Semiónovich Vygosky _@ Q ]`;`8Rk ( / 7 " &9("{X(^" (H *( (X'#( "/ H*( ((^9 /{ 97w (^"((^?;"<; "+"&!L "+ W 9+" +"&! "< ;"< y su obra más importante es ; " _`8Rk
U ?"W* ( _ k " X ( _ 9k " ( ("/ / ( _ W^ ( w k ( & ) &" ~ / ~ 9 ~ " W K"(J (? " /) " / " ( #~) w w )"/ W(w ^~) ~w_( 9 )k / (_(9/ k((X~ / ^ " ~ ) / aspecto abstracto. K"(J" X ^ ( % 9 (= ^ ^ / ( _K"(J" ``]k / ~ W 9 ~ W " ~ / ^= & * ( /( (( 'W (9~^("X~& (
U8 Maslow24 ^ ( ~^ ^ &~W~? W (" 8= "/ R U') ) ( X= ) /~X=/& /)W~^~ W &/& / W /) ( ~^~/)(& ~^'~(W (^ ) ~X~ %N X / W ~ ) &"/)? ) ( " ( / " ) " ~) /) ="~(=# ) ( (^ " " w '(( )" 24 Abraham Maslow _Q`<]#/`[<k ("#"#(J_##k 7(^*"N/w^ (7(^3+! {&J3#'/'& " (5"/ 5_~) k{ /(^&^
UR Rogers25 ( " / " & # ~ ( & ~ Q( ~ ~)W w & ~ " ^ " ( ^ XW(~ )'~)~ W~W~) ~ W / )W/~ w("( }^?'w _ w"k w=)(^w"7 "W"W3 /W()) &XX & Q("(J /&~^^ ("(((>>^W" ^?# (7&KK# '"NJ{XWw( ( 7 ( ^ ? =W=( H/*H7'" /Q((~& /^"~&w&
25 Carl Rogers_#&(`<#/`][k"(
"W^( &(! 9(^ 7(^^`8)^/ > 0 ; 0
_7Q&* #9k^^" X}QJ~(^ ? "; &? .
UU WW(/7 ( (=( "~(" X^ ( W W ~ = / w & w& 8 & [ $' / *H7' _*( H 'k ) }() # " ! _}#!k ~ = W w " = X_ X W"k(_ W W~9^}#!k '~&_K "<<<kw/w =~~W/_ &&Wk" _ ( k ~ ^ ~=X &w^ (Ww~9=&& W&~^_W~&k"~ w 7)&_J<<Uk~ =X((~?
U; 7"~ _"/"k'^ &"``[¡U];8]=9)W #& /= 7&)(( 7 ) = ) W _&"*"W *"7k " _ <¡ (k"/ ( (/_~ X )(( (k /w _ W " =^k" W" 'w""" X #=X~w ( ( ~ ~ ~WX)~ ~ " ( = ~/ *&~/"~ (? &w"^)^X= (`RU~~ w 7 ^ ~ J Q(( (&^"9
U[ ^ ^ " ^ ~ X ~&(&^ ' ^~("( ~&^ %())``;?< !wLoris Malaguzzi26"(( ? $' "~) 9"9"(~ X Q(((~H /w"~&" " )X%^%" &'()) %()) / ( ( / Q(( `;U()w /~( /) ^ " { X =(&&~ ( (" / / (( (W ?Q*))@$"!N" "#&(*# !"5+#X%JWJJ*(+& K"(J"@@/%NQ("NJW 26 Loris Malaguzzi _H `<``Rk *(( / / Q(( ()`R;%())((^ ! ""< X '(%())=*#H7 "/ "3w%())/ 9Q~(`U]`;;'9 `;<w~%())()#%X **( ("Q((""#(%()) Ww(( (^( ( # K) W ( / "(&"() "^7/*(@ *# !N"K"(J*^ "5*%"% ``=) (5}()~X ( &/)" / *("/
U] 9]<?#5 (7& ""((^ ^_@%*((KKk" _'k'*@& )@NJ"+(%('&"5&' "^/Q(( ^")&)w^&? /"^ ( = ~^ W %())``;?8 / ""< + ~~w(9&& " = " & / * " / ~ 9 " ( " &^ 9 ((^ W((^ W&")/ 7_"9 /k 3=((^ /)9 X~(9" &&("~" / () ~9 ( ~ = " ( / " " ( ()")~9&w
U` ~(/~9(" " & " ( ( ) " w ~9"/7& " ~ ( " ( ~ ("/ / ~ " W " &" "&" X/("&" (&W "&""~~ ("&" (¢// %())``;?8 / "" _ k ~ ( & " & 9 " w w w"7( w "/ ((W=W( " ) (^ _%()) ``;k " & " 9 " / (= " ( " 9 * " # ~ ( ( " W X 7~ (& ( " / ~ " /X 9 !& " " 'W_(~*(K"(J""k((=
;< ) "( (^/W 9)" (~(((" ~(97"w ("Xw ~("X( ~ " & w "~~9/)& ) que pretende. & ( " "W~^7^ & 9) ) ^ & " 9 ^ =& " (^ ( editores.» %())``;?;; * ~ & =) " ( "9"9& }^/Q((X~ ")7( (" 9~"W~wX XWX~X 9'^ X)~"= "/ }^ "X" ~(= 9"~)/" )
;
+= ' '&
3)"
@ 3)~ (
&^ ) ^ ``< Gerhard Preiss27 ((^
("?W ) & ~ w ^ " ) ( ( & W^ ( &W" "/ & *``;?8 = ~ " W (?9 7(+&_<<k&)(WW ~&"&=w(? '~~X ~~79Xw / neurotransmisor dopamina. # / ) ) W w ) ^ " ( W W(_~)W^)/) k7~& ~)( "W 27 Gerhard PreissWWWW3( '
; 89/) #W& '( ~ "}~ R ) X ( " 9 " WW (()X"Xw'WW (~9W( " U3=)* 9 W //~(_ (k '~ & (( ^ / ) w = " ~ W / ( ( ( " ~ ( '^ }#! ~ (^ & ((^ " = (( " ( " ( ~ / W / * W(&=&)( " w (( " ( ~ & ) ^"%" 9 ;< ( >> ^ ^ = w ( ' ^^w/" ( " &w(w
;8
Síntesis capítulo primero
%& ~ " =^((>>* "( ^" W ~ / / = " 9 X / X~ & / " " ( ( W ( _ ^k *^(((" % ((")&" w( ( !w~"/ "~^()(? &) " / ( / X/ 9 ~ ~ "(" &9w(" ^ )wXw ")~( X " ( 9 " ~/"
;R (= w "w" / W " comunitarios. =)() ~" ~( w ( (=
65
CAPÍTULO SEGUNDO. REFERENTES TEÓRICOS PARA UN PROYECTO EDUCATIVO
(II) MODELOS DE EDUCACIÓN ARTÍSTICA
Sinopsis capítulo segundo
^W '"& = ( ( / " / = "^~&w& '&(=( ~/^(& " ) ?/Y[&\]\]\ ("#' !H"^~~="~-)~) '^~X) XH"~w "W _-k""'~ /1. {X) ('?= /"-((~("w W&( "W' !X)w ~(='"/ "X()'w~ / 37#} ( 1~=X7 ~~ ( "
66 '~= &"( / () (/) " "* - &"~&-~ (&) "
& & W & ~ / ~~/) (>> "')/ &" ~&(>>~'(" W( " / ^~9))" (W "# 9~9ww-WX(~ (W= / " W 9~&7~"& ~(~X&~X"" 9 2``8?] 3W^~ W '~W&"(
2 Roser Juanola i Argemí// D ;D# X ^
67 '^&&X~'&-"~& )~&w"(~! (& )-XXW w )(/~W" ~)) * (('^ ~W"Ww * w " & ' " ( " w ( ^( " _k/X ( ( ( & " ' H W/w) & "^ 9) / X & ~ " !(&"^(( X" ( "/ /~ ^") "&~W= " _'<<`k (_'<<`k ~"/-(& " ~/9 &((" ("~)"!" -)~ / ~
;] ()^"X) / ~ = X ^ -( ~" ^/ "~ )W"?~9 ^ #&J"8<<`?RU` %& (@W~ ~W&- '"&"/- ~"-'9)#~ " w^" /(^ ^ ' ~~-""(~^ !& &( -" )W ( #HN_<<k^X-W" w ~ &(9) &/W w/"/X / "W X7#37#}& *( '"#}()
3 Avram Noam Chomsky _= 33 `]k =( W (¢^ ( >> (¢= /" /^"/ X(¢^H{ (%&_%H{k!^(¢^
"(7=^~£?! '
= & 7 X_<<;k0) #
;` 7 w#H {/ _``;k# H 7( >>H(~!37#}/-"/ W"^ " HNR<<?U / HN) 37#}_<<k G( ~" ? L?"( '(X ?/X9- W^^-("" " ) / XWX- /))((-WX" (" 9 ~/ ~(&^""W "~ (" ?'WW" &W HN_<<k =~9W-~W" ""&W= 4 Kaori Iwai_ k! 'H#7#37#}*^ *( 3*^>HHH_k*^ >0F _33k" &X _k
[< " ?(-W~'"( )~-')& ) ( ( ~ ~ ( ~=W ("X(@' " ?(HN_<<k(~- ("W-{X~ "W=( K"~'- 9"W-X"' /)(w~/& "&W~=-)w(""" W / 7 W)WX~9)& =) (=- "(""/ w HN<<?8] 7( _<<Uk w = '? ( = w)^w_"-k/")' "( "/( ~"/X~^9) ~^( ^'^(="-"w ") /)" & ~ ' w <<U?8
71 = w(' 7=~&"~/ ~~w WX/')&^ w w~^ (7=~'& ") -/( ({9)^ & /)=/ w #~=)- " & W&"/!-~) && #)~(9¤¥ (~&(/ N/<<U?R 3= w=~"~ (X"~ )9)&* = /(' ( (_<<Uk ( ( _<<Uk w = ''" ~ ' ~ w " ~ /!&~' "w&"~ W
72 ^"^^=' / ~W/ Langer5_<<Uk(/WW '=~wWX (? X=" ("W ( & W W " " " *X^ / ('(9~'^ ~ / /'"^ "*'( 3/w~X" ( "~w& (<<U?;; wW" &~(? X/ X /^ " 9 &W("( /W9"W-("" <<U?< }~= '!N"_<<Uk
5 Susanne K. Langer_33]`U`]Uk= /(##
` %f3) "~
( = =^") ~)& ( 7(9_" k(_ (="(=k"^_&k
[8 *X'/w~=~"~( X~W~~ (=w"~ / '"~&)-"(=" " ^ 9 ( " ! / & ~ ^=* X'~?"( !N"<<U?U '(~("!N"{ &(#& &"W~XX- )'!&^~{'(&-~ 7 w X 9'W~)W(/ (_<<Uk7~/ W'" ~(/W W(/^'~ /'~)~)WW ~X&9) (!N"" 'W ' "~ w ~"/ "-W( "W=' ^'WX'&W ~ "(
[R
X_~ 9))kw -w(^) /"^'
2.2.- RECORRIDO HISTÓRICO DE LA EDUCACIÓN ARTÍSTICA: MODELOS Y TEORÍAS
'/ (& "~ (^7(w-_<<k3& &(/X& _& k ~ = ( / ~ 9 & "~ ~9)%& ~"^ <<?U
2.2.1.- De la época clásica a la Edad Moderna
'}w_<<k(5 #W"(= /* "' -X(~ ^~/-*'X X~)9)~~ (^=/ &
75 '&RU<#( "- X"!&~ ( " ( /) " ( ~^%W( =~ )(^ X '^~ & (¢^(~ /)" Xw7 "* ~/ ^=~* !/ (~ /X (/ (. ~ * ~ X ( w W &~^ X~&(X (~&@"& " * ( = ~ X ) / 5*(!/ ( X9~&^""~ &"~~ ==''W* ~ 9"~X =// /"9/ ~( X&~) ** (=(~w "~*W ~ ~
76 " ' ' /* "( '" *= /w(/~ )~ X~~-X~ &( *' *) ' * ~W( (#'(=W )"(^&WW ?X~"/ X/'? ' ~~-(W"~(( &( X^?( "^ <<?8; ' ~"^-7;L=("w X ~~/"= " w;< w-~"(W( / '/' ( 9)?(W"
77 X=(# &U<#" /((7(= &&")W-W" &/XH ' "/~* )W/ 7 ("(&"" educación. {/"~("W-QHQ} 9R<#~= R[;#/&~)&&9='(¢ ")%{^Q" ~)7 " () /&"= &H(# (({9) periodo de decadencia. W ~ ' %'^ "-"W"( WH(X&W "'((=~ W (>H/)~&^/ W)w/"-)"W/W"(? (&(~(
[] "~ " '(- ~W/"~(&-~/~( # ~)W/X=~ 9))X ")( w W( ( ~'( X Q (= @'"^ (" &~ W'(¢&/-~ " W= ~W ( )~^"*) X & ~~'-(¢W "Xw&/-& "^& ( w & 'W /?~ X" " <<?U {9)&? 3 & ( ""
[` =(& 3& W@ 8() " ~" W)=) <<?U8 Q& X'/ -=X !K&~- W))X / &~ / (( &~X ()-~W ~&"((W~ H(%(¦()~ {Xw=(%(¦( Ww "( ("(' w&="X( &&~&" ^" W'~~/ ' ^ / " " ( ( ="~
]< ~&X "^'"W( ///Giorgio Vasari6 _HUU[RkU;/ " #H%(¦() ""( H(("(-=Q^) "-(>KHHX9)&( ^*(=~ ="( "'*" /;R]'(^~ '#/(/H(# ~' ^")&^ #{(>KH(/)= "H( /&" "#('('W-"// /~ 7 ( (^ ^ "W/( (~ "W^( ) 3~Ww ' W~?/ WX9)& =(>KHH&=(>H>
6 Giorgio Vasari_'))UU[Rk~"H(
XX""(I # "URUU<%(¦(~X"
] ! >H???~ & ? ? $'' N ( >KHHH ~> ? "{W'~&^(>HHH"~=' &^X&^(>KHHH(( "!"= (") & & '/(X-/~() (>KHHH~" ") ')"#"H( (>KHHH)" "9{X(-('/*=(>KHHH ~ / Q H(&^/W(-_~w "/k" (Q ( 7^"&= W~~-='^((W Q []`=~^
] H ?~ /)"X="X-( /)"X="X-(7 ()/ =" W @'^ & = ( >KHHH ( >H> /" ^=) ~7-"( 7(X(( ( ( * /9))( '(Q ~=(>KHHHQ"^('"Q3 -H "#=? W~'~ ? "/W ^(3 ^/) W / 3 3(/ / W /"// y cerrada. ^/Q ~
]8 ( - X"(!~Q-")"& "^W? "WX X( "/"W/-"H (>KHHH&XW /^"W~~ ~&(H( " "7(_H k=-"( "_k{X" &/W ~"W ) )( ~ ( ' /& ~w
2.2.3.- Siglo XIX. Los precursores de la escuela progresista
()(-'((>KHHH&()( "(>H>~) ) ')(= '^'&
')(>H>^-]R 9X~) )(W" / W" (( ( ^/ "?5-"X];<%Q "7"~K5(&"{ #/%"Q5%'( " W w / 3~ "X' X (~ " ~^ ~(/~ 7&"5& 5@9/9'/ 9)@'('-("9/ 9 33]<[/ !%&^ ( & (>H>];]W@'w7 }w/#(" @@''
]U ][R/@ /'?? ) X(>H>"& &W(~X( ^ !(("("9&X-/ & X ' =( *)) _^ k~ 9H QX9) 9#(~5~-)*))~/)&& ~(( /"((^-^=(>KHHH~) ")/ *))W~9 /"~ ( ( H(Walter Smith7X/)( ? / (-= "( "( ! ^ &^
7 Walter Smith _H( ]U` wk / > p " > ! _H(k (][33@!9( '%&/"' @'%&!7&"/-9)~(33/ //
]; ((&W"9 ( & W~(" )" ~ /W& <<?U8 '/)"(7& (& ^&^&~^" &9) )~) '?( '((>H>W"^" W W )X&=-W()W"' 9)/ ()) 7)&/ X ?//( "/ 3 ^ W " / (~"((-?(X)(( ("" / (>KHHH^W"/ Q-"~(" w "w( W"w %)5Q= w "{X
^"~"(-][ " ) QX ~ &&) (/"X )"'^)// (= ~~WW ^ (H(!&-"?&&~ &&~X)( 9)*& "( // &9 /(X]R<Ww^ '];</(&X W(~
2.2.4.- Principios del siglo XX
=(>H>">>X]`<"*5 %'w((~ ( ~9)(9) "=// W'" 9"^/=&)~& ^ ( 9) / ( W " (
]] 9`<w9)? q&~W^>qW ~~9 W("~ ((? " ) ^""-( ""9 '^(>>*-K( '^ ? /"w~7- &"-' "w `;&~)W- '&?^(-/ ^"^7="/ "/7))~XX7 ")(^7/w(W" ^~/'"~-?W/ (~"-" #'_% <<UkW~' ~~X ~(_^ k~(~^ W " #John Dewey] por sus ideas
8 John Dewey_33]U``Uk= /
("((((~-) (X" (" ^("((((~-)" &")Q) ]]R3#&( ^)X '= " ^"W
]` ("'"+" *J )~)H -^(&!N" #&J"<<U?R; # w ( ( ='7(!N" w~X= ~w #) ~ w " "( ^! !N"/~W"^ ( ("*(^ !N" W " ^" w!N" ~(^""&)-( ~(^""&)-( ~ // # !N" 3 #&( /" /"/ -X9)X) " 7(? w W ^ " ~ " ~ W
-`< &~)( ~) ) " ~ 9) /)"X=" =( !N"<<?U ]`;X-"/? &#%"&N"'#N" "/97 (""/ " w!N"w-(? # '~(" w9 ~(w/ /)" & " ~wX / ~X /-)""( 8# " (w "9~w !N" ~ ( " W () W ~ ( /9(~W( %"&N"N('~/ ? 9&"()-/@(^w )W" "(=" %"&N"N<<?U8
` *!N"'? 3~w(/ " ~X/"W(=7(=~ ~W&"X( "?' !N"_<<?U8k *!N"'"~ ~w'((=' &? '&")&&/'&X &(" !N"<<]`8R§ ?8<;
}(33Francis Wayland
Par-ker`~~ &? ") ~9*J& *7)"'^X*))Q" &&'( !"}&][8 W=-"%& *J^W ")@ / "9("((9 {"X"(-=)*J
9 Francis Wayland Parker_H(33]8[`<k/"X
3 ][U#&(~ ("/ /7 ; ""<_]`Rk((^ ~(*J ~& "'=~X
` "/~~~() ~" *9 ~~ ~(=~^ w/"9w~ ~& "w X * & " *J( "w~ w W w ()" ^*J~9 ~9))( (=)/!&&*J9 /w w?" /w '^ = *J / (= 2.2.5.- Período de entreguerras (1918-1939) ^(X^ "^-W) ) ~&&( X"w-
~^-`8 ( (X='" w('(>> /)*w'w *W~/~ X ~~) '-""(~~ (X*(w X/( 7 3 W K" J" (W / ')#w 'w ? ^"W-^?&w~ _7(&X&w-~X_ (XW( wk &w~ (_"~& "X= " X"~ ~~" /W(/ J"``?[; 5 ~ ) W * _k"_k 7 }7 _ J"!¢&(<<Uk
`R ``/@&_# k +'7" /9)(/ X(^/7 ^ ^W-"==9)'" 99"~ !X*5%/ =-X" "=! &"&"-"^~&^Q%& "WX-7~&^ / "^ w ~ #^? }?) !&& #?X!"X &X""w W~/?W(' ) -=( ^ ? (!^& ~~)(-() '<<`?` ' ^ w ~ ' ()<~ 10H('H("W?*8(#" /)*/)(^9_-( &// k/)*/)(^9_-( (W"(&"(_
`U '_<<`kWWWW-_W k~ ( ~w9 `` (!X&" ~'? = (X( &"((~/-( =X 9)^X( )" ( ( w~(Xw W& ' X w W ^()/ X /' ~" )"XW9)W w =~&"~ w")/-X"'w w /W (X X &k=W ! W~^("W
`; (^/?/ "~&&')"(~ 9-Xw~(" ((^w ~33 w #Franz Cizek11((^ ~9"~(~^-#)J /X~9"~(~^-#)J Q"~~~#)J (^#~X ~"^/(X~&W /)'(&XX^(" X=~&"w X`<"`R</ X w Marion Richardson12%((# #"Victor D’Amico8 "=9)-(#)J{=~9 w"~w )X/ 9)~/ "){X=
11 Franz Cizek_K];U`R;k('@@''K%
(~9"> ' ` 7~ "/ " 5 ( #J ( " W/"9W" 'w / 12 Marion Richardson_H(]``R;kW" %'"}=@(&`U`;( 9) "~ {X9W`8</" / 13 Victor D’Amico _33J`[<<`k@@''/-`;`R]"X93#_`8RRk3J_`;U[k "> " _`;`k'" %' %W8<9`8[/ 5^ %'% ~/"(w'X-"!')''X
`[ ~9 ~/ "&"(w %wW(( /?
Margaret NaumburgR/+`UJ
#15 " W (^(^" W9)~X-"=~)X ~/)/&)&" "~( '^ / 9X w ""=~w (~KJN/^= 9R<("# "WX
14 Margaret Naumburg_33]`<kQ)(&!N"#
Q) (^(^" #X X & 9 `R (H/^~9/-Xw W")/~ 9)^) ~"/ (""7J7{X=-(^"79~ ( "(=)& /~&W"W
15 Florence Cane_33]]`Uk~&9
9/ ""&(( ! X~ ~/ `U=5(5?^=-)"" #(#~9) (& "9X("~
`] }/~(#)Jw K !'_33`[k~ ~'9& ' 9) X ) "('W!'9 ~( ~W~ producto creado. #/_#)J(#"!'k^Q& X"9^= *&~/-9~9" / La corriente reconstruccionista }~"'X *( - =/(&-/)~"~&W ~)/) !N"w~~& -"#&w 'w""~wX-(W~ /w X/" '(= ( ()/X/" (& -&^( (" Ww "~"(
~(^9)-`` W' ^wX ((~' ~")-=' )~)^ X~w& w 5 ! * & ~~ (9 '^'(( (7 /~/ (( (W" &w="/ ()9)") /~'( "~X~Ww"(= ~XW~(" w'^'w " 9 / Leon de Winslow? " >;"_`8`k ~( "' +N/w = " ~ / ((W^(('W ~'9~ ^+N~/ ("X-"("X W(w (
-<< w " ^X+N*((?(' ~ ("^ /&/W^( //W" "w^X~~( 9)(~ ('&("'&-!(w & + +&¨ / ' 3 #&( `` ~ ^ ' ( (^? w (W= 9 w w " w ')`8@& ~((337(=7(5 %(@&&"^/
2.2.6.- La Segunda Guerra Mundial (1939-1945). La postguerra.
La corriente expresionista 7( 5 % _`8``RUk " X?RU933"3Q77W- 'X?RU933"3Q77W-JW( )"*^#^&" ^_&"/( k"-)X
< '7(K(? /w^/W-( """^ ?() " '(33" "'" # w @ ! " ) 5X " _<<k _& k Xw X/ ( W-W(W#"&~= &&w"= _(^k/X( ~&"&^( ~^)W"()Ww "_w (k 7"" XQ'^ -"/WX"w "w 16(339R<_`R`R[k7 ^(~w(w WX Xw ^? ` wq & Q#/-^9`U^Q()X 16~~ ?J*J _33``U;k+ (_`<R``[k@N_`<U`[<k'&5J"_' `<R`R]k) _`<`;k%J{"_]`<`[;k%JQ&J_`<8`[<kQ%&N_`U ``k/_]]<`;;kJ&_`]k%&
< (_ k=/~"^-? #~w^ /~Q-~#XX " w (^"/)-""W~w *J(<<8?8 %" w ' ^ " W "(~^33" & W ( ^ J ) ( w}^"~W w ? "~/ ((=( 7) &? &&{X( 87w "" -W~W) ~"() H( () R 7 /) W ~ ) ) ( w (/)" &"^" "w / ? / ^ _k"/~w^-"^~/~
<8 w&"~ w"&) "X(^"^ (=" ' 9 U< ( & "X9)("^ &9)W*=~9)(-*W( " (/~"~ ~9~"w En 7 17_`[kViktor Lowenfeld] -/'3*~ & ~~( ""w# ~ (( / ~&X/-" (7(_<<UkN/" 9"'&^~)& &~" '^N/=='"- w "w ~&&^^ (#)J%Q&%((##" 17 7 KJN/`R[!X`;< /"+@ 18 Viktor Lowenfeld_)'`<8`;<k'"*(^#)#)J{ H(N/( ="w-#''`8]& H("W33K!©' %}%'(X ^'!9(N/*(^ HK(`RU'3*"
<R K!'`RU"`;<33 N//^^ '^~w " 97'w != N/=~ww /)" 9( "("^ '( N/"`[?[ w //=) ~^ 9(~-"*N/'^X wX = W~9 )/W""~~w ~X= &("9 *N/ / 9?(_R9k)-w ~W_R[9k ~W_[`9k /"_ `9k) #N/ 7 W"'(>>
<U 9 W " / ~ ) W^"~~ " / 9) ' w = " ~ N/"`[? #N/`R[' '_`''k() / ( / ! ' ' 33 ' ( /()"/ ' }~N/w 9 es Herbert Read`{"% (Q_`]k -+ =/ * ~/ " = ~ ( ~^ w ? ~ & ( ~ ( ~ W " ( ( ~ ( W ( w " & = =( /~ & ) ^ ((W( Q`]?8 '((!N"%@J 9)N/( 9-~"(N/ ^@J
19 Herbert Edward Read_H(]`8`;]k= /^~"^"
? _`8Rk+ _`R8kXf _`Uk _`;]k
<; ^ Xªw (~ w "&X w %"'& w " Ww ~( w "&~) ~9~W/ N/"`[?8 Barkan<_<<k~='w ~97 X0`UU/w )~ ^(9)~) (^"@J( 9XW7(X-"~9) !@'_ k~ &"W~
}~N/ June King McFee21_<<k
" ^N/ w (~=w-&' X ( ^ N/ % 20 Manuel Barkan_33`8`[<k9 ~9) &"^` " ? " &F `8< )WW-"^ )) /('"/ W'L _`;<k /"97 =( 9X &"( ()~Xw(^ *~ /
21 June King Mc Fee/"!
'3}-(Q(W=/9/ " %9)9#^ (^(^(^"9 7(^)" ~&(
<[ 7 ~& X %Ww~ w"~ 9)/ }wElliot Eisner22^( ~'^9 9w"/X= "^^=7 +,_<<U§`[k/)) X" 9)'(~@J " ww 9~^9 )~'&= W (~' "(^&/ X" ! _ & !@'k 7 9) W " W -? ^ ' " X _'k"/ = " ^()X-22 Elliot Eisner/X'" 37/7( '/"( 3#&(`;<**" (37/~ =W9)")?= (~ ' "(^&/X" * -""7(/"/9) ()/? / `U > "$ >0?".
<] ^=( "(~&X / 9? ( -'~=( =9) "^"' XW_)7Jk~ ("(^33~`U[ ^/~ (/^ "W3)W(X(-w " &^ ^ (" "-(^5^ /(3 "&^(N/'^=' ~=WW" ( *5/8_]`[`][k~^((X _W/ ^k5/_`];k=~ (( //-!@' (@_^-23^(5/^((&7 &( _K^k(^-( _K^k(^-(X_K^k(^-( /"/ / "(
<`
k ^"~^ /97'(=~ &"~9"~9
`]: ]R funda un centro donde se ofrecen una serie de
W'("9'-/~W(+!N5~ 9w '_!@'!@'k7 !@'w"(~ &~&)9-/~(W ^"'"X *_<<UkX &&X XX(=*= '~X ^& " * W~"(X ") !`]RX!@'W/ ''`]R"`]]X&" ) W / # 5" & ( ( !@'"&=/3/5" W~('(`][ " +@w) ~9)("~/ w~"( ~&^ 8 : ] _% % ]` `[;k " / 9^ zAw; z? W"; z7 /<<;" (¢^'(#/
< W~( ( "~' ") H(~&X&"~!@'^-~X"w9) ~( W?
2.2.7.- Años 60: La educación a través de las artes
!X~" " X? # 3Q77 ~ (^33"~8§( 33(KW( 3Q77"33~(&`;``;8 & "~"5 @9#&9`;`(( #&% )/ ^ (( ""-(33"~w~ W" XW-?~"X ""/&& ^ "" {X "((" (~
111 ?@HH&*%JJJ *(K"(J"%N"Q(_^k 7(/'" (? X W(7 w~ "~^~ / ( *( ' " }= 33 " &"@(~ / 9 (X^~( 9)(`;]/ para profesores con este propósito.
') X9-(^? 7)9( 7&"-( w/ ~-9)3~ ( 7=(9 9)^-"X ()(( X9
(-112 /"~ W=W~^( &^ !! *"_&*k(( 5 ( &X ~&)9"(-)`;[ "&) "^&^"= (( W(^" = "W^ "& (&^"= '^(( " -(&")" 7/ ~/^ /"w " / = / 525 " ( X & ``[5~)(-3~=(" 5" ~&W"/-w"^w ~ ~& ( 25 Nelson Goodman_33`<;``]k= /73`]"- =`R{(^@"("7-= =`R{(^@"("7-=&W" ((^"X'(? ! " =9+ < <_`[;k7 _``<k _``UkK &%++_<<Rk; ; _`[kQ0q" _`]Rk'W"9
8 7 / ~ 5%())``;?R #5 9) ' w " ) /( X~X"
David Perkins26Steve Seide27 y Howard Gardner]&*"
`[9<<<!77! (wWw W-" ) 77 *? "( -
~~&-26 David PerkinsW"(=H{(^%&
`[</ 5 !*J? 7@ Qq_`]k Q"J"N7&! G' _`]Uk/ }?; G = 0# _`]`k! "< _``<k " = _``Rk G _``Uk( !*J& "~ ( W"# #{(^ ( (^ *~ " /(9) 27 Steve Seidel*""!' 3 <<R#((" 37/ " /"W 9^@J"@" & (5#(%& (" (w '" (('*Q}* " " **(&{(7_{7k "*"'W/(&"-()
28 Howard Gardner, ("!&9
( ?( ")^9"( ~/9!`]<&/33`];) /(5 3" **(W? La =788 '&+pY|# G_<<<k $ " 0_<<<k " _<<Rk" }++ 0 ~_<<Rk'(" 5NJ"("5*"~)XW/ (
R ~WwW( ")"w) "/W NNN)&w/ #"&("*N5 "!*J~ "X *J&((( W 9)") " )"(X&-(^9)")"&9 "()/ () " (*J ~&&X ))" 'W-/)(= _"~W k"/ (-"W7 (" ( "9)")" #9*"&( ~& X/(? "()"5 / "&()" "-")(" ""?
115 w " " (^ (W('W9 ("W"( W=)( '&W( ""7wW ~ '(w"W )" (*(X-9'#W9'X9'" # )" " ^ * ( " w /" ^"(( "
2.2.8.- Finales del siglo XX y principios del siglo XXI
=(>>^3 7X"=5^/ () "&( 33 "X((^-#&@H"^33 H/" ( =(/ " "==-(W"(~ @^~ ^"("^
116 "#$%&'('#$( (5_``Rk"W*&w-9? * ?~ #) ?"^~(" &"=& * ?&( ')" (*/I?q"> " _ &K{7k(~/%}%' _7 07 0` wqk'( (("*&N (````U"N%}%' () WK3_IF " k-"/%}%' (*K_K{7k)' 9" ^ / (~/" (()w K{7W)! %-"X_'<<`k $)) '9(&"= / ( "/~ ^"W("?
117 " X= (7XW^w7) ~ (" w/~&^(-/^& ~& '("9) "-dagogía crítica. ' "/ w& (&((^ w" "W*'W^ _' <<`k 3 '~)" ^(('_<<`k&^~ ~'W( w ((^^(^-=") ~W/~W/ (" (& ( '<<`?U !((^^_'<<`?Uk ((^ ((^ ((^ ((^ "
] w" (=XW(~/ _'<<`kW("w ^ ' & ^' ~ ) W ~ ^ " -/ " ) W <<;?R /W(/ ? ^ " ^ !XW(~ )_<<;k *+"-/*0121210 w"' W"#wQ"/ Room 13/~/~/ ~X~( 9 '~"( 9 ^ " ~ W 9 '~&w 9 ~-""~`. 299<<`"( Q8+Q 3 Q""((7^~ &97^(~() "/
`
+"-/34
La Room 13(/Rob Fairley8<
) 7 ( ( " (9-& 9 "~ ("X" %WW~ &w <<[?` Room 13/*#+ ``R?(9/')-#/~~^w^ ~(&~ wRoom 13 /=-~&&" " 'w/Y[ ""-7{'H ")-" X " )"("& 30 Rob Fairley'(#(/'/"Q8" ``RQ8#{8<9w"
< Una Room 13 Room 13/ /^ Las Room 13W(~~W/( (W `9( w ~ Q8^W9/w (^{(9 #^'"( <<[?< ~!~? ~ ( ("=)" ~ &( X ' "%#]"`9&%HX' %_H%%'k!&( /(' ~&(-W/("&&?¬ <<[?< Las Room 13 &W=)/" {X( "
121 ) & ~ (Room 13 "(^ "/ 7("" 9~Room 13"~W ~)~ (" ! / = = " ( ( Room 13 ? * ' {W'~!7%~!@J Q ()&%wQJ!N"#Q*5-)J+&+(7N"+J /~ ?(#(/'5#'@w!@Q!! *@~%"*)& ~ W((-"&"('W&" Room 13 ~( 9)= ="X-/"*~X ~X" W '~Room 13"
122 "^& (=/W~~&w ~X" /'~~-"^W"W'W~ "Room 13"(w /Ww )" '^ Room 13 ( W " / -~~~(]" 9 *"; 7"& (W^&
"&Room 13@&
(~~&9=W]8<-9;8< ~^(~w~(^ "& ~( ~7/ "(-{X(/("( =)"~ / %J9W/3#"/ ]U/ " %^%W-W?¬9 9 <<[?<
8 Una Room 13 "~-("~& Room 13 -/"(~ ^=&^~" ~""Room 13 ("-)"wX/ "W w"/" #&X`9'/Q8#-(WH/'" )~/(" w^~ #&X/ <<[?< En una Room 13 w /"X*-WW?~/ =Room 13. (/"_*!5{- !7k"-( =) /" X(""w
R 'W Room 13 w & W( (~ ~ ^ ^ ~ W =")" (~"~" w'^~/-tes Room 13w #~^ !#*"7&!K!Q8#R@{<<R Room 13 _"/- k~&(=)(-~/Room 13(" )~(&^" "(~/Room 13. "9W ""- ~(7"-9"X/Y[) /(~ wX''W
125 "&X^" (7="~ )"~3(^ =^w/"(-~~~'(="( _Room 13<<U<;k ~ ( " -~*Room 13W "~/ "{~&Room 13 " ~) " 7 ~&Room 13"(
W*"-(="&w7wRoom 13
re-/)""~(^ Xw"(
7Room 13
=~"X-126 "~9~/X X/&(" ~"("&"(-("w " ( " " " X/""~"-/"W~&"WRoom 13~ (/~-~99 " ? (="w proceso de una Room 13.
Room 13 " " / ~ " " Q 8 / ~ " " ( Q " W 9 ~ W / 3Room 13^"^( ")"w""&^&& %&&"*"7&!K!Q8#R@{<<R Una Room 13/~
127 ("#(( de una Room 13W~W(? ""~ W"(=)~~ '^(=~"" (~
En una Room 13& "
X)"9) 9) "X/w X En una Room 13^ ~^(^w (( )^(-w~"~ Room 13 )^- /^-"'W/" /~&"/ /Room 13 Room 13&/ ( *(w^ w ' (&""^ (&~~&{~^"& (~Room 13 &?-w X(='~X
] ~X~ #~~^W(~Q8 / 9 99"-/)W w #&!K!Q8#R@{<<R Room 13 (" #/#&_ <<[?k?^=)~9#&~^ "/&(W ^~"Room 13"9 "97&-&"_<<[?kw?'"# ~) (N" "(( "X~Room 13 ( ~w "("_Room 13<<;<[k *&"8_NNN8kRoom 13"^ W)"X Room 13#J5~/ wX(?)"W <<]<<`( (Room 13K y siguen creciendo.
` Room 13 ") 7{5"&w_ <<[?8k?Q8 ~ Q3® != Room 13@3 8 31{/( Room 13@3 <<`7("%%
8< 1 1 150 \9\9\ "~@& H( @&73"" ~ ) " " !" "~"\9\9\ -)!(""~< 8<~)"/( ( /Q(( * &" w w?-9))""W "( &W "\]\]\ ((^/)"/-)9 (^W( ~) 9"/X -)(^ (^/ &")" ( )" & ^ ) (= " -"& =)^~9""
8 "%"!_<<!K!<<Uk ")) )/"{X /)"9 /"() }^"? ")() W Q("( Q? (" 3((^&_#Q// "" <<!K!<<Uk" &&9 (&" 9&((~^~(&(~"&&& &Xw~X"~X&& Xw w"( " !/(w"/ #9~^~ ) '~/" #=)?9&~ ! ( # "" 9"
8 (~9"/"w w "W !~9)"~ protagonista. ' ~ " ~ & #Q<<!K!<<U '("? !/"(?9"-"&9~ /)"(9 ) 7?\9\9\ -""("/) 8 ( (? 9 w ( "(^^(X( w("( R#?{-"/ X"" ) ~~"( U'~ ?9(/-/" w
88 @( !N"/"J @"/ 8@&(&¨ R@( U/( ;@ [@/ '"&( UwUwU¯"<<]? 9@&*"7&8 9~W& -" 32{/(@&*"7&@&H(<<`7(" %%
8R 678%666"6 ' _&?(N&~kW-}J#/"~ 9) " w _&?(N&~kW8<9 /"^&/"&7-(^}L ~ _@"*9=<<;k'-(/w (^") # w { % ^ L & ~ "^~-"*&"= X"~(&'"w # ( ~^ ( ~ ^"(~(/ /~"9*^ /~&&/ ~"" '/ ~^(~-&w"~ ~^ " ')&~-'((~W&!" ~(X(" ~& /~ _{ ~{%& ^}L ~k
8U
!&9W por todo
"X"( ( w " " " '( ? A _ I> ? $ A"'_I>? 9? > A"' ( ? ` _'!#k " F 0 0 " ? '( K Q_k K7 _#Q'%kK p '; 5(NQ3W9w %'+ ) ) ;<*" 3) '""/ 37#} w9 '^~w ? 7 & ( w~/"/ =" =!H{^ &'_^ =Xk ' '-((>>X~_H<<]JJ<<Uk !(>>'=& X'X'X(& ^"(7( /W(&& ~'X9!-& W"(
8; ^/9 / ~/ "X9"& ( ^/ #" ( ``]9) ~ )^w "" = ( "-~(w " decisiones. 7( H _<<]k &" ^ (~w w "&#& ``]'?( (_W(/k{-W&) " / *'= ~& " " / (^/3 Ww37#}&Q7 #'(¢# "%%/ ^ W w " / /) " X
8[ #%Q(# "# '(¢'" "~ XXH" ""W( ("#!Q}%"R<<U<<-/;U"U()[< "&~/ )( 6 # >>?& de la UNESCO ^" ')/~( W(~&W w(>>H(-&(= "-)W"~ ( " ( ' W-&"^ ```(37#}8<§7 #/5&(X' ) _H 'k / '(/&9*^ ( 9))"(
8] )9)W~'( W"( ' 37#} & ( / '/)&-(( () /( w) *"7(#/%^ _'*^=-Q{H~k"W & _3 #W<<[k *#/%'# (>>H(*(_k^;"`%)<<;-/ W<<`[((>>H(*(_k^;"`%)<<;-/ ? " '^ '/"X # / "X( (" # *(' / Q ' _37#}<<;k"(( 7(#/%'(7#^U] "<<_37#}<<k';U<`U^~ ( '3W '(7?} '~(K /" (W&
8` W/ ~<<; * ) ~' ( ' ~ " w"~X ^( ~& ^X La K /(w ' / " ) ( >>H (R^='? 5)&& " ' =~'&-~~w (-^" _-/(( k !'=?{&-"W~ ~w" "9)~ ( ("W _ " "XX ( La K / X=~'(&("&-_"k ("/ '!(X/(
R< X "/w " 7 ~ ^ "~( X "^ -/!(~'/" / ~"(-") 8% '"R-?) """/" *'(^-%W^= ()"(X/-w_k" Rw '/)-""" "W/ & X" -() * K / ' ( ? X _) k"^^9( -/("" ^/X ~ " w-& =X~w/~'~ "? 9~=
R " _ k)9)") "(^_ Xk 'K /()(? " ~ W~/ 7((('=)? / "" "(" (W'? )W) "/ W" ( ( K /('? ^"^^' / '("X/(-/9)") " ww'~() 'w=-" /~?
R '"/"' '")"= *)("""9)") "X &"w)) " *")"-)"((^( (=~'((("/ "& *K /(w'" // 99)"( " > (= W-) K /" w") ^ _"(~-k(? '(/ -=(/) ' = ? (w'~ //((^-"w)' (~( (W "
*('*-R8 ((?"9= ( "/-'"(( "( W-"9^ ' 8 ' " ~ / W ' / ( ? /" "-"'_ ' "/)"(" ("/( 'k& /)" W(" ' ~ ( W ' ( ( >> W ~ W ^~/_ k & " / -) ") ~W " _^" ( W kX"~"& ~W / " &X " /() ! '=
RR W=)) ") ( *~X" (>>H* W" )" & &(((X- ) &(((X- (~( ^&&^ /"^ %)88<<;?[< 2.3.- LA CREACIÓN ARTÍSTICA 3~"(~X'7^ *+&```? !X ) / " ^ ~ & & '(~ 9)*~& (>> & X~ (" X( (?%+/_^ k~w " _*))`]]56`[;`[8`[`"7( `[``]`#$`;Uk ^ ( _`]`8`k " & -w -w *) #)J % Q& %( ( # " K ' _ <<k **@'#K@@''/!!Ww *W 3#%W
RU w'"^( ~/X / ~ =~ wX#"-9){X=~9 w7(( &/ "( w W`;`()( 3NJ *(~ "/" k"~^( w ( w " '^ (('~( & }~7(5%"~ w/w~X-9)' "Ww-3/W&/N/ _N/"`[k~~ _ X( k? "/ 8 R?W" - /wJX"w-"_N/"`[?8k
U?"(=-R; ~9 ~&/" =_N/"`[?8Rk ;X" [ _<<Uk=~ '/w9"~ ) = {X " " ^~ ( "7?*Room 13\]\]\ / de / ""=" discapacidad. '9)" ( >>H ( () ( W' W-) *K[# *(( )X (? «Creación. >"0 ' " / # ? 8 &&! ? # ( [ ^ 7 / 8 3 " G'759^7' «9{&/(&/((w" N ~ & / / ( {& / J(
R[ /( ( (( w 8 {& ( N& (" /R{&N&&5&&N"U' (/&(N/(( {&}w/(&!"7KHHH#&#J"# *}w/<<R _' ~(w~- && & ^ ' & / ~ w8H(/ R'~~! & U3 ( (&( (k «Creación_#k/'! %§ 8' ((R' 8§ U(#)§ !(9Q'9%! `U; «Creación ' # ^= !?ª{ %%^_<<Rk!9%?5§ = (= X " "X / " "? "( '^^)= ~( "((~ " 7(( ^)? ? «Crear ! " ? * &" ~ ! ~ w / ? & ) 9 # ( ^ 8 Q ? / 7 / (
R] 5!(9'759^7' «Crear_!k#§ (H(- #Q'Q=8({W("-W& ~ 3 #Q'!} 7Q¦ #Q'!} R ( /)& =(#Q'Q(X= =-^&U#QH'Q8§"R§ !(9Q'9%! `U; «Crear _ k ~ w ( _(k/((6_(k8_-^kR#± 5$#$#7'`[8@ _Crear_k~w( _(k/(((_(k8_-^kR#k «Create7/&(?((wN& &(N/ª//&({J/( ( w _ / w( /k7/NJ8{_/QJ("k N&QJR{(_ /kU{J/(ª(_&(k {&}w/(&!"7KHHH#&#J"# *}w/<<R _Crear!^(?&~(ww &^ª//() _ /~wk8 #_((k(R#-"(_ kU ~(k & ~ w / w & / 7 ( ' )X W= =(")?
R` Xcreación = = ? _k & ( ( w / ~ & _k * ((w~/X ~&"/_8k* ( w_Rk * (w& ``?8;[ ~= &((w/~ &"* (( w~/X~&" / ~ & " " = X~/ X/(^ " ? =^= = (((-w/((W^ *^(/" (W(&# ^( =? ~ 7 ( (( '(w (^ @(_``k=~ ^-"~ W( "(/"&"~&"~ !"("w "w ~w~&"(~W( -w~) "
U< ¤ &¥ &"/ X(/" ^^ @(_``?8;]k!^=-&& ^ w* ~ ))~)~(((~ 7( +&& _ ``?8;]k= /W (^ W / ^)"/(~ & +&&~-("/ & &" ( ~ _ ``k ~()/ ' ) (^ "~{X " ((( 7@( (~"+&&&-~"&/ " " " (~( (~ '^w = / (=~ ? / / / (= X ? "
151
!X =
?
F L ' " (" 4 0& & )6 # & 9 & # " ' 0 & L& & ) */ # #)W= / ( ( ( (& X ?~X =" (=~ / '('& /w & X X ~ " ^& ^(""/ ^"~")-~" ~&X w& !/X& representación. {~~"/( "-"X*/ ( /&W~
152 " ( -W~3w _~&~~k ~&X( X^/( /W" "¤¥ " "X7W(W(~/-( {~~" (<<U?; &_&(5*``<k W&^7(~-~W(/~ ~/'(&/-~"/ ^"^ ~~(= = / &^ -~~~ ~X/ 'W / ""(^ ~XW"/( " ( & ^)=w "/ =7^ )w/ ((= &-=~^W=X
U8 !&&/w~ /?X~-&"^ &X// *(' ~w~& )"&/"* ~^WX?)&" #&^(W~ W' ~& ( ( w & * &? ^)X #XW"-() )( X X '~ wX/~X~ "^)"~^ ~/( )_&kw ~(w !"J`]]?R 7 & " /( -(W~ ~w ~((X"~= w
UR X& " ^ W/ X //^" KX'&X /^"9"W( "" / '/w& (('&) w W&'&~ ( &X( "/W// wW&/ ~^(((' / &^ W &9"/X/W/ *'X/'^ '~ 'WXW/W"-~'XX&)'w ~W" & 'W" / ")~'& / ^)WX~ " (( W " && & ~&W/
155 ?"((&& /W//&"& (=w~)" W / ( ~ ' / w~/-("~^)/ ( " ((~ X(? / /~(=W " #}'*5##_+ ;0 + k5/( -#" "~& w w " # &"^ }K(U<<` /^ (W &()/ W? . Diversidad y variabilidad ~wW ((? & "~/ ~ ~((_<<Uk9)~