Preprint of the paper:
"A General Numerical Model for Grounding Analysis in Layered Soils" I. Colominas, J. Gómez-Calviño, F. Navarrina, M. Casteleiro (2002)
V peWeiVN W=eiy]VN !*eN 3!i pi!=W*yWp
VWVNO7y7 yW NVOeie* 7!yN7
y ]BjB8$tsR F p?B89T]sj%$KtB 3 Ws%s$ts stI ]sRj$B
pWyTpBZ} BP WZ8${sj YBIR $t et$t$t
*} BP V}}j$I sY8s${R ]$%$j et$t$t 7{YBBj
=t$%R$IsI I Ns ]BZKts ]s8}ZR I ej%$Kts dxd1 7_VyW
{BjB8$tsRo${{}ZI{R
VARs{
7sPk BP }RBtR }B{$Bt BP JZ$}8t stI {Bt$tZ$k BP }Bb RZ}}jk s Y 8s$t BA`{$%R BP Y BZtI$t RkR8 BP s js j{${sj $tRsjjs$Bt 3B $R s{{Zs IR$t $ $R RRt$sj B I8$t Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt Bt Y sY RZPs{ stI Y JZ$%sjt R$Rst{ BP Y RkR8 yt Y$R }s} b }Rt s tZ8${sj s}}Bs{Y AsRI Bt Y BZtIsk ej8t 8YBI PB BZtI$t stsjkR$R $t jskI RB$jR qY PsR$A$j$k BP Y$R PB8Zjs$Bt $R I$R{ZRRI Ak 8stR BP $R s}}j${s$Bt B s sj BZtI$t RkR8 b$Y I$&t ,$tIR BP jskI RB$j 8BIjR
d ytBIZ{$Bt
7$t{ Y sjk IskR BP Y $tIZR$sj ZR BP j{${$k BAs$t$t Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt $t js j{${sj $tRsjjs$BtR bYt s PsZj {Zt $R I$%I $tB Y RB$j YBZY s BZtI$t RkR8 YsR At s {Ysjjt$t }BAj8 V XBZtI$t" B XsY$t" RkR8 {B8}$RR sjj Y $t{Btt{I BZtI$t Ps{$j$$R BP st R}{$h{ ss BP st j{${sj $tRsjjs$Bt A$t Y XBZtI$t $I" wB Y XBZtII j{BI"D Y 8s$t j8t BP YR RkR8R qYZR Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt Bt Y sY RZPs{ $R Y 8BR $8}Bst }ss8 Ys $ $R t{RRsk B ,tBb $t BI B IR$t s RsP BZtI$t RkR8
yt 8BR BP sj j{${sj RZARs$BtR Y BZtI$t $I {BtR$RR BP s 8RY BP $t{Btt{I {kj$tI${sj {BtIZ{BR YB$9Btsjjk AZ$I stI RZ}}j8tI Ak BZtI BIR %${sjjk YZRI $t {s$t }js{R BP Y RZARs$Bt R$ yR 8s$t BA`{$% $R B {sk stI I$RR$}s j{${sj {ZtR }BIZ{I IZ$t PsZj {BtI$$BtR $tB Y BZtI $t BI B tRZ Ys s }RBt $t Y %${$t$k BP Y BZtII $tRsjjs$Bt $R tB -}BRI B s {$${sj j{${sj RYB{, 3ZY8B Y }Bb RZ}}jk {Bt$tZ$k stI Y JZ$}8t $t$k 8ZR A }R%I qB ss$t YR BsjR Y s}}st j{${sj R$Rst{ BP Y BZtI$t RkR8 8ZR A jBb tBZY B Zsst Ys PsZj {ZtR I$RR$}s 8s$tjk YBZY Y BZtI$t j{BI $tB Y RB$j BB% j{${sj }Bt$sj %sjZR Abt {jBR }B$tR Bt Y sY RZPs{ wYs {st A {Btt{I Ak s }RBtD 8ZR A ,} ZtI {s$t 8s-$8Z8 RsP j$8$R wR} BZ{Y stI 8RY %BjsRD RsAj$RYI $t 8BR BP Y Z$IR stI jsj }B{IZR BP BZtI$t RkR8 IR$t >d 1H
7$t{ Y R$-$R R%sj 8YBIR stI }B{IZR PB Y BZtI$t stsjkR$R stI IR$t BP j{${sj RZARs$BtR Ys% At }B}BRI qYR 8YBIR s tsjjk AsRI Bt Y }BPRR$Btsj }s{${ Bt R8$T8}$${sj bB,R Bt -}T $8tsj Iss BAs$tI PB8 R{sj 8BIj RR B Bt $tZ$$% $IsR *BZAjRRjk YR {Bt$AZ$BtR }RtI st $8}Bst $8}B%8t $t Y BZtI$t stsjkR$R ss <Bb% RB8 }BAj8R Ys% At }BI RZ{Y sR Y js {B8}Zs$Btsj JZ$8tR Y Ztsj$R${ RZjR BAs$tI bYt Y R8ts$Bt BP {BtIZ{BR $R $t{sRI stI Y Zt{s$tk $t Y 8s$t BP B >d nH
sj }BAj8R !t Y BY YstI Y {Yss{$R${ B8k BP BZtI$t RkR8R ws 8RY BP $t{Btt{I As {BtIZ{BR b$Y s js$%jk R8sjj s$B I$s8TjtYD 8s,R %k I$^{Zj Y ZR BP tZ8${sj 8YBIR qYZR Y ZR BP {Yt$JZR {B88Btjk s}}j$I PB RBj%$t ABZtIsk %sjZ }BAj8R RZ{Y sR ht$ j8tR B ht$ I$&t{R $R -8jk {BRjk R$t{ Y I$R{$9s$Bt BP Y IB8s$t wY BZtI -{jZI$t Y j{BID $R JZ$I qYPB BAs$t$t RZ^{$tjk s{{Zs RZjR RYBZjI $8}jk Zts{{}sAj {B8}Z$t &BR $t 88Bk RBs stI ]_= $8
3B sjj YR sRBtR $t Y jsR ksR Y sZYBR Ys% }B}BRI s tZ8${sj s}}Bs{Y AsRI Bt Y stRPB8s$Bt BP Y I$&t$sj JZs$BtR Ys B%t Y }YkR${sj }YtB8ts BtB st JZ$%sjt ABZtIsk $tsj JZs$Bt stI Y RZARJZt s}}j${s$Bt BP Y BZtIsk ej8t YBI ptsjjk R}s,$t ABZtIsk j8t s}}Bs{YR s AsRI Rt$sjjk $t Y Rs8 $t}Bjs$Bt {Bt{}R wYs $R Y 8RY$t BP Y IB8s$t stI Y ZR BP RYs} PZt{$BtRD $t$$sjjk I%jB}I PB Y 3$t$ ej8t YBI >;H qY e YsR $R Rs8 sI%stsR {Bt{t$t tsj$k stI 4-$A$j$k $t Y RBjZ$Bt BP }BAj8R $t t$t$t s}}j${s$BtR AZ $t {BtsR b$Y ht$ j8tR Y e s}}B-$8s$BtR s 8sI Btjk Bt Y ABZtIsk BP Y IB8s$t >x E H
qY ABZtIsk j8t PB8Zjs$Bt }B}BRI PB Y sZYBR PB Y stsjkR$R BP BZtI$t RkR8R 8AIII $t Zt$PB8 RB$jR 8BIjR >M H {st A RsI $t Y tsj Ps8bB, BP Y Rk88${ psj,$t ABZtIsk j8t s}}Bs{YR >d( dd d1H qYZR Y Rs8t BP s %s$s$Btsj PB8 AsRI Bt s b$YITR$IZsj s}}Bs{Y BP Y ABZtIsk $tsj JZs$Bt stI Y Rj{$Bt BP s psj,$t k} b$Y$t jsI B s tsj Rk88${ PB8Zjs$Bt PB8 $ $R }BRR$Aj B I$% R}{$h{ tZ8${sj BtR BP Y$Y s{{Zs{k >H 3ZY8B Y I%jB}8t BP Y$R e s}}Bs{Y YsR sjjBbI B -}js$t PB8 s 8sY8s${sj }B$t BP %$b Y stB8sjBZR sRk8}B${ AYs%$BZ BP Y {jsR${sj 8YBIR }B}BRI PB BZtI$t stsjk$R stI B $It$Pk $BBZRjk Y RBZ{R BP B >dnH 3$tsjjk Y$R ABZtIsk j8t s}}Bs{Y YsR At $8}j8tI $t s ]V* s}}j${s$Bt PB sY$t RkR8R>d; dxH Ys sjjBbR B stsjk9 sj BZtI$t $tRsjjs$BtR $t sjT$8 ZR$t b$IR}sI }RBtsj {B8}ZR
yt Y$R }s} b }Rt s tsj$9s$Bt BP Y ABZtIsk j8t PB8Zjs$Bt PB BZtI$t $IR 8AIII $t jskI RB$jR Bt Y AsR$R BP Y tZ8${sj s}}Bs{Y }B}BRI PB Zt$PB8 RB$j 8BIjR 3ZY8B st s}}j${s$Bt B R%sj }s{${sj {sRR Ak ZR$t Y B8k BP s sj sY$t RkR8 $R }RtI
1 sY8s${sj BIj BP Y _BAj8
1d pB%t$t eJZs$BtR
VR b Ys% RsI $t Y $tBIZ{$Bt Y JZs$BtR Ys B%t Y I$RR$}s$Bt BP j{${sj {ZtR $tB Y BZtI YBZY s BZtII j{BI {st A I$%I PB8 s-bjj:R ej{B8st${ qYBk qYZR R${$t Y stsjkR$R B Y j{B,$t${ RsIkTRs R}BtR stI tj{$t Y $tt R$R$%$k BP Y sY$t {BtIZ{BR w}Bt$sj $R sRRZ8I {BtRst s %k }B$t BP Y BZtI$t j{BI RZPs{D Y n* }BAj8 {st A b$t sR
I$%wD ) (, )sIsIwsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsI ~D $to
0zzzzzzzzzzzzzz
o) ( $t o ~ )~ $t ~ (, $P/??????????????/ wdD
bY o $R Y sY $R $R {BtIZ{$%$k tRB o $R Y sY RZPs{zzzzzzzzzzzzzzo $R $R tB8sj -$B Zt$ hjI stI $R
Y j{BI RZPs{ >H
qYPB bYt Y BZtII j{BI ss$tR s %Bjs~wpBZtI _Bt$sj i$R B p_iD js$% B 8B sY
Y RBjZ$Bt B }BAj8 wdD $%R Y }Bt$sj~ stI Y {Zt ItR$ks st sA$sk }B$t?????????????? qYt $ $R }BRR$Aj B BAs$t Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt Bt Y sY RZPs{ wstI {BtRJZtjk Y R} 8RY stI BZ{Y %BjsR BP Y
sY$t RkR8D sR 8Z{Y sR Y Bsj RZ {Zt stI Y JZ$%sjt R$Rst{ Ak 8stR BP Y {Zt ItR$k Bt
>d 1H !t Y BY YstI R$t{~ stI s }B}B$Btsj B Y p_i %sjZ $ b$jj A ZRI Y tB8sj$9I ABZtIsk
{BtI$$Bt~) d PB8 Y Bt
yt 8stk BP Y 8YBIR stI YB${sj }B{IZR }B}BRI PB BZtI$t stsjkR$R Y RB$j $R {B88Btjk {BtR$II
YB8BtBZR stI $RBB}${ qYt {BtIZ{$%$k $R RZAR$ZI Ak st s}}st R{sjs {BtIZ{$%$k Ys 8ZR A
y $R BA%$BZR Ys s,$t $tB s{{BZt sjj %s$s$BtR BP RB$j {BtIZ{$%$k bBZjI t% A s&BIsAj t$Y PB8 Y {BtB8${sj tB PB8 Y {Yt${sj }B$t BP %$b 3B Y$R sRBt s 8B }s{${sj RB$j 8BIj {BtR$RR BP sRRZ8$t Y RB$j Rs$hI $t s tZ8A BP YB$9Btsj B %${sj jskR IhtI Ak st s}}B}$s Y${,tRR stI st s}}st R{sjs {BtIZ{$%$k Ys 8ZR A -}$8tsjjk BAs$tI yt Ps{ $ $R b$Ijk s{{}I Ys bBTjsk RB$j 8BIjR RYBZjI A RZ^{$t B BAs$t BBI stI RsP IR$tR BP BZtI$t RkR8R $t 8BR }s{${sj {sRR>dH qY$R }s} $R I%BI B RZIk$t Y s}}j${s$Bt BP tZ8${sj 8YBIR PB BZtI$t stsjkR$R $t Rs$hI RB$j 8BIjR R}{$sjjk $t {sRR b$Y bB I$&t YB$9Btsj B %${sj jskR whZR d stI 1D
g
12
g
3$Z d 7{Y8 BP s RB$j 8BIj b$Y bB YB$9Btsj jskR
g
2g
13$Z 1 7{Y8 BP s RB$j 8BIj b$Y bB %${sj jskR
qYPB $t Y Yk}BYR$R BP s Rs$hI RB$j 8BIj PB8I AkUjskR b$Y I$&t {BtIZ{$%$$R A$t Y BZtII
j{BI AZ$I $t Y jskK Y 8sY8s${sj }BAj8 wdD {st A b$t $t 8R BP Y PBjjBb$t WZ8stt -$B
}BAj8>dMH
I$%wD ) (, )sIsIwsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsIsI~D $to, dU
0
ezzzzzzzzzzzzzzo) ( $t o, ~K) d $t
~( $P /??????????????/ , 0zzzzzzzzzzzzzz )Ld0 zzzzzzzzzzzzzz $t , dUd w1D
bYo $R s{Y Bt BP Y RB$j jskR $R $R R{sjs {BtIZ{$%$k~ $R Y }Bt$sj s st sA$sk }B$t $t Y jsk o $R $R {BR}BtI$t {Zt ItR$k $R Y $tPs{ Abt jskRo stIoLd stIzzzzzzzzzzzzzz $R Y tB8sj hjI
B >dMH
11 ytsj e-}RR$Bt PB _Bt$sj
~BR BP BZtI$t RkR8R BP sj j{${sj RZARs$BtR {BtR$R BP s $I BP $t{Btt{I As {kj$tI${sj {BtIZ{BR YB$9Btsjjk AZ$I stI RZ}}j8tI Ak BIR A$t Y s$B Abt Y I$s8 stI Y jtY BP Y {BtIZ{BR
js$%jk R8sjj w d(nD qY$R s}}stjk R$8}j B8k $8}j$R R$BZR I$^{Zj$R $t Y 8BIjj$9s$Bt BP Y
}BAj8 qYZR $ R8R BA%$BZR Ys tB stsjk${sj RBjZ$BtR {st A BAs$tI $t 8BR BP sj {sRR !t Y BY YstI Y ZR BP b$IR}sI tZ8${sj {Yt$JZR wRZ{Y sR 3e B 3*D RYBZjI $t%Bj% s {B8}jjk BZ BP st
{B8}Z$t &B R$t{ $ $R JZ$I Y I$R{$9s$Bt BP Y n* IB8s$tR o w-{jZI$t Y BZtI$t j{BID 3B
YR sRBtR b Ys% ZtI BZ st$Bt B BY tZ8${sj {Yt$JZR bY${Y JZ$ Btjk Y I$R{$9s$Bt BP Y
ABZtIs$R G$Y Y$R s$8 $ $R RRt$sj B I$% st $tsj -}RR$Bt PB }Bt$sj~ $t 8R BP Zt,tBbtR IhtI
*Z$t Y {BtRZ{$Bt }B{RR BP Y j{${sj $tRsjjs$Bt Y RZBZtI$tR BP Y RZARs$Bt R$ s j%jjI stI
Zjs$9I qYZR Y sY RZPs{ o stI Y $tPs{R Abt jskR {st A sRRZ8I YB$9Btsj {BtRJZtjk
b b$jj sIB} st XYB$9Btsjjk jskI RB$j 8BIj" $t BZ 8sY8s${sj 8BIj $t BI B {s{Y Y %s$s$BtR BP Y RB$j {BtIZ{$%$k b$Y I}Y whZ dD yt Y {sR BP %s$s$BtR BP Y RB$j {BtIZ{$%$k ts Y BZtI$t RkR8
Y R$8}jR 8BIj b {st Rs ws X%${sjjk jskI RB$j 8BIj"D {BtR$R BP sRZ8$t Ys Y sY RZPs{ o $R
YB$9Btsj bY$j Y $tPs{R s }ssjjj Bt B stBY stI }}tI${Zjs B o whZ 1D
qYZR s,$t $tB s{{BZt YR sRRZ8}$BtR Y s}}j${s$Bt BP Y X8YBI BP $8sR" stI pt:R yIt$k B }BAj8 w1D k$jIR Y PBjjBb$t $tsj -}RR$Bt >dE d dMH PB }Bt$sj ~w??????????????D s st sA$sk }B$t?????????????? ;o $t 8R BP
Y Zt,tBbt js,s {Zt ItR$kwD w )0zzzzzzzzzzzzzz bYzzzzzzzzzzzzzz$R Y tB8sj -$B Zt$ hjI B D s stk }B$t BP
Y j{BI RZPs{ 2oKU
~w??????????????D ) ;$Kd 8 8
;>Kw??????????????, DwDQ, ??????????????;o3 wnD
qYs $R Y }Bt$sj s }B$t ?????????????? IZ B s BZtII j{BI AZ$I $t Y jskK $R Y $tsj B% sjj }B$tR Bt
Y j{BI RZPs{ BP Y js,s {Zt ItR$k Ys 4BbR PB8 s{Y }B$t; b$YI Ak Y pt PZt{$Bt
>Kw??????????????, D qYR $tsj ,tjR s PB8I Ak R$R BP $tht$ 8R {BR}BtI$t B Y RZjst $8sR BAs$tI
bYt WZ8stt -$B }BAj8 w1D $R stRPB8I $tB s I${ $tsj }Rts$Bt > dMH *}tI$t Bt Y k} BP Y RB$j 8BIj YR R$R {st Ys% st $tht$ B s ht$ tZ8A BP 8R >dH yt Y {sR BP Zt$PB8 RB$j wU) dD Yk s IZ{I B Btjk bB RZ88stIR R$t{ Y $R Btjk Bt $8s BP Y B$$tsj $I >M HU
>ddw??????????????d, D ) w d
??????????????d,>?, r, FHDL
d
w??????????????d,>?, r,FHD, w;D
bYw??????????????d,>?, r, FHD $tI${sR Y I$Rst{ PB8??????????????dB#>?, r, FH A$t >?, r,FH Y Rk88${ }B$t BPb$Y
R}{ B Y sY RZPs{ o G sRRZ8 Ys Y B$$t BP Y {BBI$tsR RkR8 $R Bt Y sY RZPs{ stI Y
FTs-$R $R }}tI${Zjs B o
yt Y {sR BP s %${sj bBTjskI 8BIj whZ 1D Y R$R BP Y ,tjR s sjRB IZ{I B s ht$ tZ8A BP 8RU
>ddw??????????????d, D ) w??????????????d,>d
?, r, FHD L
d
w??????????????d,>?, r,FHD L
w??????????????d,>?,r, FHD L
w??????????????d,>?,r,FHD >d1w??????????????1, D ) w??????????????1,d L>
?, r, FHD L
d L
w??????????????1,>?, r,FHD wxD
bY w??????????????,>?, r, FHD $tI${sR Y I$Rst{ PB8 ?????????????? B qY BY 8R {BR}BtI B Y I$Rst{R PB8 ?????????????? B
Y Rk88${ }B$t BP b$Y R}{ B Y sY RZPs{ o stI B Y RZjst $8sR b$Y R}{ B Y %${sj
$tPs{ G sRRZ8 ss$t Ys Y B$$t BP Y {BBI$tsR RkR8 $R Bt Y sY RZPs{ stI Bt Y %${sj $tPs{
stI Y FTs-$R stI rTs-$R s }}tI${Zjs B o stI d R}{$%jk ]B^{$t$R s s$B IhtI $t 8R BP Y
jsk {BtIZ{$%$$R
) d 1
dL13 wED
yt Y {sR BP st YB$9Btsj bBTjskI RB$j 8BIj whZ dD Y -}RR$BtR BP Y $tsj ,tjR >d 1(H s $%t Ak
>ddw??????????????d, D )3
7)(
7
w??????????????d,>?, r,17I LFHDL
3
7)(
7
w??????????????d,>?, r,17IFHD
L3
7)d
7
w??????????????d,>?, r,17ILFHD L 3
7)d
7
w??????????????d,>?, r,17IFHD
>d1w??????????????1, D ) 3
7)(
wd LD7
w??????????????1,>?, r,17ILFHDL 3
7)(
wd LD7
w??????????????1,>?, r,17IFHD
>1dw??????????????d, D ) 3
7)(
wdD7
w??????????????d,>?, r,17ILFHDL
3
7)(
wdD7
w??????????????d,>?, r,17IFHD
>11w??????????????1, D ) w d
??????????????1,>?, r, FHD
w??????????????1,>?, r,1ILFHDL 3
7)(
wd1D7
w??????????????1,>?, r,17ILFHD3 wD
yt Y sAB% -}RR$BtRw??????????????,>?, r, FHD $tI${sR Y I$Rst{ PB8??????????????B qY BY 8R {BR}BtI B Y I$Rst{R
PB8 ??????????????B Y Rk88${ }B$t BP b$Y R}{ B Y sY RZPs{ o stI B Y $tPs{ RZPs{ Abt jskR
I $R Y Y${,tRR BP Y Z}} jsk stI $R $%t Ak wED G sRRZ8 Bt{ 8B Ys Y B$$t BP Y {BBI$tsR
VR b {st BAR% $t -}RR$BtR w;D wxD stI wD bs,jk R$tZjs ,tjR >Kw??????????????, D I}tI Bt Y {BtIZ{$%$k BP Y jskR stI Bt Y $t%R BP Y I$Rst{R PB8 Y }B$t?????????????? B Y }B$tstI B sjj Y $8sR BP b$Y R}{ B Y
sY RZPs{ o stI B Y $tPs{R Abt jskR >dM dH 3B Zt$PB8 stI bBTjsk RB$j 8BIjR YR ,tjR
{st A -}RRI $t Y tsj PB8U
>Kw??????????????, D )
q>
3
q)( >q
Kw??????????????, D, >qKw??????????????, D ) qwD
w??????????????, qwDD, wMD
bY q $R s b$Y$t {B^{$t Ys I}tIR Btjk Bt Y s$B IhtI Ak wED stI w??????????????, qwDD $R Y eZ{j$Ist
I$Rst{ Abt Y }B$tR?????????????? stIq A$t + Y }B$t Bt Y j{BI RZPs{ w+wD )D stI A$tq wq W) (D
Y $8sR BP b$Y R}{ B Y sY RZPs{ stI B Y $tPs{R Abt jskR >dMH 3$tsjjk q> $R Y tZ8A BP
RZ88stIR $t Y R$R BP $tsj ,tjR stI $ I}tIR Bt Y {sR A$t stsjk9I wR w;D wxD stI wDD
1n zs$s$Btsj 3B8BP Y _BAj8
qY $tsj -}RR$Bt PB Y }Bt$sj wnD $R sjRB Rs$RhI Bt Y j{BI RZPs{ > H bY Y }Bt$sj %sjZ
$R ,tBbt Ak Y ABZtIsk {BtI$$Bt ~KwD ) d ; ]BtRJZtjk Y js,s {Zt ItR$k 8ZR %$Pk Y
PBjjBb$t 3IYBj8 $tsj JZs$Bt BP Y hR ,$tI Bt d
;$K 88
;>KKw, DwDQ ) d, ;3 wD
y $R $8}Bst B 8s, Ys BAs$t$t Y js,s {Zt ItR$k PB8 wD $R Y ,k B RBj% Y }BAj8 R$t{
Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt }BIZ{I bYt s PsZj {Zt $R I$%I YBZY Y BZtI$t $I {st A sR$jk BAs$tI
Ak 8stR BP -}RR$Bt wnD }B%$II Ys Y %sjZ BP$R ,tBbt 3ZY8B 8BR BP Y 8s$t$t RsPk stI IR$t
}ss8R wRZ{Y sR Y JZ$%sjt R$Rst{ stI Y Bsj RZ {ZtD {st sjRB A I${jk {B8}ZI $t 8R BP
>H
qY sAB% JZs$Bt {st A b$t $t s %s$s$Btsj PB8 $P Bt $8}BRR Ys wD $R %$hI $t Y RtR BP b$YI R$IZsjR $ Y PBjjBb$t $tsj $It$k
88
;jwD
X
d ;$K
88
;>KKw, DwDQd ~
Q ) (, wd(D
8ZR YBjI PB sjj 88ARjwD BP s RZ$sAj {jsRR BP R PZt{$BtR IhtI Bt >M H WBb $ $R {js Ys s tZ8${sj s}}Bs{Y AsRI Bt Y BZtIsk ej8t YBI R8R B A Y AR {YB${ B RBj% JZs$Bt wd(D stI B BAs$t Y js,s {Zt ItR$k R$t{ $R RBjZ$Bt Btjk JZ$R Y I$R{$9s$Bt BP Y RZPs{ BP Y {kj$tI${sj {BtIZ{BR
n e WZ8${sj 3B8Zjs$Bt
nd ptsj 1* s}}Bs{Y
qY js,s {Zt ItR$k stI Y j{BI RZPs{ {st A I$R{$9I sR
wD )3[
7)d
7]7wD, ) &
)d
, wddD
PB s $%t R BP[ $sj PZt{$BtR\]7wDiIhtI Bt stI s $%t R BP&bB I$8tR$Btsj ABZtIsk j8tR\i
W- Y $tsj -}RR$Bt wnD PB Y }Bt$sj~w??????????????D {st sjRB A I$R{$9I sR
~w??????????????D ) [ 3
7)d
7~,7w??????????????D ~,7w??????????????D ) & 3 )d q~ 3 q)( ~q
,7w??????????????D wd1D
~q
,7w??????????????D );$d K
88
;>
q
Kw??????????????, D]7wDQ wdnD
bY q~ }RtR Y tZ8A BP RZ88stIR B {BtR$I $t Y %sjZs$Bt BP Y R$R BP ,tjR Zt$j {Bt%t{ $R
!t Y BY YstI PB s $%t R BP[ R PZt{$BtR\jiwDiIhtI Bt Y %s$s$Btsj PB8 wd(D $R IZ{I B Y j$ts RkR8 BP JZs$BtRU
[ 3
7)d
pi77)"i wi) d, 3 3 3 ,[D
pi7) & 3 #)d & 3 )d qp 3 q)(
p#qi7 , "i ) & 3
#)d "#i,
wd;D
A$t
p#q
i7 ) ;$Kd 88
;#jiwD
88
;>
q
KKw, D]7wDQQ#, wdxD
"i#)
88
;#jiwDQ
#, wdED
bY qp }RtR Y tZ8A BP RZ88stIR B {BtR$I $t Y %sjZs$Bt BP Y R$R BP ,tjR Zt$j {Bt%t{ $R
s{Y$%I wqp)q>$P Y$R tZ8A $R ht$D
7BjZ$Bt BP Y j$ts RkR8 wd;D }B%$IR Y %sjZR BP Y {Zt ItR$$R7 w7) d, 3 3 3 ,[D js,$t PB8 Y tBIR
BP Y $I <Bb% Y Rs8t BP Y$R RkR8 JZ$R Y I$R{$9s$Bt BP s 1* IB8s$t wY bYBj RZPs{ BP Y BZtII j{BIRD BB% Y {BR}BtI$t 8s$- $R PZjj stI B {B8}Z $R {B^{$tR Bt 8ZR }PB8 IBZAj $ts$Bt Bt 1* IB8s$tR qYR Ps{R $8}jk s js tZ8A BP IR BP PIB8 stI st Zts&BIsAj {B8}Z$t JZ$8tR $t Y stsjkR$R BP }s{${sj {sRR 3B sjj YR sRBtR $ $R t{RRsk B $tBIZ{ RB8 sII$$Btsj Yk}BYRR $t BI B I{sR Y {B8}Zs$Btsj {BR>H
n1 V}}B-$8sI e s}}Bs{Y stI ^{$t{k BP Y tZ8${sj R{Y8
VR b Ys% }%$BZRjk 8t$BtI BZtI$t $IR BP 8BR j{${sj $tRsjjs$BtR s PB8I Ak s 8RY BP {BtIZ{BR
bY${Y s$B I$s8\jtY $R %k R8sjj wd(nD *Z B Y$R R}{$h{ B8k Y Yk}BYR$R BP {${Z8Pt$sj
Zt$PB8$k {st A $tBIZ{I>d H yt Y$R bsk Y js,s {Zt ItR$k $R sRRZ8I {BtRst sBZtI Y {BRR
R{$Bt BP Y {kj$tI${sj {BtIZ{BR BP Y BZtI$t $I stI I$R{$9s$BtR wddD stI wd;D A{B8 8Z{Y R$8}j R$t{ Y {jsRRR BP R stI $sj PZt{$BtR s R${I B YBR b$Y {${Z8Pt$sj Zt$PB8$k bY$j Btjk Y s-$sj j$tR BP Y BZtI$t j{BIR Ys% B A I$R{$9I >H ]BtRJZtjk $t {B8}s$RBt b$Y Y tsj 1* ABZtIsk j8t PB8Zjs$Bt Y tZ8A BP j8tsj {Bt$AZ$BtRp#i7 stI"i# tII B Rs Y RkR8 BP j$ts JZs$BtR
wd;D stI Y tZ8A BP Zt,tBbtR7 s tBb R$t$h{stjk R8sjj PB s $%t j%j BP 8RY ht8t
yt R}$ BP Y $8}Bst IZ{$Bt $t Y {B8}Zs$Btsj {BR -tR$% {B8}Z$t $R R$jj t{RRsk 8s$tjk A{sZR BP Y {${Z8Pt$sj $ts$Bt Bt Y }$8 BP Y j{BIR Ys s $t%Bj%I $t Y $tsj ,tjR yt }%$BZR bB,R b Ys% }B}BRI Y s}}B-$8sI %sjZs$Bt BP YR {${Z8Pt$sj $tsjR Ak ZR$t R}{$h{ JZsIsZR>H qY htsj RZj $R st s}}B-$8sI d* s}}Bs{Y R$8$js B Y }RtI $t R{$Bt nd bY {B8}Z$t Y {B^{$tR BP Y JZs$BtR RkR8 Btjk JZ$R $ts$Bt Bt d* IB8s$tR $ Y s-$sj j$tR BP Y j{BIR>dMH
WBb R}{$h{ tZ8${sj s}}Bs{YR {st A I$%I PB I$&t Rj{$BtR BP Y RR BP $sj stI R PZt{$BtR w _B$t ]BjjB{s$Bt B psj,$t R{Y8RD 3ZY I$R{ZRR$Bt $t Y$R }s} $R R${I B Y {sR BP s psj,$t k} s}}Bs{Y bY Y 8s$- BP {B^{$tR $R Rk88${ stI }BR$$% Iht$>H qY sZYBR Ys% I$%I s Y$Yjk ^{$t stsjk${sj {Yt$JZ B %sjZs Y {B^{$tR BP Y j$ts RkR8 BP JZs$BtR>H PB _B$t ]BjjB{s$Bt stI
psj,$t k} b$Y$t $t Zt$PB8 RB$j 8BIjR 7$t{ Y d* s}}B-$8sI -}RR$BtR PB Y 8R~q
,7 stIp#qi7 $t
wdnD stI wdxD s PB8sjjk JZ$%sjt B YBR BAs$tI $t Y {sR BP Zt$PB8 RB$j 8BIjR Y$ {B8}Zs$Bt {st sjRB A }PB8I stsjk${sjjk Ak 8stR BP Y sAB% 8t$BtI {Yt$JZR >dMH
qY$R sR}{ BP Y tZ8${sj s}}Bs{Y $R Y ,k PB $R tsj$9s$Bt PB stk jskI RB$jR 7$t{ Y $tsj ,tjR
s -}RRI $t Y tsj PB8 $%t Ak wMD Y {Bh{$tR BP Y R$&tRR 8s$- pi7 s {B8}ZI Ak Y IBZAj
RZ8 $t Y&j8tR BP Y R$R BP qp 8Rp#qi7 IhtI Ak wdxD VtI YR 8R {st A {B8}ZI Ak ZR$t Y
Y$Y ^{$t stsjk${sj {Yt$JZR I%jB}I PB Y Zt$PB8 RB$j {sRR >H
!P {BZR st $8}Bst sR}{ BP Y }B}BRI tZ8${sj PB8Zjs$Bt 8ZR A {BtR$IU Y {BR}BtI$t Bsj
{B8}Zs$Btsj {BR yt BZ {sR PB s $%t R}{$h{ I$R{$9s$Bt w&j8tR BP tBIR s{Y stI s Bsj tZ8A
BP [ IR BP PIB8D s j$ts RkR8 wd;D BP BI [ 8ZR A tsI stI RBj%I s$- ts$Bt }B{RR
JZ$R 5w&11b1D B}s$BtR R$t{ 1 R$R BP {Bt$AZ$BtR BP k} wd(D Ys% B A {B8}ZI PB %k }s$ BP
PB8I Ak Btjk bB 8R <Bb% $t bBTjsk 8BIjR Y R$R {st Ys% st $tht$ tZ8A BP Y8 qYPB s RZ^{$t tZ8A BP YR 8R 8ZR A tZ8${sjjk sIII Z} Zt$j s Bjst{ {BtI$$Bt $R PZjhjjI B st Z}} j$8$ BP RZ88stIR $R s{Y$%I ]BtRJZtjk 8s$- ts$Bt RYBZjI A 8Z{Y 8B -}tR$% $t bBTjsk 8BIjR
!t Y BY YstI R$t{ Y 8s$- $R Rk88${ AZ tB R}sR Y RkR8 RBj%$t }B{RR JZ$R5w[nbnD B}s$BtR
$P Y RBjZ$Bt $R {s$I BZ b$Y s I${ 8YBI
<t{ 8BR BP Y {B8}Z$t &B $R I%BI B 8s$- ts$Bt $t R8sjj\8I$Z8 }BAj8R bY$j j$ts RkR8 RBjZ$Bt RYBZjI }%s$j $t 8I$Z8\js BtR yt YR {sRR Y ZR BP I${ 8YBIR PB Y j$ts RkR8 RBjZ$Bt $R BZ BP st qYPB $s$% B R8$$s$% {Yt$JZR b$jj A }PsAj >1dH qY AR RZjR Ys% At BAs$tI Ak s I$sBtsj _{BtI$$BtI ]Bt`Zs psI$t sjB$Y8 >11H b$Y sRR8Ajk BP Y jBAsj 8s$- >H qY$R {Yt$JZ YsR ZtI BZ B A -8jk ^{$t PB RBj%$t js R{sj }BAj8R b$Y s %k jBb {B8}Zs$Btsj {BR $t {B8}s$RBt b$Y Y {BR}BtI$t B 8s$- ts$Bt qY sRBt PB Y$R 8s,sAj ^{t{k 8ZR A RBZY PB $t Y YB${sj {Bt%t{ AYs%$BZ BP Y {Bt`Zs sI$t 8YBI $t js$Bt b$Y Y {BtI$$Bt tZ8A BP Y }BAj8 >d( 11H
qsAj d sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U ptsj ]Yss{$R${R sjs$IBR yy ]Yss{$R${R
s- p$I *$8tR$BtRU Edd 8d 8
p$I *}YU (M( 8
WZ8A BP p$I ej{BIRU d(
WZ8A BP z${sj iBIRU E
ej{BI *$s8U dd1M 88
z${sj iBI *$s8U d;(( 88
z${sj iBI NtYU dx 8
pBZtI _Bt$sj i$R wp_iDU d( ,z
y
(61.1,79.1)
x
(0,0)3$Z n sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U _jst BP Y BZtI$t $I w%${sj BIR s 8s,I b$Y Ajs{, }B$tRD
!t Y BY YstI Bt{ Y js,s {Zt YsR At BAs$tI Y {BR BP {B8}Z$t Y JZ$%sjt R$Rst{ $R tj$$Aj qY sII$$Btsj {BR BP {B8}Z$t }Bt$sj s stk $%t }B$t wtB8sjjk Bt Y sY RZPs{D Ak 8stR
BP wd1D Btjk JZ$R 5w&D B}s$BtR R$t{ {Bt$AZ$BtR BP k} wdnD Ys% B A {B8}ZI PB %k j8t
<Bb% {B8}Z$t $8 8sk A $8}Bst $P $ $R t{RRsk B {B8}Z }Bt$sjR s s js tZ8A BP }B$tR PB -s8}j B Isb {BtBZ j$tR $t s -tR ss BP Y BZtI$t R$
-20.00 0.00 20.00 40.00 60.00 80.00 X (m.) -20.00
0.00 20.00 40.00 60.00 80.00 100.00 Y (m.)
3$Z ; sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U _Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt wd(,zD Bt Y sY RZPs{ BAs$tI Ak ZR$t s Zt$PB8
RB$j 8BIj w8BIj VD
; V}}j${s$Bt BP Y tZ8${sj s}}Bs{Y B }s{${sj {sRR
;d *R{$}$Bt BP Y sY$t RkR8
qY }B}BRI tZ8${sj s}}Bs{Y AsRI Bt Y BZtIsk ej8t YBI YsR At $8}j8tI $t s ]B8}Z V$II *R$t RkR8 PB sY$t stsjkR$R >d;H yt Y$R R{$Bt b b$jj }Rt RZjR BAs$tI b$Y I$&t k} BP RB$j 8BIjR Ak ZR$t Y sj B8k BP s BZtI$t $IU Y sjs$IBR yy RZARs$Bt {jBR B Y {$k BP z$B $t 7}s$t
qY sY$t RkR8 BP Y$R RZARs$Bt $R s $I BP d( {kj$tI${sj {BtIZ{BR wI$s8U dd1M 88D AZ$I B s I}Y BP M( {8 RZ}}j8tI b$Y E %${sj BIR ws{Y Bt YsR s jtY BP dx 8 stI s I$s8 BP d;( 88D qY Bsj
RZPs{ }B{I $R sABZ ;M(( 81 qY Bsj ss RZI$I $R s {stj BP dx( 8 Ak d;( 8 w$ s RZPs{ sABZ PBZ
$8R js Yst Y BZtI$t $ID qY pBZtI _Bt$sj i$R {BtR$II $t Y$R RZIk YsR At d( ,z qY }jst BP Y BZtI$t $I $R }RtI $t hZ n stI s RZ88sk BP Y {Yss{$R${R BP Y RkR8 $R $%t $t sAj d
qsAj 1 sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U ]Yss{$R${R BP Y WZ8${sj BIj e WZ8${sj BIj
qk} BP V}}Bs{YU psj,$t
qk} BP ]Zt *tR$k ej8tU N$ts
WZ8A BP ej8tRU 1;d
*R BP 3IB8U 1(M
;1 iRZjR BAs$tI Ak ZR$t I$&t RB$j 8BIjR
-20.00 0.00 20.00 40.00 60.00 80.00 X (m.) -20.00
0.00 20.00 40.00 60.00 80.00 100.00 Y (m.)
3$Z x sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U _Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt wd( ,zD Bt Y sY RZPs{ BAs$tI Ak ZR$t st
YB$9Btsj bBTjsk RB$j 8BIj w8BIj D
qsAj n sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U WZ8${sj RZjR PB Y I$&t RB$j 8BIjR 7B$j BIjR
V ]
eJZ$% iR$Rst{ wD (nnE MM (;;;
qBsj ]Zt w,VD 1 ddd 11x
]_= q$8 wRD 1E d(nx ;1
qY -s8}jR }RtI Ys% At }sIjk RBj%I $t{sR$t Y R8ts$Bt BP Y j{BIR V Y R{sj BP Y bYBj $I RZjR stI }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$BtR Bt Y sY RZPs{ b tB tB${sAjk $8}B%I Ak $t{sR$t R8ts$Bt VR s tsj Zj s sRBtsAj j%j BP R8ts$Bt $R RZ^{$t PB }s{${sj }Z}BRR stI $t{sR$t Y tZ8A BP j8tR b$jj tB A t{RRsk ZtjRR Y$Y s{{Zs RZjR 8ZR A BAs$tI PB s j$8$I }s BP Y bYBj sY$t RkR8 3ZY8B Y ZR BP Y$Y BI j8tR b$jj A $t tsj 8B sI%stsBZR Yst $t{sR$t R8ts$Bt $ttR$%jk R$t{ s{{Zs{k b$jj A Y$Y PB s 8s,sAjk R8sjj Bsj tZ8A BP IR BP PIB8 VtI {BtRJZtjk $ RYBZjI JZ$ s {BtR$IsAjk R8sjj {B8}Zs$Btsj &B >H
yt Y sjs$IBR yy BZtI$t RkR8 b Ys% stsjk9I Y I$&t ,$tI BP RB$j 8BIjR XBIj V" {BR}BtIR B s
Zt$PB8 RB$j 8BIj b$Y ) x(d w8Dd X8BIj " {BR}BtIR B st YB$9Btsj bBTjsk RB$j 8BIj wsR hZ dD
b$Yd ) x(d w8Dd1) x(((d w8Dd stII ) d3x 8 stI X8BIj ]" {BR}BtIR B s %${sj bBTjsk RB$j
8BIj wsR hZ 1D b$Yd) x(d w8Dd1) x(((d w8DdstI Y %${sj $t}YsR $R jB{sI s s I$Rst{ BP
d 8 PB8 Y BZtI$t $I wk ) M(3d 8- $t Y }jst BP hZ nD
3$Z ; RYBbR Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt Bt Y sY RZPs{ BAs$tI Ak ZR$t Y Zt$PB8 RB$j 8BIj V 3$ZR x stI E RYBb Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt Bt Y sY RZPs{ BAs$tI Ak ZR$t Y bBTjsk RB$j 8BIjR wYB$9BtsjD stI ] w%${sjD 3$Z $R s {B8}s$RBt BP Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt Bt Y sY RZPs{ BAs$tI b$Y 8BIjR V stI ] $t Y 9Bt bY Y {BtIZ{$%$k BP Y BZtI %s$R
qsAj 1 RZ88s$9R Y {Yss{$R${R BP Y tZ8${sj 8BIj stI qsAj n RYBbR RB8 BP Y RZjR BAs$tI $t Y Y I$&t {sRRU Y JZ$%sjt R$Rst{ BP Y BZtI$t RkR8 Y Bsj {Zt I$%I B Y RB$j stI Y ]_= $8
-20.00 0.00 20.00 40.00 60.00 80.00 X (m.) -20.00
0.00 20.00 40.00 60.00 80.00 100.00 Y (m.)
3$Z E sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U _Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt wd(,zD Bt Y sY RZPs{ BAs$tI Ak ZR$t s %${sj
bBT jsk RB$j 8BIj w8BIj ]D
{B8}Z s Y eZB}st ]t PB _ssjjj$R8 BP s{jBts ]e_ V VjYBZY Y !1((( $R s Y$YT}PB8st{ {B8}Z b$Y E; y_7 id(((( }B{RRBR s 1x( <9 Y ]_= $8R $%t $t qsAj 1 {BR}BtI B -{Z$t Y -s8}jR $t RJZt$sj 8BI $t BI B {B8}s Y {B8}Zs$Btsj {BR y $R {js Ys Y {B8}Z$t $8 {BT R}BtI$t B 8BIj $R 8Z{Y jBb bYt Y {BI $R -{ZI $t }ssjjj 8BI R$t{ Y PB8Zjs$Bt s{{}R 8sRR$% }ssjjj$9s$Bt>1nH
VR b {st R $t YR -s8}jR Y Rj{$Bt BP s RZ$sAj RB$j 8BIj $R RRt$sj B Zsst Y RsPk $t Y BZtI$t $tRsjjs$BtR R$t{ RZjR BAs$tI Ak ZR$t s 8Zj$}jTjsk RB$j 8BIj {st A tB${sAjk I$&t PB8 YBR BAs$tI Ak ZR$t s R$tj jsk wB Zt$PB8D RB$j 8BIj whZR ;xEM stI sAj nD qYPB $ {BZjI A sI%$RsAj B ZR 8Zj$Tjsk RB$j PB8Zjs$BtR B stsjk9 BZtI$t RkR8R sR s tsj Zj $t R}$ BP Y $t{sR BP Y {B8}Zs$Btsj &B yt Ps{ Y ZR BP Y$R ,$tI BP sI%st{I 8BIjR RYBZjI A 8stIsBk $t {sRR bY Y {BtIZ{$%$k BP Y RB$j {YstR 8s,Ijk b$Y I}Y B $t Y %${$t$k BP Y RZARs$Bt R$
!A%$BZRjk Y$R ABZtIsk j8t PB8Zjs$Bt {st A s}}j$I B stk BY {sR b$Y s Y$Y tZ8A BP jskR <Bb% ]_= $8 8sk $t{sR Z} B ZtsI8$R$Aj j%jR 8s$tjk IZ B Y }BB s BP {Bt%t{ BP Y ZtIjk$t R$R -}stR$BtR stI B Y tI BP %sjZs$t IBZAj R$R w$t YTjsk 8BIjRD $}j R$R w$t PBZTjsk 8BIjRD stI RB Bt
WBbsIskR bY$j R$tjTjsk 8BIjR Zt $t sj $8 $t {Bt%t$Btsj {B8}ZR PB Y stsjkR$R BP 8I$Z8\A$ R$9 BZtI$t $IR> d;H stI bBTjsk 8BIjR JZ$ s tBt tj$$Aj AZ R$jj s{{}sAj {B8}Z$t &B 8Zj$}jT jsk 8BIjR JZ$ $t tsj st BZ BP BI {B8}Z$t $8 3B Y$R sRBt b s RZIk$t Y $8}B%8t BP Y {Bt%t{ R}I BP Y R$R Ak ZR$t -s}Bjs$Bt {Yt$JZR>1;H stI Y ZR BP s{{js$Bt {Yt$JZR PB RjBbjk {Bt%t R$R >1x 1EH !t Y BY YstI b s sjRB bB,$t Bt Y }ssjjj$9s$Bt BP Y }B}BRI s}}Bs{Y R$t{ Y$R 8Zj$Tjsk e PB8Zjs$Bt {BZjI A{B8 s sjT$8 IR$t BBj $t s {jBR PZZ sR Y$YT}PB8st{ }ssjjj {B8}Z$t A{B8R s b$IR}sI s%s$jsAj RBZ{ $t t$t$t>1nH
x ]Bt{jZR$BtR
-10.00 0.00 10.00 20.00 30.00 40.00 50.00 60.00 X (m.) 60.00
65.00 70.00 75.00 80.00 85.00 Y (m.)
-10.00 0.00 10.00 20.00 30.00 40.00 50.00 60.00 X (m.)
60.00 65.00 70.00 75.00 80.00 85.00 Y (m.)
Case A, detail
Case C, detail around vertical border in y=80.1m ( =1/50 ( ·m) in South,g1 W
-1 g W -1
2=1/5000 ( ·m) in North)
3$Z sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U ]B8}s$RBt Abt Y }Bt$sj I$R$AZ$Bt wd(,zD Bt Y sY RZPs{
BAs$tI Ak ZR$t RB$j 8BIjR V stI ]wIs$j BP Y BZtI$t R$ {jBR B Y 9Bt b$Y {Yst $t Y {BtIZ{$%$kD
yt Y$R }s} b Ys% }RtI s tsj$9s$Bt BP Y$R ABZtIsk j8t s}}Bs{Y PB BZtI$t $IR 8AIII $t Rs$hI RB$jR qY }B}BRI s}}Bs{Y YsR At s}}j$I B Y stsjkR$R BP s sj sY$t RkR8 {BtR$I$t I$&t ,$tIR BP RB$j 8BIjRU Zt$PB8 RB$j RB$j b$Y bB YB$9Btsj jskR stI RB$j b$Y bB %${sj jskR qY jskI 8BIjR sjjBb B stsjk9 Y $t4Zt{ BP Y %s$s$BtR $t Y RB$j {BtIZ{$%$k b$Y I}Y stI $t Y RZBZtI$tR BP Y BZtI$t RkR8
qY RZ$sAj Rj{$Bt BP s RB$j 8BIj $R s ,k }B$t $t BZtI$t stsjkR$R G Ys% RYBbt Ys $ $R }BRR$Aj B BAs$t Y$Yjk s{{Zs RZjR b$Y Y }B}BRI ABZtIsk j8t tZ8${sj s}}Bs{Y stI YR RZjR {st A tB${sAjk I$&t I}tI$t Bt Y ,$tI BP RB$j 8BIj {BtR$II $t Y RZIk ]BtRJZtjk R$t{ Y BZtI$t RsPk }ss8R 8sk R$t$h{stjk {Yst $ {BZjI A sI%$RsAj B ZR Y 8Zj$Tjsk RB$j PB8Zjs$Bt sR s tsj Zj $t R}$ BP Y $t{sR $t Y {B8}Zs$Btsj {BR
V{,tBbjI8tR
qY$R bB, YsR At }s$sjjk RZ}}BI Ak Y X$t$R$B I ]$t{$s k q{tBjB?s w}B`{R 'd3*T(d(M stI '*_y1((dT(xxED" BP Y 7}st$RY pB%t8t {Bhtst{I b$Y 3e*ei PZtIR stI Ak Rs{Y PjjBbRY$}R BP Y XeZT B}st ]t PB _ssjjj$R8 BP s{jBts ]e_ V" Y XZts I psj${$s" stI Y X=t$%R$IsI I Ns ]BZKts"
iPt{R
>dH VW7y\yeee 7IM( yeee pZ$I PB RsPk $t V] RZARs$Bt BZtI$t Wb OB, w1(((D
>1H 7%s, Fp _BRR $t R} stI BZ{Y %Bjs JZs$BtR BP VW7y\yeee 7IM( yeee qstR Bt _Bb *j$%kdn E1uE wdD
>nH ps *N _Z$ Fp _BAj8R t{BZtI b$Y Y V_ BP stsjk9$t BZtI$t RkR8R yeee qstR Bt _Bb *j$%kd(; ;((Eu;(1n wdMxD
>;H <ZYR qFi qY 3$t$ ej8t YBI _t${ <sjj Wb FRk wdMD
>xH AA$s ]V qjjR F]3 GBAj N] BZtIsk j8t {Yt$JZR 7}$t zjs = wdM;D >EH st` _ qY BZtIsk ej8t YBI $t t$t$t { psbT<$jj NBtIBt wdxD
A
C B
A C
x y Line x = 30.0m
Line y = 79.1m
-10. 0. 10. 20. 30. 40. 50. 60. 70. 80. 90.
y (x=30.0) (m)
8.0
8.5
9.0
9.5
10.0
10.5
Potential
(kV)
-10. 0. 10. 20. 30. 40. 50. 60. 70.
x (y=79.1) (m)
8.0
8.5
9.0
9.5
10.0
10.5
Potential
(kV)
BG.P.R.=10 kV
G.P.R.=10 kV
3$Z M sjs$IBR yy pBZtI$t 7kR8U _Bt$sj }BhjR w,zD Bt Y sY RZPs{ sjBt bB j$tR PB Y Y ,$tIR BP RB$j 8BIjR WB${ Y $8}Bst I$&t{R $t Y RZjR
>MH Ws%s$ts 3 ]BjB8$tsR y ]sRj$B Vtsjk${sj $ts$Bt {Yt$JZR PB sY$t $I {B8}Zs$Bt Ak e yt XWZ8${sj YBIR $t et$t$t stI V}}j$I 7{$t{R" ddud1(E ]yWe s{jBts wd1D
>H ]BjB8$tsR y Ws%s$ts 3 ]sRj$B V ABZtIsk j8t tZ8${sj s}}Bs{Y PB BZtI$t $I {B8}Zs$Bt ]B8} Y V}} {Y et d; nT( wdD
>d(H FBYtRBt ] WZ8${sj RBjZ$Bt BP }s$sj I$&t$sj JZs$BtR Ak Y 3$t$ ej8t YBI ]s8A$I =t$% _RR ]s8A$I =7V wdMD
>ddH 7$B$ 7 s$ p WB%s$ p ${{Bj$ 7 V psj,$t Rk88${ ABZtIsk j8t 8YBI $t jsR${$kU PB8ZT js$Bt stI $8}j8ts$Bt yt F WZ8 Y et nx 1xxT1M1 wd1D
>d1H Btt s$ p _Bj$99BB ] !t Y Rk88${ psj,$t ABZtIsk j8t 8YBI V}}j {Y i% xd EET(; wdMD
>dnH Ws%s$ts 3 ]BjB8$tsR y ]sRj$B GYk IB {B8}Z 8YBIR PB BZtI$t stsjkR$R }BIZ{ stB8sjBZR RZjR2 yeee qstR Bt _Bb *j$%k w1((1D >V{{}I PB }ZAj${s$BtH
>d;H ]sRj$B <t?stI9 NV ]BjB8$tsR y stI Ws%s$ts 3 8Bk stI =R pZ$I BP RkR8 q!q e PB ]V* BP BZtI$t $IR $t j{${sj $tRsjjs$BtR ]$%$j et$t$t 7{YBBj =t$%R$IsI I Ns ]BZKts wd;D >dxH ]BjB8$tsR y Ws%s$ts 3 ]sRj$B V BZtIsk ej8t 3B8Zjs$Bt PB Y 7ZARs$Bt pBZtI$t *R$t
VI% et 7BP n( E(nu(( wdD
>dEH *ZstI e ?ej{BRs$JZ sRRBt _s$R wdEED
>dMH ]BjB8$tsR y Ws%s$ts 3 ]sRj$B V tZ8${sj PB8Zjs$Bt PB BZtI$t stsjkR$R $t Rs$hI RB$jR yeee qstR Bt _Bb *j$%k w1((dD >yt }RRH
>dH qs p3 esY R$Rst{R _$8st Wb OB, wdE;D
>1(H *sbsj$A$ 3_ ZIY,s * !}$8Z8 IR$t BP RZARs$Bt BZtI$t $t s bBTjsk sY RZ{Z yeee qstR Bt _Bb V}}ssZR stI 7kR8R ; 1x1T11 wdxD
>1dH V-jRRBt ! ys$% RBjZ$Bt 8YBIR ]s8A$I =t$% _RR ]s8A$I =7V wd;D >11H 7ssI O ys$% 8YBIR PB R}sR j$ts RkR8R =t$%R$k BP $ttRBs =7V w1(((D
>1nH ]BjB8$tsR y Ws%s$ts 3 BRJZ$s p e$Bs F ]sRj$B WZ8${sj 8BIjj$t PB BZtI$t $IR $t Y$YT}PB8s{ }ssjjj {B8}ZR BZtIsk ej8tR yy Gyq _RR 7BZYs8}Bt = w1(((D
>1;H Vt$BR F V tZ8${sj PB8Zjs$Bt PB BZtI$t stsjkR$R BP j{${sj RZARs$BtR Ak ZR$t bBTjsk RB$j 8BIjR R7{ qYRkR ]$%$j et$t$t 7{YBBj =t$%R$IsI I Ns ]BZKts wdED
>1xH $tsk8st W V,RZt y ]B8}ss$% RZIk BP s{{js$Bt {Yt$JZR PB $tsjR stI R$R $t j{B8st${ }BAj8R isI$B 7{$t{ n( ddnTd11 wdxD
